With 2:20 remaining in the fourth quarter, the Commanders were trailing 17-21. Their attempted comeback drive had stalled out at their own 45 yard line. On 4th and 2, they took one last shot at extending the drive for a win. Jayden Daniels’ pass to Chig Okonkwo was intercepted by Ar’Darius Washington. It was his second pick of the season. His first had ended the Commanders’ previous possession.
I had decided to “work from home” to watch the game, which started at 11:15 am in my time zone. That was
looking like a poor choice. I thought the game was over and, with it, the Commanders’ season. Judging by the comments on the live game thread, I wasn’t alone.
Then we got a little reminder of what it was like watching the Commanders play in 2024. The defense held the Giants to just 7 yards on the next set of downs, capped by Sonny Styles catching J.J. McCarthy from behind for a 2-yard loss on 3rd and 3, at the two minute warning. Five plays and 55 seconds later, Jayden Daniels connected on a short pass with Stefon Diggs, who ran it in for the go-ahead score, with 1:05 remaining. Daronte Jones’ defense applied pressure on the Giants’ final drive, which stalled out on the Washington 48 yard line. And Rasul Douglas sealed the victory by intercepting an attempted bomb to Malik Nabers with 34 seconds on the clock.
This season, the Commanders have demonstrated the ability to play good teams close, and even beat them. They have also demonstrated the ability to lose to bad teams. The clutch play on both sides of the ball in the final two minutes on Thursday night reminded fans that when this team locks in, they can beat anyone.
The victory against the Giants pulled the Commanders within two wins of the leaders in the second-weakest division in the league, and gave them the benefit of the head-to-head tiebreak. They have 8 games remaining to at least pull even with the Giants and fend off the 4-6 Cowboys. Five of their 8 remaining opponents have losing records, including their last remaining divisional opponent.
With the comeback win against the Giants, the Cardiac Commanders kept their playoff hopes very much alive. Can they sustain the momentum against the visiting 7-2 Bengals? The Commanders’ biggest issue this season has been playing with consistency. If they can start the game like they finished against the Giants and maintain that level of play through four quarters, then they absolutely can. But that kind of consistency has been elusive.
There were positive signs in Thursday night’s win which might be built on to help establish consistent winning football down the stretch. The franchise QB demonstrated that he’s still got resilience in the face of adversity, Stefon Diggs showed that he’s still capable of explosive plays, Ben Sinnott flashed elite productivity in limited opportunities, the offensive line bounced back from a shocking performance against the Rams, Sonny Styles flashed elite potential in all phases on defense, the secondary continued to gel with all its players healthy, and Daronte Jones found the formula to generate pressure through the fourth quarter against a solid offensive line.
As we await the Monday night matchup with the Bengals, let’s have a look at who lined up where, who stepped up and who stepped out of bounds at exactly the right time in what might prove to be the pivotal win of the Commanders’ season.
Technicalities: Stats were sourced from the official NFL gamebook via NFLGSIS, Pro Football Reference (PFR), Pro Football Focus (PFF) and ESPN’s total QBR. In cases where advanced stats are scored differently, I have chosen preferred providers (eg. QB pressures – PFF, yards before contact – PFR). Where differences in advanced stats result from judgment calls (eg. Coverage yards allowed, broken tackles) I have gone with a modified consensus approach. When there is fundamental disagreement between sources, the stats won’t be reported. Minor differences between sources that support the same conclusion are reported. If advanced stats are reported without attribution of source, it means there was consensus. As always, official NFL stats override conflicting data from other sources.
