The Royals have traded away third baseman Maikel Garcia to replenish their pitching depth. While that may address the rotation, the departure of their All-Star leaves a major hole at third. For a team that also needs to address center field and perhaps left field, that’s another significant need to add to an already lengthy offseason shopping list.
Who could the Royals turn to at third base? There are several potential options available through trades or free agency, ranging from established veterans
to younger players who could fit into the team’s long-term plans.
Nick Loftin would be the next man up on the depth chart. The 28-year-old former first-round pick had a breakout season, getting an opportunity when Garcia missed time with injuries. He hit .240/.322/.388 with eight home runs in 118 games, good for a league-average OPS+ of 100. He had a solid 9.6 percent walk rate and a low 17.1 percent strikeout rate. He was not far behind Garcia for the lowest swing rate and best contact rate on the team. Loftin played all over the field, and while he had some defensive miscues at second, he was solid at third with some highlight–reel plays. He finished at +6 Defensive Runs Saved and was a Gold Glove finalist at the position.
The Royals may not see his 2026 performance as sustainable, and may prefer him in a utility role. J.J. Picollo praised Loftin for his defense, but still insisted that the trade left a “void in our offense.”
“But knowing he can play second, he can play left, he can move around gives us the flexibility to try to determine what’s the bat that we (have) to go out and try to acquire to replace the production of Maikel Garcia.”
With that in mind, the Royals may seek to look outside the organization for their next third baseman.
Free agent candidates
Alec Bohm is the name that has come up the most as a potential replacement. The Royals reportedly had interest in the Nebraska native before. The former third-overall pick had a sensational rookie season, but has had a mixed track record since then. He hit 20 home runs in 2023, and 11 more heading in to the All-Star break in 2024, where he was a participant in the Home Run Derby. But he hit just four home runs after the break, and followed it up with an 11-home run season. This year he had his lowest OPS+ since 2021, hitting .249/.315/.383 with 15 home runs, and was below replacement level according to Baseball Reference. The 30-year-old hits from the right side, which the Royals’ lineup needs, and perhaps their coaches can reenergize his bat.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. is probably the top infield free agent with MLB experience, and the Yankees may be ready to move on from him. The 28-year-old was an All-Star in 2025 with a career-high 31 home runs, but had the rare contract year regression in 2026. This year he hit .231/.312/.399 with 19 home runs, although with a career-high 41 steals. He has played mostly second base and center field in his career, but he started 73 games at third for the Yankees from 2024-25, albeit with poor results. Chisholm has a history of beefing with the Royals, and it would be ironic if he replaced Garcia, one of the players he’s had issues with. Chisholm’s upside could land him a lucrative deal, but his mental gaffes and a lackluster season may reduce demand for his services. He could end up signing a short-term deal in an effort to rebuild his market appeal.
Teruaki Sato could be one of the most intriguing options on the market, although he would also be one of the most expensive. The 27-year-old Japanese star is coming off a monster season with the Hanshin Tigers, winning the Central League Triple Crown with a .306/.383/.609 line and 39 home runs. Sato is a left-handed hitter with tremendous power, and he won a Gold Glove at third in Japan. There are some questions about how his contact rate and defense will translate to MLB, but his offensive upside is considerable. The Yankees, Mets, Dodgers and Phillies have all been linked to him, so the Royals would face some stiff competition in luring an Asian player to the Midwest. Still, if they really want to make a big splash, Sato would be the player to target.
Eugenio Suárez might be a stretch as a third baseman at this point in his career. He still has great power, adding 26 home runs last year to give him 351 in his career. But his overall hitting numbers fell to .212/.307/.433, his worst line since 2023. He rated as a poor defender at third the last few seasons, and has been playing more at DH. But he still has good pop and is just a year removed from a 52-home run All-Star season in 2025. The Royals could add him to the lineup and hide his defense by having him split time between third with Loftin and DH. But at age 35, he is in the twilight of his career, and the Royals already have one aging star they have to transition to DH.
Si-Hwan Roh is another international option for the Royals to consider, as the 25-year-old South Korean third baseman is available through the posting system this offseason. Roh spent this year with the Hanwha Eagles, where he hit .283/.360/.505 with 29 home runs in 127 games. He has been one of the KBO’s most productive power hitters in recent years, ranking second in the league with 116 home runs since 2023. The Yankees, Mariners, Phillies and Pirates have reportedly shown interest, but he is likely to command a lower deal than Sato.
