It’s a good thing Miguel Vargas is currently playing like he wants to wear an All-Star jersey in a couple of months, because something tells me the White Sox won’t be getting anything else in return for Erick Fedde when he departs the rotation this time around.
Despite what wound up being a cathartic, 9-8 victory in 10 innings, it appears likely that said departure will come sooner rather than later, given the glut of minor league pitching that needs a chance at some big league action. He just didn’t
have particularly astute command today, and his stuff simply doesn’t have the juice to get much done when his command isn’t astute. It’s not surprising that the Cubs put three runs on him before we even had a chance to blink, when you take a look at the pitches they were swinging at in the first inning.
Those are a lot of fat locations for pitches that are pretty easy to make contact with, and it’s not particularly surprising that Michael Busch managed to extend his hands on one of those outside cutters and yank a two-run homer out to right field against the breeze. Two singles and a wild pitch later, it was a 3-0 game, and any hope at a repeat of yesterday’s home side thwacking was swiftly thwarted.
Fortunately, opposite Fedde, Colin Rea wasn’t exactly a portrait of intimidation, and it took just one additional inning for the Sox to string a few hits together, as singles from Colson Montgomery, Andrew Benintendi and Edgar Quero scratched their first run across.
Unfortunately, things didn’t get a whole lot better for Fedde, who still walked two Cubs in the second inning despite bouncing back to hold them scoreless. He then appeared to be dealing with some sort of cut or blister on his throwing hand, receiving brief medical treatment between innings before allowing another walk and double in a shaky third. Finally, it all fell apart entirely in the fourth inning, as Fedde failed to record an out and was removed from the game after allowing Dansby Swanson and Nico Hoerner to reach via a single and walk.
Taking the ball from Fedde 12 years after being taken three picks ahead of him in the 2014 draft, Sean Newcomb has been generally excellent this year in taking on whatever role has been asked of him, from garbage time to LOOGY work to traditional long relief. He couldn’t quite clutch up all the way this time, letting in a run by way of a deflected ground ball back up the middle and pushing the Cubs run total to four. But he was excellent the rest of his time in the game, keeping the Cubs off the board in the rest of the fourth and fifth and giving his club a chance to chip away.
That chipping began with Newcomb still pitching, as Miguel Vargas got plunked to open the fourth and circled the bags on a double into the gap off of Benintendi’s bat, his second hit of the day.
The ability to meaningfully chip away at a deficit is not a skill that Sox offenses have possessed very much in recent years, but evidence mounts that this might finally be changing. The whipping wind was as important as any individual player in this one — according to Statcast, it robbed a would-be Ian Happ home run to right of an absurd 124 feet of distance in the third inning.
And for a minute in the fifth inning, it felt as though the White Sox were putting this one in the category of games that would be more reasonable to expect them to win next season. A would-be game-tying home run from Derek Hill, smoked off the bat at 100.4 mph at a nearly-ideal 24° launch angle, was kept in the park just enough for Pete Crow-Armstrong to get his glove on it. Munetaka Murakami’s hustle kept the inning alive with a legged-out fielder’s choice that could have been an inning-ending double play, and though it looked like Vargas was on the precipice of being a wind victim for the second time, his 103 mph line drive evaded Crow-Armstrong’s leather to tie the game at four:
Grant Taylor was nails in relief of Newcomb, facing the minimum six hitters and using just 25 pitches over two perfect innings against the top of the Cubs lineup. It was the 55th appearance of his career, which moved him into a tie with a couple of the dead ball era’s most infamous names — Carl Mays and Ed Cicotte — for the most games to start a career without allowing a home run. Bryan Hudson avoided disaster for the second time in three days, narrowly escaping a bases-loaded jam to keep things scoreless headed to the Sox half of the eighth.
Much to his credit, Benintendi came to play ball today, working a two-out walk to get Phil Maton on his toes before moving into scoring position on an Quero single and, finally, gloriously streaking home on Tristan Peters’ first big league bomb:
Then Seranthony Domínguez came on and had an easy 1-2-3 inning to secure the 8-5 win, right?
Reader, you know the answer to that question. Domínguez walking Alex Bregman to start the inning was predictable, as might have been his subsequent strikeout of Ian Happ. It also probably wouldn’t have been hard to predict that he’d be unable to bear down and stop the fire when Vargas threw away the second out of the inning and made Michael Conforto the tying run at the plate.
You know why I called Conforto the tying run at the plate, right?
Murakami gave the Sox some hope for keeping things out of extra innings with a slightly bizarre double that dropped between a tumbling Seiya Suzuki and Crow-Armstrong in the outfield, but Vargas and Chase Meidroth couldn’t bring Mune around to score. Crow-Armstrong himself started the 10th inning on second base for the North Siders, and instantly stole third with freshman righty Tyler Davis taking over for Domínguez. Crow-Armstrong eventually was thrown out trying for home on an infield-in ground ball, but it nonetheless set the table for Alex Bregman to step to the plate with the bases loaded.
Davis did his job, drawing a slowly-chopped ground ball, but it was just a hair too slow for Montgomery to have a play at the plate. Even though Davis nutted up and punched out Suzuki to end the threat, the Cubs still took a 8-7 lead to the bottom of the 10th.
It’s worth repeating, Benintendi had a hell of a game, capping off his afternoon with a perfectly executed sacrifice bunt to move the tying run to third — perfectly executed enough that it rather irritated me when he couldn’t beat it out and make himself the winning run.
Fortunately, it didn’t matter, because as I was typing up my message of complaint into the South Side Sox slack, Quero made it all a moot point. Given the slight reported setback in Kyle Teel’s rehab assignment, Quero couldn’t have possibly picked a better time to escape from the malaise that’s plagued his bat all season. What started out as a sure game-tying sac fly kept carrying into the seats, for a game-winning home run:
Even with every game spent with a winning record this season being house money, failing to come back and win this game would have been tough to swallow. But the win wraps up Chicago’s longest homestand of the season, and one that undoubtedly brought some of the best vibes Rate Field has seen in years despite a couple of highly-avoidable losses.
Their schedule has them on a plane to the West Coast as I write, where they’re set to take on Seattle for a trio of nightcaps Monday through Wednesday. Tomorrow will be the most challenging start of Noah Schultz’s young career, as he’ll see a potentially potent Seattle lineup for the second time in 10 days opposite All-Star Bryan Woo. First pitch is at 8:40 p.m. CT, and I’ll be there to watch and recap it with you!
