Just one week after Rutgers was held scoreless against Nebraska, the Scarlet Knights pulled off an impossible upset over Penn State, taking down the Nittany Lions 25-24 in one of the most incredible victories in program history. Although my analysis will not do this win its justice, here is everything that led up to the final result.
First Half: Defensive Plays Lead To Offensive Opportunity
The Rutgers defense came up with multiple fourth-down stops and big plays in the first half to keep the team in the game. One of the critical sequences came at the end
of a Penn State drive that lasted over eight minutes but came up empty at the goal line.
With first-and-goal from the one-yard line, Cam Wallace was stuffed for no gain before Rocco Becht was brought down in the backfield for a sack by Sekou Kromah and RJ Johnson Jr. for a three-yard loss. Wallace was able to pick up three of the yards back, setting up fourth and goal from the one, but the quarterback sneak was read perfectly as Sean Allison combined with Rondo Porter to hold the Nittany Lions out of the end zone.
The Knights repeated the sequence on the next drive following the safety, with Penn State being stopped on a fourth-and-one at the Rutgers 29-yard line. Allison converged with Kromah to stuff Wallace and give the offense the football back. Surace moved the football, but was ultimately sacked on fourth-down at the Lions’ 33.
Special teams played a role in jumpstarting Rutgers’ first touchdown drive, with offsetting penalties on the kickoff following Penn State’s second touchdown forcing a re-kick that Ja’Shon Benjamin returned 25 yards to start the drive at the 45-yard line. The gunners came forward to make good open-field tackles, which included Dylan Braithwaite swallowing up Zay Robinson for no gain early in the half and Dino Kaliakmanis making a tackle later, which was celebrated by Greg Schiano.
Surace found Houston for a 14-yard pass to get the offense into Nittany Lion territory for the first time, but the big play was Antwan Raymond going up the middle for a 33-yard gain, which set up first-and-goal from the two-yard line. Despite Penn State’s defenders making a tackle for a three-yard loss, Raymond rushed right and found the end zone to get the Knights on the board.
The biggest play came on the next drive, with Kromah delivering a huge strip-sack on Becht and punching the ball out, which was recovered at the PSU 43-yard line. Surace worked the two-minute offense, finding Logan Blake over the middle for 13 yards, before finding Jourdin Houston for an eight-yard gain.
An unsportsmanlike penalty on Penn State cornerback Josiah Zayas set up first-and-goal from the nine-yard line, and Rutgers got inside the five, but Zayas knocked down a well-thrown pass intended for Houston in the end zone. The Knights wisely took the points, and Jack Scullion converted the chip-shot field goal to bring Rutgers within six points, trailing 16-10 at halftime.
Of course, it was not all perfect, as the defense still allowed big plays, including a 56-yard rushing touchdown by Cam Wallace to open the scoring, a 36-yard pass from Becht to Robinson, a 27-yard pass to tight end Benjamin Brahmer, and a 17-yard pass to Chase Sowell for the second Nittany Lion touchdown.
Second Half: Rutgers Fights Back To Pull The Stunning Upset
The second half did not start well for the Scarlet Knights as they went three-and-out, but a dropped ball fumble from Cam Wallace was recovered by Allison. The offense went backwards and ended up punting after a false start on a field goal and the offense coming out being negated by slow substitutions by the Penn State defense.
The Rutgers defense continued to play hard, forcing another punt, but with Surace taking a sack deep in Knights’ territory, the Nittany Lions flipped the field and started the drive at the Rutgers’ 49. With Becht finding Sowell for a 43-yard pass, the quarterback took it in himself on a well-designed draw play before catching a pass from Benjamin Brahmer to put Penn State up 24-10.
On the next drive, Rutgers went 75 yards on 19 plays to answer the Lions’ score and cut the game back to a seven-point margin. Surace stood tall in the pocket and continued to deliver timely passes, while Kirk Ciarocca mixed a healthy dose of Antwan Raymond in the run game to keep the chains moving.
Even after Surace took a brutal sack from Tony Rojas, he was able to find Dyzier Carter on a fourth-and-ten, the second fourth-down conversion of the drive before Raymond converted on fourth-and-two from 16 yards out to cut the deficit to one touchdown.
The defense continued to get stops, with the defensive line and linebackers continuing to bottle up the run game, and the offense was not able to get too far as another sack on Surace appeared to slam the door on a Knights’ comeback. But the Rutgers defense stood tall one more time, with Allison and Walker leading the charge before Devonte Anderson broke up the third-down pass to give the offense one more chance.
With 3:28 left in the game, Surace found Vernon Allen III for a drive-starting 13-yard pickup, and Raymond had a reception and carry to cross midfield and set up Rutgers with a fighting chance at the two-minute warning. A pass interference penalty moved the Knights 15 yards closer, and Black and Carter caught passes to move Rutgers to the 11-yard line of Penn State.
The comeback attempt appeared to have fallen short with a two-yard run from Raymond preceding two incompletions by Surace and another one on fourth down. But Penn State cornerback Audavion Collins was called for his second pass interference of the drive to give Rutgers first-and-goal from the three-yard line.
One heroic sequence later, Antwan Raymond appeared to be tackled near the goal line, but smartly lateraled it to Black who crossed into the end zone for the improbable touchdown. And the screen pass from Surace to Thevenin had no issues converting as the Scarlet Knights stole one of the most improbable wins this century.
Everything Went Right in a Season When Nothing Seemed To
The same team that dropped their opening game to UMass as 29.5-point favorites pulled off the monumental upset over a Penn State team that was on a three-game win streak and favored by 25.5 points.
Everything went right tonight. The defense came up with multiple fourth-down stops early, but it all appeared to be for nothing when the Knights went down 16-0 early following a safety in which Rutgers ran shotgun from their own end zone.
Even when Rutgers was down 16-10, Penn State got a big touchdown and somehow, someway, Rutgers put together one of the longest drives in program history to cut the game to one score. The defense would not let Penn State escape through the air or on the ground and continued to give the offense chances.
And the final drive will be one for the books. With Raymond lateraling the ball back to Black and the gutsy two-point conversion putting the Knights over the top, Rutgers football snapped their long losing streak to Penn State and came up with the win in Happy Valley.
For all the technical analysis I can provide, this game belongs to the team, the fans, and everyone invested in this program. Because we deserved this one. The Scarlet Knights have defeated Penn State for the first time since 1988, snapping an 18-game losing streak, and after all, have defeated a team that nobody thought they would.
To support me and my work, please follow @arnavsarkar1000 on X!













