The Phillies, in their perpetual search for depth, signed super utility man Dylan Moore to a minor league contract last offseason in the hopes he could be a source of said depth. Moore split 2025 with the Mariners and Rangers while hitting just .201 with a .642 OPS but his biggest selling point has always been his versatility. The 34-year-old has logged innings at every position except catcher in his eight-year career, no doubt something that piqued the Phillies interest as they were looking for big league depth for multiple
positions, particularly the outfield where Moore has played the most.
Despite this, Moore did not exactly impress in spring training as he hit .194 with a .524 OPS across 41 plate appearances. He appeared he would not make the big-league team, so Moore triggered an opt-out clause in his minor league deal that forced the Phillies to sign him to a major league deal worth $1.45M to keep him around.
In hindsight, they may have been better off letting him head to free agency and using that money and roster spot on someone else.
2026 stats: 13 games, 15 plate appearances, .000/.200/.000, -0.2 WAR, 1.2 innings pitched, 5.40 ERA
What went right
Obviously, Moore did not contribute much to the Phillies this season. He went hitless in 15 plate appearances and struck out six times, reaching base just three times on walks. His most lasting impression was his service as mop-up pitcher, a role Moore dutifully fulfilled in two games where he allowed a total of one run on one hit and a walk.
What went wrong
Moore only appeared in 13 games with the Phillies before being outrighted to Triple-A after clearing waivers on May 8th. The Phillies were able to keep Moore in the organization for the rest of the year, but he hit only .239 with a .692 OPS in 87 games for Lehigh Valley and was not ever much on the radar to return to the majors.
Final Grade: D-
Moore’s adequate performance as a pitcher in those two blowouts is keeping this grade from an F if you allow for a generous curve. It’s a small and unglamorous role, but it is one that is necessary in some cases. In all the other aspects of Moore’s season however, it was a failure. Maybe Moore could have gotten into some sort of groove if the Phillies gave him more at-bats early in the season, as he only started three of the 13 games he appeared in. But conversely, he didn’t really give the Phillies any reason to want to give him more playing time, as he did not stand out in the spring and did effectively nothing at the plate in his extremely small sample size.
Moore was one of the first in a cavalcade of misfits that the Phillies placed on their bench as they tried to patch together a starting caliber outfield and a major league caliber bench, ultimately failing in both. Eventually, the Phillies tried to turn Edmundo Sosa into a form of Dylan Moore lite defensively, as Sosa began to log time in the outfield. That experiment did not yield much better results than Moore’s performance at the plate did.
Perhaps the Phillies or some other team will take another flyer on Moore for 2027, but considering his meager performance in Triple-A and the fact he’ll be 35 in August, it’s likely that Moore has played his last game in the majors.













