The Pittsburgh Pirates outfield in 2026 had a few consistent pieces, but overall this was a group that saw a lot of turnover and a lot of opportunities for young players to prove their worth.
The mainstays
One of the more impressive stat lines this year has to do with the former All-Star Bryan Reynolds. At age 31 Reynolds completed another season with consistent solid production, and he did all of that while also appearing in 162 games for the first time in his career. Reynolds was the first Pirate to play in all 162 contests
since Jason Bay completed that feat in 2005. He was also just one of seven major leaguers to achieve that in 2026. As he tends to do, Reynolds once again quietly put together a solid campaign that included 17 home runs and a .261 batting average.
It’s unfortunate that Oneil Cruz dealt with the injuries that he did in 2026 because he was on pace to have an absolutely monster season. Cruz initially landed on the 10-day IL for a hand fracture but was then upgraded to the 60-day, thus limiting his action to just 97 games, his lowest amount of appearances since 2023. Despite the time he missed he still finished with one of his finest statistical seasons to date. Across the board his slash line was much improved as he hit .280/.368/.486 with a .854 OPS. Not to mention he hit 20 or more home runs for the third straight season and also had 30 or more stolen bases for the second straight year.
New blood to keep and build with
It was a huge surprise when Esmerlyn Valdez stepped on the major league scene and started tearing the covers off of baseballs. He quickly became a powerful fixture in Pittsburgh’s lineup notching 17 home runs in his rookie season. Be that as it may he did dramatically cool off after his hot July, and looked lost at times in August and September. However, very few have come out firing like that in their rookie year and there’s reason to keep Valdez around and develop him into a better every day hitter for the Pirates. Valdez took home National League Rookie Of The Month honors for July.
Jake Mangum proved to be a great spark plug at times for the Buccos. He was awarded the team’s Heart and Hustle Award in 2026, and certainly embodies the qualities that it takes to receive that honor. Mangum finished his second major league season with a slash line of .276/.331/.363 and set new career highs for homers, triples, doubles and total bases. He did strike out 29 more times this season compared to last with the nearly 20 more appearances, but overall Mangum was reliable down the stretch, and should certainly be brought back in 2027.
Additional pieces who may or may not be with Pittsburgh in 2027
Several other fringe players made appearances in the outfield for the Pirates in 2026, but outside of Jhostynxon Garcia many of them will likely be relegated back to the minor leagues or shipped off to other organizations.
Garcia remains the outlier because of his age. At just 23-years-old Garcia still has time to develop into the player that he was projected to be when the Boston Red Sox signed him in 2019 out of Venezuela. In 2026 he battled injuries and was up and down the Pirates’ organization, and only ended up appearing in Pittsburgh for 20 games. In that span he was unremarkable. While he was very successful at the minor league ranks this season, he had a lowly .167 batting average at the major league level and had 16 strikeouts in 48 at-bats. He’s shown that he has the pop and explosiveness to succeed at the next level, he just hasn’t been able to put all those pieces together to this point.
The real fringe players were guys like Tyler Calihan, Billy Cook and Ronny Simon. At this point in their careers something catastrophic would have to happen for them to be brought on as full time outfielders for a major league organization . Calihan and Cook are both already 27-years old and are largely career minor leaguers. Cook did appear in 87 games for Pittsburgh this season which is by far the most major league action he’s seen in his career, but he was overall a below average ballplayer.
Callihan was traded for in early March and saw action in 40 major league contests this year and was mostly average. He slashed .211/.283/.389 with a .672 OPS. Not a bad player, but certainly more of a rotational piece than a mainstay.
Simon is another career minor league player and only appeared in 21 games for the Pirates in 2026. He certainly wasn’t bad, and did seem to make the most of his opportunity, but he will not be viewed in the same light as a guy like Valdez who will almost definitely be on the big league roster in 2027.
Ryan O’Hearn, Jared Triolo and Nick Yorke also had their fair share of appearances in the outfield, but were more prominently used in the team’s infield.
The Pirates’s outfield has a good foundation, and could be viewed as great with one above average rotational piece and a fully healthy season from Cruz.
