That draw feels both bad and good for Arsenal, doesn’t it? The Gunners were dominant in the first half, forgot to come out for the second, and claimed a point from behind. The far bigger concern coming out of today’s match is whether David Raya is seriously injured and how much time he’ll miss. It did not look great for the Arsenal keeper — he walked off the pitch cradling his left arm as you often see with a shoulder injury.
David Raya’s injury was the direct result of referee Chris Kavanagh’s failure
to book William Osula for fouling the Arsenal keeper to prevent him from releasing the ball quickly. The Newcastle forward did it once, was whistled for the foul but not warned or booked, and so he did it again, injuring an opponent. That’s precisely what can happen when a referee doesn’t keep a proper hold on things. Players get hurt.
There was a time in football where preventing the keeper from releasing the ball was pretty much an automatic yellow card. I’m really not sure why we’ve gone away from that. If the keeper starts a quick counter and someone fouls the next person on the ball to stop that counter, it’s a yellow card. So why isn’t it a yellow card to stop the move one step earlier with an intentional foul? Not to mention that there is zero reason or justification for fouling a goalkeeper like that. You cannot challenge a keeper when he is holding the ball, end of story.
Arsenal don’t really have anybody but themselves to blame for the dropped points. They were tremendous in the first half and were a bit unfortunate not to go in at halftime with a bigger lead. Lewis Hall’s last ditch sliding block on Noni Madueke saved a would-be second goal that turned out to make a massive difference in the match. The Kai Havertz pass to Ebere Eze for the opening goal was magnificent. Eze’s smashed finish was nice, too.
Newcastle made three substitutions to open the second half and came out with a lot more energy. Arsenal were poor and didn’t match the intensity. Kudos to the hosts, I guess. But it wasn’t as if they did much more than run harder and play a bit sharper. They didn’t make some brilliant tactical adjustment. The Gunners really should have been able to respond.
Newcastle’s equalizer was entirely avoidable. Riccardo Calafiori should never throw the ball in to Martin Ødegaard under pressure, moving back towards his own goal, expecting a difficult, turning volley clearance. Ødegaard could, you know, not miss his kick, although to be fair to him, he was under heavy pressure from Joe Willock whose bump as the ball came in was right on the line of being a foul. And somehow Harvey Barnes was left in acres of space with Ezri Konsa narrow and Jurrien Timber pushed way up the pitch.
Arsenal would have been better off ceding possession to Newcastle for taking too long to throw the ball in rather than turning it over in open play as they did. Heck, Riccardo Calafiori would have been better off launching it up the line to turnover possession around or beyond midfield. I’m not certain the referee had even begun his countdown. It’s not the first time that’s happened this season, either. It’s inexplicable and quite poor.
Newcastle took the lead from a goalmouth scramble on a corner kick. David Raya wound up on his backside in the goal and Malick Thiaw, who was also somehow unmarked, poked the ball into the back of the net. It was an annoying goal to concede because there was a fair bit of what everyone made such a big deal of supposedly wanting to get out of the game on set pieces last season when Arsenal were so effective from them.
Dan Burn was open for a free header because Jurrien Timber, who might have been assigned to Burn, is held by William Osula. Ezri Konsa was screened off by another Newcastle player from stepping out to challenge him Burn, too. David Raya ended up on his backside because Joe Willock drove Gabriel into him. I guess it was all within whatever the rules are now because the referee and VAR didn’t see anything wrong with it but what you can and can’t do now is as clear as mud. Kudos to Newcastle for pushing up against wherever the line is now without getting caught / going over it.
As poor as Arsenal were to open the second half — and they were quite bad for a solid 20 minutes, failing to match the Newcastle’s energy — they were also maybe a bit unlucky to concede two goals during that period. They gifted them the first and the corner kick scramble was really the only other good chance during Newcastle’s flurry. For all their energy and Arsenal’s slack play, the home side didn’t get great looks at goal.
Eventually, the Gunners woke up and responded. They had far the better of the play in the closing 25 minutes of the second half. Noni Madueke deserved his equalizer — he was excellent all match, continuing his excellent run of form. Maybe Newcastle keeper Lukas Hornicek should have done better, but he was screened on the shot.
Arsenal pushed for a winning goal but lacked the necessary sharpness to find one. Christos Tzolis was ineffective. Kai Havertz ran out of gas. Mikel Merino misplaced what looked to be a simple pass to kill a promising attack. Viktor Gyokeres made a poor decision to shoot instead of pass late in the match. I think a third goal was there to be had — Newcastle aren’t good and looked spent — but the Gunners didn’t put it together.
Obviously, you avoid all that by scoring another goal or two when you’re firmly in control of the match in the first half. Maybe you get another goal from that period if Bruno Guimaraes has a better game. He was abject in his return to St. James’ Park. He’s firmly in the “disappointing” category this season, for me.
You can also avoid it needing to find a late goal by not gifting your opponent an equalizer with a series of inexplicably poor decisions from your own throw-in. Self-inflicted wounds, man. It’s really quite annoying to drop points after such a dominant first half. At the same time, it’s a decent performance to reclaim a point after barfing up the lead, particularly when Arsenal looked so off the pace to start the second half.
One more thing that I’ve said before. Get the nonsense of standing over a player and shouting at them out of the game. Dan Burn took out Jurrien Timber with the out-of-control follow-through on a sliding challenge, for which he was booked. With Timber lying on the ground, Burn bends over and berates him. Noni Madueke picked up a booking on the sequence for defending his prostrate teammate. It’s all dumb and a bad look. Make it an automatic yellow to stand over an opponent and scream at them. You avoid creating a flashpoint for more nastiness, too.













