And it can only be solved by the folks at the very top.
The Micro
The news of Trev Alberts accepting the Michigan athletic director job certainly caught me off guard. I appreciate what Trev did for us, the PlayFly deal was a really good set up for A&M and he seemed like he was a good steward of our resources. The hire of Bucky McMillan seems to be paying off, with the other hires TBD. On the other hand, there has been speculation that Schloss’s departure could have been handled better…and Baseball as a whole
isnt quite as good as when he found it and football is currently 4-6. So ultimately, I’m sad to see him go but also I’m fine with it. Trev strikes me as a change agent kind of guy, someone who is built to burn bright but not long and I appreciate him for his time here.
The Macro
There are trends and patterns that we need to pay attention to. At the AD level we’ve now lost three guys…Woodward, Bjork, and Trev to other power 5 schools who have a higher level of esteem than us (much to our own chagrin). Maybe our athletic department is a stepping stone because the trend of three guys looking at LSU, Ohio State, and Michigan as a step up says as much. This makes 3 different ADs (including RC’s time as interim) in the past 5 years.
But bigger than that, this trend reflects the unstable, and inconsistent nature of leadership at Texas A&M. We’re working on our 5th (including interim) president in the last 5 years. We can talk all day about why each individual person had to leave or mitigating circumstances associated with their departure, but 5 presidential transitions in 5 years is more than any other program in the country (Florida is right behind us at 4). It is impossible to create any sustainable momentum as an athletic department with this much churn and turnover.
The Impact
The lack of consistent leadership at key executive levels has led to rash decision making to the tune more than a 125 million dollars of committed money for two coaches, one of whom was fired and the other in the middle of a losing season. We worship at the alter of cutting edge facilities as a way to demonstrate our commitment to excellence…when in actuality excellence is quiet and takes place through steady, firm, values driven leadership. We are desperate for sustained success and stable excellence but we act rashly and out of fear of our coaches leaving.
The reality is that this kind of leadership means circumstances have to be absolutely perfect for us to succeed at the level to which we think we’re capable of. Things have to go exactly right in order for us to have an “elite” season and maybe it only happens once every 5-7 years…and guess what. That’s exactly who we are. It’s not a surprise that we’re a “lightening in a bottle” type of program, it’s who we have set ourselves up to be.
Autopsy Without Blame
I’ve never been one to blame people. I dont care if someone says “it’s my fault”. I recognize the importance of both, but those, to me, are rear view thinking comments. I want someone to take responsibility and to recognize it’s in their purview to fix things. In my view we have a flawed culture of decision making at the highest levels, which rests squarely on the Board of Regents. When we look at continuity, many of the folks on the Board have been there for almost a decade. But during their watch, A&M has seen tremendous churn and turnover. That’s an issue. It cant be the fault of the coach because we’ve changed that. It cant be on the AD because well we’ve changed that too. It cant be the president because…well we’ve changed there. Ultimately it’s about the context and culture that these folks have operated in and that context and culture is driven by our Board of Regents.
Our Board is made up of competent folks who are likely much smarter and more accomplished than me. But they HAVE to recognize their impact on how our programs are operating right now and operate differently. There is a culture of dogmatic decision making and black and white thinking which results in high turnover, a constant state of interim leadership all over campus, and stagnation. You can either live in a state of circumstance where you are reacting to what goes on around you or you can live in a state of Vision. We value the latter but spend all our time in the former.
What Frustrates Me
Two of the statues A&M has on campus are Sully and Rudder. These two folks made difficult decisions to look beyond what A&M was at that time to what it could be and they made a lot of people mad about the decisions they made…but that tough forward thinking revolutionary paradigm made A&M what it is today. Yet generations later we revel in their shadow, while trying to maintain tradition and make sure things dont change too much. We deify Rudder and Sul Ross without learning from the legacy they left.
Another issue I have is that I’ve seen us plan effectively. When I was a student our campus was a mish mash of architectural styles that reflected periods of growth followed by periods of stagnation. There was no consistency, or coherency, despite there being an institutional master plan in the late 80s focused on student experience that did not address the physical campus. In 2004 Texas A&M created a campus physical master plan, and that master plan has been adapted and built upon, and we’re now starting to see the campus make sense. We’ve gone from the Spence Park metal gym equipment to Aggie Park. The buildings aren’t just soviet bloc architecture, they make sense next to each other. We have values and those values help us make decisions on what comes next. The people who created that master plan recognized the value in creating something that set the groundwork for the next folks to make decisions….they built plans that would outlast them and could be built upon. We’ve done this with our physical campus, yet we seem unable to do it in the systemic decision making processes that impact our athletic programs.
In Closing
It is not about one president or one AD. It is about a concerning trend related to the overall governance of Texas A&M. We cannot sit here and be surprised that our football program has a difficult time sustaining relevance when the decision making environment surrounding it is full of chaos and churn. Buddy I get that it’s not the Board of Regents fault that Elko hired Wiggins and Lynch. But we have to consider the environment created where a football coach is empowered to do whatever they think fit despite all evidence supporting the notion that it might not be the best idea.
Texas A&M needs sustained, calm, principled leadership at the highest levels. In essence, Texas A&M is a big ass sailboat. We spend so much money on the biggest sails money can buy to take us wherever the wind might go and to operate in reaction to however fast that wind might be blowing. But in the grand scheme of things it doesn’t matter how big the sails we raise are if we dont have a functional compass or rudder.