BIGGEST PLAYS OF THE GAME
These plays had the largest impact on teams’ scoring potential within a drive, as judged by Expected Points Added (EPA). Threshhold: EPA = +/- 2.25
Biggest Plays for Commanders
Q4, 1:05, 3rd and 4 at NYG 32, Jayden Daniels pass complete short middle to Stefon Diggs for 32 yards, touchdown. EPA 4.39
Q3, 7:05, 3rd and 1 at NYG 31, Jayden Daniels pass complete short right to Antonio Williams for 31 yards, touchdown. EPA 4.13
Q1, 4:08, 4th and 4 at WAS 15, Dominic Zvada 33-yard field goal no good. EPA -3.0
Q3, 4:13, 2nd and 12 at WAS 19, J.J. McCarthy pass complete short right to Malik Nabers for -1 yards. Malik Nabers fumbles (forced by Frankie Luvu), recovered by Jeremy Reaves at WAS-20. EPA -3.88
Biggest Plays for Giants
Q4, 8:24, 3rd and 7 at NYG 34, J.J. McCarthy pass complete deep middle to Isaiah Likely for 66 yards, touchdown. EPA 6.83
Q1, 6:14, 3rd and 7 at NYG 45, J.J. McCarthy pass complete short left to Cam Skattebo for 34 yards. EPA 3.28
Q3, 6:49, 1st and 10 at NYG 27, J.J. McCarthy pass complete deep left to Malik Nabers for 37 yards. EPA 2.44
Q4, 9:07, 4th and 2 at NYG 31, Jayden Daniels pass incomplete short middle intended for Stefon Diggs (defended by Ar’Darius Washington). EPA -2.4
Q3, 14:13, 2nd and 11 at WAS 20, Jayden Daniels sacked by Shelby Harris for 14 yards. EPA -2.84 Q4, 5:30, 1st and 10 at NYG 24, Jayden Daniels pass deep left intended for Chig Okonkwo is intercepted by Jevon Holland at NYG 2 and returned for no gain. EPA -3.5
OFFENSE
There were 4 penalties called on three offensive players this week.
Jayden Daniels completed 23/33 passing attempts (69.7%, ADOT 6.2 yds) for 249 yds, 3 TDs and 2 INTs, with 2 balls dropped by receivers. Prior to this game, JD5 was the only QB with more than 100 passing attempts and no interceptions.
As a crude metric of how well QBs protect the ball, I calculated turnover opportunities (interceptions + fumbles) as a percentage of passing attempts. After the Giants game, JD5 had 1.9% turnover opportunities, the third-lowest figure among starting QBs after C.J. Stroud and Dak Prescott at 1.8%. Drake Maye, Baker Mayfield and Justin Herbert brought up the rear, all over 6%.
On the ground, JD5 contributed 11 rushing attempts for just 28 yds (2.5 Y/A) and 2 first downs. While that effort tied for his lowest rushing average of the season, his 54.5% success rate was his 4th best in 7 games.
Daniels was flagged in the third quarter for his fifth delay of game penalty this season. To his credit, he was clapping for the ball to be snapped on the play.
While he wasn’t perfect, his play was good enough to get the win. JD5’s 52.2 Total QBR ranked 14th among starting QBs in Week 10.
Rachaad White had 11 carries for 47 yds (4.3 Y/A) and 4 first downs (54.5% success rate). He averaged 2.7 yards before contact/attempt, a little above average for RBs this season. White also caught 1/2 targets for 5 yds, with 1 drop.
Austin Ekeler made 9 rushing attempts for 26 yds (2.9 Y/A) and 3 first downs, with 2 broken tackles. He averaged just 1.2 YBC/att, yet still managed a team-leading 55.6% rushing success rate. Ekeler also caught 4/4 targets for 26 yds.
Robert Henry had 2 carries for 4 yds.
Stefon Diggs led the Commanders in targets (10), receptions (6) and receiving yards (83), but not reception rate (60%, ADOT 5.7 yd). He was one of three Commanders with a receiving TD. He was second on the team with an impressive 7.2 YAC/rec. He made just 1 of 3 contested catches. In most games this season, his 2.77 Y/RR receiving productivity would have led the team. But he was up against stiff competition in Week 10.
Antonio Williams caught 2/2 targets, at an ADOT of 11.5 yds, for 42 yds and 1 TD. He led the team at 9.5 YAC/Rec, but had modest receiving productivity at 1.24 Y/RR.
Treylon Burks caught 2/3 targets for 27 yds, at a team-long 16.3 yd ADOT.
Luke McCaffrey was not targeted as a receiver, but he received a team-high 90.4 run blocking grade from PFF.
Ben Sinnott only played 24 offensive snaps, yet finished second on the team in receptions (3-way tie) and receiving yards. He caught 4/4 targets for 42 yds and 1 TD. His receiving output in limited opportunities equated to elite-level productivity at 4.67 Y/RR. Fans who have been calling for him to get more targets can feel vindicated by that result. He certainly delivered when given the opportunity. This game tied for the most targets he has received in his career with the second Dallas game last season, and set new career highs in receptions and receiving yards.
Sinnott’s 81.9 run blocking grade was the third-highest on the team.
