The Yankees got run out of Queens this weekend, dropping back-to-back contests to the Mets—the latter in particularly ignominious fashion—to lose the Subway Series and their third straight series overall. Adding to their woes is the Rays’ continued success, which leaves them three games back in the divisional road. Now seems like a less-than-ideal time for the Yanks to face a team that was a true nemesis for them in 2025: the Blue Jays. Fresh off going 11-6 against them in 2025 (including the playoffs),
Toronto returns to the site of their ALDS Game 4 clincher to begin a new four-game series tonight.
The Jays have battled inconsistent hitting and a rash of pitching injuries to start their year, as they enter action at 21-25. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is in the midst of one of his rather frequent power outages (though he did go deep yesterday), and the cast surrounding him hasn’t flexed much muscle this year. NPB free agent Kazuma Okamoto has been their most reliable slugger, but much of the core that brought them within a few feet of winning the World Series has failed to repeat their success. That said, the Jays remain flush with talent and have won six of their last eight series. This four-game rumble promises a bevy of fascinating pitching matchups. Let’s dig in.
Monday: Ryan Weathers vs. Patrick Corbin (7:05 pm ET)
Both teams will open this series sending a portsider to the mound. Ryan Weathers was invincible for most of his last start against the Orioles. He didn’t allow a hit until the seventh inning, at which point he was chased from the game and Coby Mayo’s go-ahead home run off Brent Headrick spoiled all the fun. Weathers, whose father David was a Blue Jays draftee in 1986, will face them for just the second time in his MLB career. His first time at Rogers Centre marked a nice finale to his 2024 season with Miami: 6.1 innings of one-run ball with three hits, two walks, and six strikeouts.
Patrick Corbin always comes back. He signed in Toronto when the season was already underway to shore up an undermanned rotation which was reeling from preseason injuries to José Berrios, Shane Bieber, and Wednesday night’s starter Trey Yesavage. Corbin has performed better than your typical replacement-level arm so far, with a 3.93 ERA through seven spins of the wheel. He’s always going to be pitching around a good amount of traffic, but his slider remains a weapon after all these years.
Tuesday: Will Warren vs. Dylan Cease (7:05 pm ET)
Warren got decidedly more aid from his lineup than from his defense in Tuesday night’s win against the Orioles—a bevy of misplays in the field cost him a chance to complete six frames, but he wound up with a win regardless thanks to a big third inning. Warren will return to the barn where he got eaten alive last playoffs, wearing the rest of the Blue Jays’ relentless onslaught during ALDS Game 2, in relief of Max Fried. But he does so having grown into his repertoire a lot more than his up-and-down rookie year. Regardless, this will prove a psychologically important start.
Cease is the Jays’ shiny new ace, channeling Dave Stieb in more ways than just his striking mustache. The 30-year old is on a roll, having finished seven innings in three straight starts. His last effort was almost wasted, as the Rays rallied against the Toronto bullpen to force extra innings; the ultimately Jays prevailed 5-3. Cease’s command is always liable to fly away on any given day, but you’ll take the chance because he has 75 strikeouts, the most in the AL so far.
The only MLB pitchers with a higher fWAR than Cease’s 2.2 thus far are the Phillies’ Cristopher Sánchez at 2.5 and the 6-foot-6 Yankee I’m about to discuss.
Wednesday: Cam Schlittler vs. Trey Yesavage (7:05 pm ET)
You get the feeling we’ll be seeing this exact pitching matchup in the AL East for years to come. Both breakout stars of the 2025 playoffs have repeated their brilliance in 2026, but Schlittler’s first 10 starts have been in a class unto themselves in the Junior Circuit. Cam exceeded 100 pitches in a start for the first time his last time out against the Mets; a leadoff home run from two-out walk to Brett Baty was all that stood between him finishing seven innings. Revenge may be on his mind after his Game 4 loss to Toronto, which sent the Yankees home last October.
Yesavage stole the spotlight from Schlittler in those playoffs as his team’s playoff run went all the way to Game 7 of the World Series. The big righty with the extreme top-down delivery had a shoulder issue that delayed his encore, so he’s only four starts into his campaign. His latest outing against the Tigers was his first to complete six innings, and he limited Detroit to two runs on four hits while striking out exactly six batters for the third straight appearance. Seeing these two sorcerers of the slab go toe-to-toe should be a delight.
Thursday: Carlos Rodón vs. TBD (7:05 pm ET)
Carlos Rodón would be the first to tell you that his first two starts of 2026 “didn’t go well at all.” The left-hander departed Saturday’s start before the end of the fourth inning thanks to command issues and a pair of gaffes on one play in the third which gave the Mets the lead. Room for optimism exists: Rodón’s issues have almost exclusively come after getting two outs in an inning. The two-out numbers have been rather grisly: the Mets and Brewers combined went 4-for-11 with three walks and five runs scored. As long as he can continue to obtain the first two outs without too much trouble, those troubles should even out over time. Toronto was an outstanding two-out offense in 2025, but have not been quite the same force this season.
This slot in the Blue Jays’ rotation used to belong to Eric Lauer, but he struggled so mightily to begin the year that the Jays designated him for assignment last week. On Saturday against the Tigers, Toronto turned to a bullpen game in which lefty reliever Mason Fluharty opened ahead of rookie Spencer Miles. Miles proved effective in the bulk man role last time, pitching 3.2 scoreless innings with two runs and two walks on five hits. Depending on how much (or how little) the Yankees make the Jays’ bullpen work in the first three games, Miles may be compelled to eat up more of this contest than that affair in Detroit—a 10-inning 2-1 victory.
