We have been doing this for a few years now: looking at the top free agents, using the contract Ben Clemens suggests he’ll get, and asking whether you would like the Jays to give him that contract. This year, the lockout makes it a little more complicated. Keith Law’s list is here. Ben Clemens’is here.
Number six on FanGraphs list and also number six on Keith Law’s list is Freddy Peralta.
Peralta is a 30-year-old (31 in June), right-handed pitcher, who has had nine years in the MLB. Last year was split
between the Mets (where things didn’t go well, 4.99 ERA in 22 starts) and the Rays (where things did go well, 3.25 ERA in 10 starts. In 2025 he led the NL with 17 wins and had a 2.70 ERA in 176.2 innings. Generally, he’s been well over a strikeout an inning, but in 2026 he had 156 strikeouts in 169.0 innings. His strikeout rate was 21.4% in 2026, 28.2% in 2025, which would worry me about his future. He did lose half a mile per hour on his fastball.
Among the things Keith Law said:
He limits hard contact and tries to live on the edges of the zone, so his walk rates have hovered at the higher end of what’s acceptable in a starter, and that would be my main concern in going long-term with Peralta (aside from the whole pitchers-breaking part). If his stuff tapers off in his early to mid-30s, he’ll need better command and control to make this formula work. I assume he’s getting four years, if not more, and will be paid like the 3-4 WAR pitcher he was in 2025, at least, which is probably in the $30 million a year range.
Ben Clemens:
Peralta presents a real models versus eyeballs test at the top of the list. He has always felt more ace-y than his numbers would suggest, and he had a down season heading into free agency, which will give suitors pause. I know it’s popular to talk about how the Rays “fixed” him after the Mets “broke” him, but I think that’s reading too much into small samples. Peralta has always succeeded with a pile of whiffs and strikeouts. His lowest full-season strikeout rate before 2026 was 27.1%, but he was at 22.1% on the Mets and 19.7% on the Rays, with career lows in every bat-missing category you can imagine. His feel-good playoff run came with 10 walks and 16 strikeouts in 21 ⅓ innings. Teams won’t ignore his production over the past decade, but the warning lights put him the lowest in this trio of second bananas for me.
Ben figures he will get a 4-year contract at $23 million per. I’m not sure I’d want him for four years, but I think that’s what it will take.