Trade candidates
Brett Baty was previously connected to the Royals in trade rumors, but after career numbers in 2025, his numbers fell off sharply this year. He hit just .238/.311/.374 with 11 home runs in 143 games, although he did post good walk rates and was able to elevate the ball more than in the past. He has been unplayable against lefties, which limits his utility for the Royals. The Mets have played him all over the field, so he could benefit from sticking to one position. Baty has good power potential and is still young enough to turn things around, but he would be a risky proposition with his track record.
Nolan Gorman could end up on the free agent list if he is non-tendered by the Cardinals. The former first-round pick hit 27 home runs in 2023, but has been a major disappointment since then. He bottomed out this year, hitting just .184/.272/.308 with nine home runs in 85 games, earning a demotion to Triple-A. But the left-handed hitter is just 26 years old with several controllable years left and 30+ home run potential if he can get back on track. His defense is passable at third, and despite his struggles, he doesn’t have much of a platoon split.
Colt Keith is a 25-year-old left-handed hitter with the Tigers, who hit .258/.322/.406 with 10 home runs in 140 games this year. He hasn’t developed the power some scouts projected, but he makes consistent contact with low strikeout rates. His bat is a liability against lefties and he has had mixed results defensively at third. He has experience at second and first base as well. The Tigers have committed to him with a very club-friendly long-term deal through 2029 that includes three team options, so they may not be that inclined to move him.
Royce Lewis is also a non-tender candidate with the Twins after hitting just .227/.287/.380 with 15 home runs in 125 games. He put up solid offensive numbers early in his career, but has gotten worse each season. His defense has also been a bit mixed, and the Twins moved him to first base mid-season. Lewis is a former #1 overall pick who was a 2.4-rWAR player in 2023, but may need a change of scenery. The 27-year-old would not be eligible for free agency until 2029.
Coby Mayo may be available as the Orioles are open to revamping their roster. He emerged to hit 24 home runs in his first full season with the Orioles, with a line of .228/.297/.461 in 132 games. The 24-year-old has the right-handed bat the Royals covet with good power potential. He is a free swinger with a strikeout rate over 30 percent this year, and his defense was average. It may take a lot to acquire a player so early in his career, but the Orioles don’t seem particularly wedded to guys they drafted.
Isaac Paredes could be one of the more appealing trade targets for the Royals if the Astros are willing to move him. The 27-year-old is coming off a productive 2026 season, hitting .262/.360/.447 with 25 home runs, and was worth 4.1 rWAR. Paredes is one of the biggest pull hitters in baseball, and he actually would have hit more home runs had he played all his games at Kauffman Stadium. He had a healthy 10.8 percent walk rate and the second-lowest strikeout rate of any hitter with at least 20 home runs. He will earn $13.35 million next year before becoming a free agent, so he is a short-term rental.
Casey Schmitt had a career year with the Giants, hitting 22 home runs with a line of .271/.301/.483 before a knee injury ended his season in July. He can play all over the field, but was a solid defender at third in place of the injured Matt Chapman. With Chapman returning, the Giants could sell high on Schmitt to address pitching. The 27-year-old has several controllable years left and has shown decent offensive number prior to this year. He is also a free swinger who had the lowest walk rate in baseball among hitters with 400 plate appearances, and he could be exposed with more playing time.
Matt Shaw is another first-round pick who has had an underwhelming MLB performance so far and could be on the move. He was a 3 rWAR player in his rookie season in 2025, hitting .226/.295/.394 with 13 home runs, but missed two months this season with a hand injury. The Alex Bregman signing forced him into more of a utility role and he might be penciled in the Cubs outfield this year. But the team could look to move him in return for some pitching or catching help.
Jordan Westburg is another Orioles infielder that could be available, although he comes with some injury concerns. The right-handed hitter was an All-Star in 2024, hitting .265/.312/.481 with 18 home runs, and he followed that up with a solid 2025. But he missed all of this season after suffering a UCL tear that required Tommy John surgery. He is expected to be ready for next season, but may find playing time more difficult in a crowded Orioles infield. Baltimore may not want to “sell low” on a player, but if they are open to ideas, he could be a solid cost-controlled player for the Royals for several years.
Ben Williamson was acquired a year ago by the Rays from the Mariners, but with Junior Caminero entrenched at third, Carson Williams ready to take over at short, and Richie Palacios and Taylor Walls still in the mix, Williamson could be on the move again. The 26-year-old is a defense-first infielder, hitting just .245/.298/.314 in 581 plate appearances over the last two years. He was +8 in Defensive Runs Saved at third base for the Mariners in 2025 in limited action, while the Rays played him more at second. He has never hit for any kind of power, but he did post better walk rates in the minors.













