The Buffalo Bills are leading the NFL in points per game at 31.9, and they’re 8-1 for the first time since 1991, but there’s always room for improvement.
And I think said improvement can occur in Buffalo’s pass game if slot receiver Khalil Shakir becomes a focal point.
I won’t fault you for questioning why I’m writing this now after Shakir had two catches for 29 yards — along with three “runs” for 26 yards — in the win over the Jets in Week 10.
There are a few reasons — it’s a follow from one of my
takeaways from Buffalo’s victory in MetLie Stadium, Amon-Ra St. Brown went off for the Lions against the Patriots in Germany, and Parker Washington had the most receiving yards in a game (152) for the Jaguars since 2019. Oh, and now is the ideal time to start incorporating Shakir into a more prominent role, right before the Bills have this five-game stretch during the holiday season — vs. Chiefs, at Patriots, at Packers, vs. Bears, and at Broncos.
Let’s start general, with a question — who has been the Bills most reliable receiver for going on four seasons now?
Shakir.
Even in 2023, his second season as a professional, on a team with Stefon Diggs, Shakir’s yards-per-route run (1.79) rivaled Diggs’ (1.89). His drop rate was drastically lower than Diggs’ 2.0% vs. 6.4%, and he averaged 7.0 yards after contact per reception to Diggs’ 3.9. All those figures are counting the playoffs too.
Yes, of course — sample size.
Diggs was targeted 175 times to just 56 for Shakir that season. That’s drastic.
Speaking of the playoffs… in the two Bills games that postseason, Shakir and Diggs both had 10 grabs. Shakir had slightly more yards 75 vs. 73 and scored two touchdowns to Diggs’ zero.
Even if you believed Diggs was more reliable in 2023, from 2024 to the present day, we can all agree the answer to my original question is Shakir, right?
And in Allen’s MVP campaign of 2024, Shakir led the team in targets (100), receptions (76), and yards (821) during the regular season. Correlation doesn’t automatically equal causation, but Shakir’s presence as Buffalo’s defacto No. 1 receiver during a season with outrageous efficiency from Buffalo’s offense shouldn’t be ignored.
If any receiver has put in the time, paid his dues, and produced to a level that should earn more looks — it’s Shakir!
And it’s not as though he’s an overachiever without the physical skills of two of the better slot-based veterans in football.
*testing figures at USC Pro Day
Shakir stacks up very favorably with St. Brown and Downs. I didn’t include Washington in that comparison because he didn’t work out before he was selected by Jacksonville in the sixth round of the 2023 NFL Draft.
As for this season, Shakir has made a strong case to see the football more based on how effective he’s been accumulating yardage on a relatively low percentage of the team’s targets.
Check this graphic, Shakir can be found near Nico Collins just barely in the upper left quadrant, where the under-utilized, above-average producers reside:
What can you make of that scatter plot?
Shakir has a target share of 18.1% — simply meaning he’s earned 18.1% of Buffalo’s pass targets through nine games — which is the 34th-highest among 71 qualifying wideouts.
He’s also 20th in yards per route run (2.00) despite his relatively lower target-share percentage.
That disparity is the quantifiable crux of my argument here.
In short, Shakir isn’t seeing the football thrown in his direction very much, but he’s still averaging a reasonably high yards-per-route run figure.
Note on that graphic too — Washington’s target share is 24.9%, and St. Brown’s is over 30%. Downs’ is almost identical to Shakir’s at 18.0%.
Really, there aren’t many other receivers beyond Shakir in the upper-left quadrant either. They are Jameson Williams, Tre Tucker, Caleb Douglas, DeMario Douglas, Rome Odunze, and Collins.
Shakir’s average depth of target (aDOT) is currently just 4.7 yards. That is up from a super-gimmicky 3.9 yards a season ago, and not quite to his 5.6 aDOT during the uber-efficient 2024, when his yards-per-route run figure was a hefty 2.15.
St. Brown’s aDOT is nearly double Shakir’s at 8.6 yards, and he’s been over 8.0 yards in aDOT in each of the last four seasons. Washington’s aDOT is 13.1 yards, exactly what it was during his breakout year a season ago.
And it’s not as though Shakir is incapable of generating big plays or YAC at the rate of the other slot monsters:
For as much as usage may contribute to Shakir’s higher YAC here, the same can be said regarding the 20-plus yard reception percentage for Washington relative to the other three wideouts in the table.
And heck, Shakir has at least one 50-plus yard reception in each of the last four seasons now.
Lastly, if you needed one more piece of persuasion, Shakir is so damn sure-handed. He has a career drop rate of 3.4%. St. Brown’s is 2.9%. Downs’ is 5.2%. Washington’s is 9.0%.
Now I’m officially on the record — I believe Shakir should move into a leading role in the Bills passing offense. He deserves it. And Buffalo’s aerial attack would probably be better if he started seeing more than five targets per game.













