The easiest way for the Mariners to get markedly better is probably the least likely.
Let me say off the top that I don’t really follow the offseason rumor mill. I don’t know which rumors are legitimate and which have been debunked. I have no sources. I am completely useless.
But that doesn’t mean I’m not willing to make a meal of something that doesn’t exist. It’s projection season after all, and we’re starting to get a sense for what the computers think of the Mariners roster ahead of 2027. So far,
so good. FanGraphs Depth Charts, the site’s premier projection system, opened with the Mariners at a familiar 88-90 wins. At this point in the offseason, with more than 150 WAR still available in free agency, that’s enough to give them the third best roster in majors.
Now, Depth Charts gives the Mariners about three wins more than my recent napkin math, and 15 wins more than the active roster produced in 2026. It’s understandable if you don’t trust these projections — I don’t quite either. The computers are simply offering a hedge against the pessimism that’s built up around the organization the last six months. The core of this roster has earned the benefit of the doubt, statistically.
So what can we expect this offseason?
We can see the Mariners are almost exactly where they were entering 2026. It’s a roster that should be favored in a middling AL West, even if it’s unlikely to win an extraordinary number of games. This is the sweet spot we’ve come to expect from the Mariners, where they can be competitive each year without having to leverage much future value to do so. They can have their cake and it eat in perpetuity, even if that cake is unfrosted and stale.
That’s why I expect a fairly quiet offseason. I assume the team has similar numbers, and I don’t think they see themselves quite as far from competition as many fans and pundits do. My expectation is they’ll inch above last year’s projection by raising their floor with players like Dylan Crews, Alesia Vesia, and Kevin Ginkel, rather than commit significant resources toward the next rung on the ladder.
Again, I’m not an insider, and this is just speculation based on how they’ve operated this decade. And I’m sure the front office will make interesting offers to interesting players, as they always do. I just don’t see why this is the year they’ll abandon the wisdom of their economists and offer the type of margin-breaking, above-and-beyond packages that are required to land the biggest names. I think they’ll stick to what got them here, wherever you think that may be.
But… if they did want to make a big deal, what should that be? The plot below shows the Mariners relative to league average at each position on the x-axis, and the amount of projected WAR below the top five on the y-axis.
The Mariners rate as average or above at every position but two: shortstop and left field. I have some quibbles, of course — remember, I’m 5-10% more pessimistic on this roster than FanGraphs. I’m not quite buying Brendan Donovan as the 10th best third baseman in the majors. I’m also lower on the pitching staff than most. Still, this is a team without too many true blackholes. Whatever you think about Donovan at third (or Bryce Miller or Matt Brash or Michael Arroyo or whoever), most teams have worse and less believable options at those positions. The Astros, for instance, are below average at six positions, including starting pitcher, where they’re 6 WAR off the top five. The Mariners, for all their faults, are well rounded.
The one exception is at shortstop. That’s where the Mariners have a massive question mark in Colt Emerson. He’s still a great prospect, he’s still likely to be a good major leaguer, and he’s still guaranteed quite a bit of money between now and the mid-2030s. But his rookie season raises questions about his health and performance in the near term,, and there isn’t any institutional depth behind him for contingency. The Mariners must do something to address the position this offseason.
It’s worth considering if that something should be a big thing, or even a really, really big thing. We can see in the plot above that not only are the Mariners projected to be below average at the position, but they’re two full wins from the top five. Shortstop is a crucial position in the WAR games because it’s one of the easiest places to separate from the pack, and having a great one could push a “good” team like the Mariners to legitimate World Series contenders.
It just so happens there are great shortstops rumored to be available this offseason. Elly De La Cruz is one such name. He is the fourth best projected player in the majors for 2027 and would give the Mariners three of the top 15 by Depth Charts. If he came to Seattle today, he would bring five additional wins and give the Mariners the best roster in the majors.
Then there’s Gunnar Henderson. He’s projected as the 11th best player in baseball, right between Julio and Cal. That’s fitting because all three will be looking for a bounce back next year. For a team built around having two star batters at premium positions, there’s no better hedge than having a third star batter at a premium position. Again, if Gunnar came to Seattle today, he would fundamentally change what we think about this roster ahead of 2027.
There’s also Otto Lopez and Jeremy Peña, who are worse, and Zach Neto and CJ Abrams, who are shortstops in so much as Bryce Miller is a starting pitcher. These players would no doubt make the Mariners better, but they don’t quite move the needle like Elly and Gunnar.
Of course, Elly and Gunnar are not free agents. They would each subtract good players from the major league roster, and subtract some nebulous amount of future value from the farm system. The first question that comes to mind when considering what either player might cost is, “Why would the Reds or Orioles trade club-controlled stars?” Making either deal would require massive amounts of talent going the other way. We’ve never seen the front office take on a true blockbuster like this. We’ve never seen them take such risk. I’ll believe it when I see it.
To be clear, the Mariners don’t need to operate this “efficiently.” Shortstop is the easiest place to add big wins, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t wins available elsewhere. Seiya Suzuki makes them better, even if there isn’t a lot to gain in left field. Teruaki Sato makes them better, even if there isn’t a lot to gain at whatever position he plays. Adrian Morejon makes them better, even if relievers are relievers are relievers. There’s plenty of relative risks the Mariners can take, even if the rewards are notably smaller.
But if the front office is ready to take its first (and potentially last) big swing, to take the risk they’ve spent the last six or 12 or however many years avoiding, to truly go for it, then a blockbuster deal for a shortstop is a good step toward greatness.