Chig Okonkwo seemed out of sync with his QB for much of the evening. He caught 4/8 passes for 24 yds, with 1 drop. His anemic 0.96 Y/RR receiving productivity was second-lowest on the team after Rachaad White at 0.36 Y/RR. His 49.0 run blocking grade was third-lowest on the team.
John Bates committed a 5-yard false start infraction in the 1st quarter. His 61.3 run blocking grade was fair to middling.
The offensive line had a bounce back from the dismal performance against the Rams, pretty much across the board.
LT Brandon Coleman nearly halved his pressure rate in pass protection from last week. According to PFF, he allowed 1 QB hit and 1 pressure. His 5.1% pressure rate against the Giants was better than average for starting OTs this season. Coleman’s 84.8 run blocking grade was second only to Luke McCaffrey on the Commanders.
It wasn’t all sunshine and lollipops, however. Coleman was penalized 5 yards for a false start in the 1st quarter. A holding penalty in the 4th quarter was offset by a penalty on the Giants. These were his 9th and 10th penalties in 9 games this season.
LG Chris Paul did not allow a single pressure in pass protection, for the third time this season. His 58.1 run blocking grade was an improvement over his 43.2 season average.
Nick Allegretti returned to the lineup at center to replace Lucas Patrick, who is in the concussion protocol. Nick Allowed just 1 QB hurry. His 2.6% pressure rate was above the 75th percentile for centers. His 79.2 run blocking grade was second-highest on the OL this week.
RG Sam Cosmi allowed 0 pressures in pass protection. His 68.3 run blocking grade was close to this 68.8 season average
RT Josh Conerly Jr continued to struggle in pass protection at times, giving up 4 QB hurries. His 10.3% pressure rate in pass protection was about twice what we’d like to see at OT. But at least he improved on the 14.6% pressure rate allowed last week against the Rams. His 66.6 run blocking grade was an improvement on his 56.4 season average.
DEFENSE
The Commanders committed 1 penalty on defense this week.
Odafe Oweh made 3 tackles and 2 assists, with 1 TFL. In the pass rush, he got home with 1 sack and 1 QB hit, for a pressure rate of 7.4% (<10th percentile for edge rushers). He currently ranks 18th among NFL edge defenders with 5 sacks.
K’Lavon Chaisson made 1 tackle and 1 assist, with 1 stop and 1 missed tackle. PFF credits him with 1 QB hurry in the pass rush (4% pressure rate). K’Lavon dropped into coverage 4 times, and was targeted once for a 66-yard TD reception by TE Isaiah Likely.
Dorance Armstrong generated 1 QB hit and 1 hurry in the pass rush (10.5% pressure rate, just below 25th percentile).
Shy Tuttle led the tackling on the interior, with 1 tackle for a run stop, and 2 assists.
Charles Omenihu led the interior pass rush, with 2 QB hits and 1 hurry. His 11.5% pressure rate was just below the 90th percentile for iDL. He also contributed 1 tackle assist.
Tim Settle contributed 2 tackle assists, with 1 contributing to a run stop.
Johnny Newton had 1 tackle assist. Deatrich Wise kept a clean stat sheet.
Rookie Sonny Styles led the team in combined tackles (13) and defensive stops (5). He made 5 tackles, 8 assists and 1 TFL, catching J.J. McCarthy from behind for a 2-yard loss to force a punt at the 2 minute warning, setting up Washington’s go-ahead score on the ensuing drive.
Styles posted a 16.7% run stop rate against the Giants, which is off-the charts for LBs (90th percentile = 11.3%).
Sonny generated a team-leading 4 pressures (4x QB hurries) in 10 blitzes. His 40% pressure rate led the team, and is an elite figure for LBs (Week 8 season leader = Quincy Williams at 34%).
His coverage figures differed slightly, ranging from 0.71 Y/Cov Snap (> 50th percentile) per PFF to 1.03 Y/Cov Snap (< 50th percentile) per PFR.
Frankie Luvu registered 2 tackles, 4 assists, and 1 forced fumble, with 1 missed tackle and 2 total defensive stops. He generated 1 hurry in 10 blitzes.
There was close agreement on his coverage stats (PFF: 19 yds, 0.61 Y/Cov Snap; PFR 18 yds, 0.58 Y/Cov Snap) with both agencies rating him right around the 90th percentile for LBs, based on Week 8 season stats.
There was strong consensus between stats services on two of the three CBs’ coverage performance this week.
