With 4:36 left in Northwestern’s Friday night game against No. 24 West Virginia, junior forward Kat Righeimer scored through contact, drawing a foul and converting the and-one. The Wildcats were tied with the Mountaineers at 51, looking to make their mark on the college basketball world with a completely rebuilt program.
Northwestern would only manage two more points the rest of the way.
West Virginia closed the game on a 15-2 run, with the ‘Cats turning it over seven times in the final 6:34, with four
in the last 1:42, falling 66-53 and never leading in the game.
It’s one loss, but the final minutes of the game were the clearest look at what head coach Carla Berube is trying to build in her tenure in Evanston, and what still has to be done.
After the season opener against Milwaukee, Berube described that model, based on the Golden State Valkyries. In just its second season, the franchise captured its first WNBA title, a team that includes Northwestern alum Veronica Burton. Berube said she was impressed with the team winning without “a ton of stars.”
“If you can play connected and you can play for each other and you can … just play really hard, care about the defensive side,” Berube said. “You can be really, really successful.”
She was just as direct with her team’s own expectations.
“I don’t think anybody has us winning the Big Ten or anywhere close,” she said. “But … I think that we can do some damage.”
Bart Torvik’s college basketball analytics site reflects that perception. According to its projections, the Wildcats are projected to go 10-22 overall and 2-16 in Big Ten play.
Analytics are good tools, but I don’t think a record is the best way to judge this team. The better question is how this team will grow into the foundation that Berube is trying to build. That’s what I plan to track in this column.
Berube took over the program this past March, following the retirement of Joe McKeown, who coached the Wildcats for the previous 18 seasons. After six successful seasons at Princeton, she takes over a team that has seen success… but not recently. The program hasn’t eclipsed nine wins in nearly five years and missed the Big Ten Tournament last season, finishing 8-21 overall and 2-16 in conference play.
With most of the roster gone, Berube rebuilt the team using the transfer portal, looking, in her words, for “players with versatility.” Of the five starters, only one is returning: senior guard Casey Harter.
Piece her words together, and the blueprint shows three things in my mind. Two come from her Valkyries framing: playing connected and emphasizing the defense. The third came up following the exhibition win against Lewis, where transfers junior guard Lexi Blue, junior guard Lily Carmody and sophomore guard Camdyn Nelson each played 30 minutes.
“We’d love to not play them that much,” Berube said, adding that she hoped for “a deeper rotation” once injured players returned, which most notably included junior guard Xamiya Walton and junior guard Claire Keswick.
Five games in, Northwestern is slightly behind in a few parts. Here’s how I see the progression thus far.
Connected: ahead of schedule
Thus far, the roster is playing well despite having started playing together in June. Of the 123 field goals made, 78 have come off assists. That 63.4% rate ranks 63rd on Torvik, with the best of those games coming against Milwaukee, where the ‘Cats had 18 assists on 22 makes.
“The open shot is the best shot,” Berube said that night.
Carmody echoed that sentiment, saying of her teammates that “everybody’s a threat on the floor.” That’s been the case since the opener, with three starters all averaging double figures. It’s a stark difference from last year’s team, where Grace Sullivan scored 21.4 points per game, averaging 11.4 points more per game than the next-highest scorer.
Defense: flashes, but no pattern
After the Lewis win, Berube said that defense is what the team will be “hanging” their “hat on.” So far, it’s been hit or miss.
According to Torvik, Northwestern ranks 191st nationally in adjusted defensive efficiency. On two-point shots away from the basket, NU’s opponents are shooting 48.1%, which ranks 344th of 363 eligible teams. In the 91-78 loss to Xavier at Welsh-Ryan, the Musketeers shot 62% from the field.
Perimeter defense has been concerning too. In the season opener, Milwaukee shot 9-for-14 in the near upset, and Xavier went 8-for-15. When asked how much of the perimeter success was luck and how much was due to the defense against Xavier, Berube said it was a “little bit of both.” She pointed to Xavier getting “into our house a lot,” which left defenders scrambling to close out on shooters.
The threes have cooled off to a cumulative 16-for-67 from opponents since then, but Northwestern still ranks 272nd in the nation in opponent three-point shooting percentage.
The best flash came in the third quarter against West Virginia, where the ‘Cats held the Mountaineers to just 3-for-18 from the floor and finished 4-for-23 from deep. The stretch shows they’re capable of strong defense, but nothing substantial enough to say they’ve succeeded in that respect.
Depth: the biggest gap
The depth has been a rotation, not because of its performance but because it hasn’t seen much time. Only eight players have appeared in regular-season games, and only seven in the first two. Moreover, 83% of the team’s minutes have been played by Northwestern’s five starters, and the bench has been outscored 75-40.
The slight expansion of the rotation was because of Walton’s return from injury. So far, she’s been easing back in, with a season-high 26 minutes on Saturday against App State, up from six minutes against UIC and 23 against West Virginia. Fellow returner Righeimer has seen her minutes drop, going from 20 against Milwaukee to just eight against WVU. First-year forward Brooke Golden rounds it out, but has stayed within eight to 11 minutes in her appearances. On the other end, Harter has barely gotten a break, playing 193 of the possible 200 minutes.
After the loss to Xavier, Berube was asked about player fatigue.
“I also think we’re pretty fit,” she said. “We can play from minute one to minute 40, whoever’s out there.”
That also played a role in the loss to West Virginia. The late turnovers came from players who barely sat, including Carmody (36) and Harter (35). Interestingly, the low bench minutes weren’t due to a lack of production. Golden and Righeimer combined for 11 points on 5-for-7 shooting in 19 minutes.
The good news is that the next five games give the team an opportunity to fix this trend. Northwestern will visit Abilene Christian on Wednesday, then it has a four-game home stand against Northern Illinois, Oakland, DePaul and Illinois State.
If I could make a call to Berube, it would be to use this stretch to give the bench some opportunity before the ‘Cats’ first conference matchup against Indiana. Mistakes will happen, but letting the starters rest and giving the bench a chance to prove themselves could pay off in the long run.
The connection is in place, and by the time Indiana visits Welsh-Ryan Arena on Dec. 5, hopefully we’ll know more about how the other two points fit in.













