You can probably guess why the headline to this recap is what it is, because, well, there aren’t many non-profane words to describe the Cubs’ 9-8 loss to the White Sox Sunday afternoon on the South Side.
Two blown three-run leads. A remarkable ninth-inning comeback. And then… well, just too many home runs served up to an up-and-coming Sox team that seems to enjoy hitting them.
I suppose I’ll begin at the beginning.
The Cubs jumped out to a quick first-inning lead. Nico Hoerner led off the game with
a single and Michael Busch made it 2-0 with this home run, his fourth [VIDEO].
Fun fact about Busch’s homer from BCB’s JohnW53:
The Cubs had not had a two-run homer hit by their second batter of the game since Aug. 3, 2024, at home vs. the Cardinals, following a leadoff walk.
They had not had one after a leadoff single since June 20, 2024, at Milwaukee.
The batter who hit both: Michael Busch.
Alex Bregman followed with a single, extending his hitting streak to eight games. One out later, he moved to third on a single by Seiya Suzuki, then scored on this wild pitch [VIDEO].
It’s 3-0 early! What could possibly…
You don’t want to know the answer to that question. But you will get it, right here.
The Sox scored a run in the second on three singles, and it might have been more except for this great throw by Pete Crow-Armstrong [VIDEO].
The Cubs got that run back in the fourth. Dansby Swanson led off with a single and Nico walked, Both runners moved up on a fly ball by Busch, and this single by Bregman scored Swanson [VIDEO].
Unfortunately, the ball didn’t go far enough to score Hoerner and he was stranded. That turned out to be important.
The Sox made it 4-2 in the fourth off Colin Rea, who hit the first batter he faced, Miguel Vargas. Vargas eventually cored on a double by Andrew Benintendi. Then Rea walked the leadoff hitter in the fifth and, as you well know, that’s never a good thing. The Sox wound up scoring a pair of runs on a double by Vargas and that was it for Rea, who has struggled in his last couple of starts.
It might have been worse in the fifth if not for this impressive catch by PCA [VIDEO].
The bullpens for both teams took over and did well for a while. Jacob Webb, who’s been very good lately, threw 1.1 scoreless innings, as did Hoby Milner. For the Sox, they got five shutout innings of relief from Sean Newcomb, Grant Taylor and Bryan Hudson. The Cubs stranded a bunch of runners in those innings, too.
Personally, I think I’d have let Milner throw the entire eighth inning. I know he’s not used to multiple innings but he’d thrown only 18 pitches (14 strikes) to record his four outs. Craig Counsell did let him start the inning and he struck out Colson Montgomery. Phil Maton came on in relief and got Chase Meidroth to ground out.
Two out, nobody on, and then Maton fell apart. Walk, single, three-run homer by Tristan Peters. That, my friends, was Peters’ first MLB home run. It gave the Sox a 7-4 lead. Maton has been just awful most of the year, now with a 9.49 ERA, and the Cubs signed him to a two-year deal with a third-year option. That’s looking like a really bad signing right now.
So. To the ninth, and Seranthony Dominguez on to close for the Sox. Dominguez had some rough outings early in the year but had converted seven straight save opportunities since blowing a save April 16 vs. the Rays.
The Cubs had themselves an amazing ninth inning. Bregman led off with a walk and after Ian Happ struck out, moved to second on a wild pitch. Suzuki then hit a ground ball to third that was thrown away by Vargas and was safe, advancing to second, with Bregman stopping at third.
That brought up Michael Conforto [VIDEO].
Conforto has shown a flair for the dramatic in his first couple of months as a Cub. The homer, his third, tied the game 7-7. Also, from John:
A Cub had hit a game-tying three-run homer in the ninth inning only 15 times previously since 1910, first season for which baseball-reference.com has searchable play-level data.
The last to do it was Anthony Rizzo, at Cincinnati on April 21, 2017. He did it with two out.
Nine days earlier, Willson Contreras had done it with one out at St. Louis.The only three earlier since 1994:
Shane Andrews, at home vs. the Braves, with nobody out, on April 10, 2000
Kosuke Fukudome, at home vs. the Brewers, with nobody out, on March 31, 2008 (his first game as a Cub)
Geovany Soto, at home vs. the Brewers, with two out on Sept. 18, 2008.
There’s still only one out after Conforto’s blast, but Miguel Amaya popped to short center and PCA lined to second. In the bottom of the ninth, Daniel Palencia allowed a one-out double but got out of the inning scoreless, so on to extras the game went.
PCA was the placed runner. He stole third [VIDEO].
After that, Swanson walked and Hoerner hit a ground ball that got PCA in a rundown [VIDEO].
The rundown lasted long enough to get Swanson to third and Hoerner to second with one out. Busch was intentionally passed to load the bases, and Bregman hit a grounder to short, which scored Swanson [VIDEO].
But that’s all they got. Happ was intentionally passed and Suzuki struck out to end the inning.
Still, there’s a one-run lead with three outs to go. Who’s going to pitch?
Well, there aren’t a lot of choices here. The Cubs could have gone with Ty Blach, who was just called up from Triple-A Iowa Sunday. Blach hasn’t pitched in the majors since 2024 and is 35 years old and wasn’t doing all that well at Iowa.
So Ryan Rolison, who threw the eighth Saturday night, was the choice. Meidroth was the placed runner for the Sox. They had Andrew Benintendi lay down a bunt, and here’s what happened [VIDEO].
That was pretty clearly a terrible call by Laz Diaz, and it took very little time for it to be overturned. So the Sox have a runner on third with one out.
Not that any of it really mattered when Sox catcher Edgar Quero hit a walk-off homer off Rolison.
From John:
That was the Cubs’ first walk-off loss of the year. They had won six games on walk-offs.
The Cubs blew three leads today, 3-0 and 8-7. They have blown 21 for the season, in 16 different games, including seven in the next half-inning after going ahead.
They are 8-8 in the 16 games.
The Cubs scored a lot of runs in this series — 21 of them, to be exact, averaging seven per game. That’s really good! They have now scored 241 runs for the year, which is 5.13 per game, which would be 831 for the year.
The problem, as you surely know, is pitching. The Sox scored 22 runs off Cubs pitching in this series. The Sox have some pretty good young hitters, but they are not that good. The Cubs need better starters and relievers; the current bunch, decimated by injury, is just not up to the task at this point. This was a winnable game, even after the two blown leads.
A reinforcement could come soon when Caleb Thielbar returns, but the Cubs will need more bullpen help. And clearly, they need a starting pitcher, or maybe more than one. It’s still several weeks until Matthew Boyd can return.
Hopefully they can hang in there until then, or until a deal or deals can be made. Fortunately, everyone else in the NL Central also lost Sunday, so the Cubs’ division lead remains at 1.5 games over the Brewers and Cardinals.
Oh, yes, one other problem with this game:
Yeah, that’s going to have to change.
Oh, speaking of the Brewers? They’ll be at Wrigley Field to open a three-game series Monday evening. Shōta Imanaga will start the opener of this series for the Cubs and Brandon Sproat goes for Milwaukee. Game time Monday is 6:40 p.m. CT and TV coverage will be via Marquee Sports Network.