Rasul Douglas played sparingly, but could be argued to have made the biggest impact per unit of playing time. Rasul allowed 0 completions in 15 coverage snaps (PFF: 1 tgt; PFR: 3 tgts). The NFL credits him with 1 pass breakup and 1 interception, the latter sealing the Commanders’ victory with 34 seconds remaining and the Giants driving at the Washington 48 yard line.
Amik Robertson played 98% of defensive snaps, primarily at outside CB. He registered 4 tackles and 1 assist, with 2 TFL and 3 total defensive stops (tie – 2nd on team).
Amik allowed 4 receptions for 43 yds in 41 coverage snaps. His 1.05 Y/Cov Snap rate of yardage allowed was right around his season average, a little above the 40th percentile for CBs.
There was disagreement on Trey Amos’ performance in 40 coverage snaps, with PFF rating him above the 75th percentile (4 rec, 28 yds, 0.70 Y/Cov Snp) and PFR rating him below the 25th percentile (3 rec, 52 yds, 1.30 Y/Cov Snp).
Amos also contributed 2 tackles and 2 assists, with 1 stop.
Jeremy Reaves led the team in tackles (7) and was second on the team in combined tackles (9), and tied with Amik Robertson for second in total stops (3). Reaves recovered the fumble forced by Frankie Luvu to complete the turnover.
Reaves allowed just 3 receptions for 16 yds in 28 coverage snaps. His 0.57 Y/Cov Snp rate of yardage allowed was just below average for safeties per Week 8 season stats.
Reaves registered 1 QB hit and 1 hurry on 5 blitzes for an impactful 40% pressure rate.
Reaves was flagged for Washington’s only penalty on defense this week, a questionable DPI for 4 yds near the Washington goal line in the 2nd quarter.
Nick Cross made 1 tackle and 5 assists, with no stops this week. He made his strongest positive impact in the pass rush, tying Sonny Styles for team lead in total pressures (1 QB hit, 3 hurries) and leading the team with a whopping 57.1% pressure rate on 7 blitzes.
A week after his near shutdown performance in coverage against the Rams, Cross was picked on by J.J. McCarthy, allowing 3 receptions in 34 coverage snaps for somewhere between 1.65 Y/Cov Snp (PFF: 56 yds) and 1.94 Y/Cov Snp (PFR: 66 yds), depending on which stats service you believe. In either case, his rate of yardage allowed was below the 10th percentile for his position, this week. Last week, he was at the 90th percentile.
Quan Martin made 1 tackle and 4 assists, with no stops. There was slight disagreement on his performance in 22 coverage snaps. PFF credits him with allowing 1 reception for 8 yds, while PFR counted no receptions.
Percy Butler made the most of limited opportunities, registering 1 tackle, 3 assists along with 1 pass breakup and 1 forced fumble. The stats services disagreed on his coverage performance (PFF: 3 tgt, 2 rec, 35 yds, 2.92 Y/Cov Snp; PFR: 4 tgt, 0 receptions).
SPECIAL TEAMS
Luke McCaffrey returned 3 kickoffs for 58 yds, averaging 19.3 Y/A. He returned 2 punts for 13 yds (6.5 Y/A). He had 1 tackle assist in coverage.
McCaffrey’s biggest play in the return game was not even credited to him on the stat sheet. With 8:13 remaining in the 4th quarter, and Washington trailing 17-21, Luke stepped out of bounds before touching a loose ball on a kickoff. By NFL rules, the heads up play resulted in New York being penalized for an out of bounds kickoff, with Washington getting the ball on their 40 yard line.
Drew Stevens was a perfect 3/3 on extra points and connected on his only field goal attempt from 46 yards. For the season, he is now 15/18 (83.3%) on extra points, and 17/20 (85.0%) on field goals. He is 13/13 on field goals under 50 yards and 4/7 on field goals over 50 yds.
Tress Way punted 4 times for 198 yds (49.5 Y/A), with 1 return for 2 yds (Net 49.0 Y/A).
Kain Medrano led the charge in coverage, with 2 tackles, and also forced a funble that was recovered by the Giants on their final drive of the game. Tyler Owens had 2 tackles and 1 missed tackle. Percy Butler made a single tackle.
Jordan Magee, Ale Kaho and Joshua Josephs each had 1 tackle assist.
There were no penalties on special teams.













