When Blake Butera was hired as Nationals manager, there was plenty of optimism, but there was also some skepticism mixed in. Sure, Butera seemed like a sharp guy and had the endorsement of a Hall of Famer in Mike Piazza. However, he was going to be the youngest manager in over 50 years and had been a player development guy rather than a manager the past few years.
For goodness sakes, Butera is younger than Aaron Judge. He was going to coach a young team, so his age was not as much of an issue. Through
the first two months of the season, Butera has shattered all expectations as manager of the Nats. He has this team sitting at 29-27, and playing the best baseball we have seen from a Nats team since 2019.
Even a week ago, there were people whispering about Butera being a Manager of the Year candidate. This was when the team had just gotten to that .500 mark on May 20th. At that point, the Nats were shattering expectations. Since then though, things have only gotten better, and the Butera Manager of the Year candidacy is getting louder.
If the season ended today, Butera would certainly be in the mix for that award. The Nats are one of the surprises of all of baseball. This was supposed to be a tough rebuild year where 100 losses was not out of the question. Now, Butera and this team have Nats fans believing. For crying out loud, the folks at 106.7 The Fan threw a parade yesterday. That was not happening before Butera.
Of course, the lion’s share of the credit goes to the players, especially this elite offense. However, the coaching staff also plays a huge role. I think a big part of being a great manager is finding the right staff. Butera absolutely hit his staff hires out of the park.
The hiring of Matt Borgschulte as hitting coach has genuinely changed the direction of this franchise. Simon Mathews has also done a nice job helping some of his pitchers right the ship. Veteran arms Miles Mikolas and Zack Littell looked absolutely cooked at the start of the season. However, after working with Mathews, who is younger than them, these two guys have righted the ship. Cade Cavalli also seems to be getting better with every start.
The hitting coach and the pitching coach get the most press, but those are not the only hires that Butera has nailed. This is mostly a pretty young and inexperienced staff, but Butera added experience in the right spots. Bobby Wilson is a great example of that. He had a 10 year big league career as a glove first backup. After that, he was a catching coach with the Rangers, where he helped Jonah Heim a lot. In DC, the seasoned catching mind has helped turn around Keibert Ruiz’s defense.
Butera’s staff hiring genuinely gets an A+ to this point. I also think he does a solid job managing the games. There are times where I do not agree with what he does, like any manager. As a whole, I think he is good most of the time. Last night, he made a move that I was upset with at the moment, but looking back, it was pretty cool.
When Mitchell Parker was in trouble in the 9th, he did not have anyone warming up in the bullpen. He let Parker work his way out of the mess. I bet that felt really good for Parker. It showed that his manager believes in him. Sure, if the Nats had not gotten the insurance runs in the top of the inning, things may have been different. However, with the lead in a fairly comfortable spot, Butera wanted to show Parker he trusted him.
That is a good example of Butera showing feel and trusting his players. With a full bullpen, he could have easily yanked Parker after 2.1 innings of work. However, he wanted the lefty to try and finish the game himself. That sends a positive message to the locker room.
I wonder what the Nats would have to do for Butera to be in Manager of the Year contention. Obviously, if the Nats somehow make the playoffs, Butera would be a lock, but would he get the award if the Nats won 80 games? The Nats over/under for wins this year was 65.5, so 80 wins would be a massive overperformance. Butera still would probably get snubbed for a team that made the playoffs though.
Honestly, the .500 mark could be the magic number. If Butera’s Nats finish the season at or above .500, his candidacy would be tough to deny. These Nats were supposed to be basement dwellers, but now they are showing serious spunk and are rising up the NL East.
The faith that Butera has in his players is awesome. He set the tone early in Spring Training, when he talked about how CJ Abrams could be one of the best players in baseball. The Nats shortstop is making Butera look like a sage right now, having a career year so far.
It is wild how much a new coaching staff can change things. We got on Davey and Darnell Coles over the years, but maybe we were not harsh enough. Was the talent always there and just getting wasted? It is a new day now, and the Nats are led by their 33 year old wonderkid manager Blake Butera, who is impressing fans every day.
