Last week, the much-discussed College Football Playoff Expansion finally became official, with the playoffs expanded to 24 teams starting in 2027.
While the additional teams are getting the big headlines, equal attention should be given to the new details about the new scheduling standards for teams to be considered, or likely even qualify, for the playoffs.
Nicole Auerbach has a good summary of things here:
There are positives from
this. It’s nice to lay out some consistency in scheduling to prevent some uneven playing fields for teams. While no team’s schedule is the same as another’s, there is at least common ground in the types of teams they schedule.
Limiting all FBS teams to a maximum of one FCS game to be considered is great, although banning FCS teams on the schedule at all may have been a better move for everyone except FCS teams, of course. They stand to be hurt as their budgets may take a hit from fewer buy games. Although maybe that is why one FCS game was able to remain on the schedule as a compromise of sorts. Blue bloods still get a warm-up game, and FCS schools get the fat check they desperately need to keep the lights on in their programs.
The hope is that with an expanded field, teams won’t be as hesitant to play a quality non-conference game, because a tough loss won’t be the end of the season.
Also, it’s nice that the scheduling qualifications are the same for both FBS groupings. It’s fair for everyone to prioritize scheduling the best competition they can outside of their conference and for the committee to reward those who schedule well, even if they drop a game (or two) as long as they pick up some quality wins.
On the other hand, there are a few issues with this that don’t fit neatly into a social media graphic.
For starters, out-of-conference schedules are often hard to predict, as they are scheduled years in advance. Take a program like UNLV, which is now going to its fourth straight bowl game. They played a top mid-major program in Memphis this season, and although they lost, it was an awesome Week 0 matchup and one that had immediate CFP implications. The two teams are playing one another again in 2029, hoping for the same stakes then. But who knows how good either program will be next season, let alone in three years. This has always been the drawback of scheduling games so far in advance, and it won’t be solved by these scheduling standards.
Also, if everyone is scheduling as well as they can, that inevitably means that some teams will be left out and not have quality opponents to play. It is almost certain that this will directly impact Group of 6 teams. The more traditional college football blue bloods will schedule more games against one another, or at least other P4 programs, which means their schedules won’t have room to include the top mid-major programs. And those kinds of games were hard to come by before; they may be nonexistent going forward.
All of this was definitely intentional. However, is there another aspect of all this that negatively impacts G6 teams? And if so, is that intentional too?
With fewer opportunities for schools from the Group of 6 to play Power 4 teams, the next best option is for the top mid-major teams to play one another as frequently as possible. Hopefully we can see home-and-home games featuring the top G6 conferences in September. Memphis played UNLV and Boise State this season. It didn’t work out for them, as the Tigers went 1-1 in those games, but they should get credit for their bold scheduling, and the sport is better for it.
Imagine Boise State alternating between New Mexico and USF every season while North Dakota State has a home-and-home with Oregon State. Quality teams playing quality games before embarking on their conference schedules.
However, it’s hard not to imagine some ulterior motives in this design.
As the number of teams who make the CFP is expanding going forward, the number of guaranteed spots for the Group of 6 is not. If this format had existed over the past decade or so, it’s likely we would have seen multiple Group of 6 teams crack the top 24 and thus make the playoffs. Going forward, that would mean one of those teams should get into the playoffs as an at-large bid, with another automatically qualifying in the guaranteed spot.
But if those teams play one another at the start of the year, does that limit the ceiling of how high they can get in the rankings? Especially if they have another non-conference game or two against other solid G6 teams.
The point being, if top G6 teams play each other in the OOC schedule, there’s a good chance they beat one another up a bit. And by doing so, it ensures that there’s only one mid-major team that ends up in the rankings, rather than multiple.
Perhaps that is accurate, or perhaps that is a tinfoil hat conspiracy, but it appears within the realm of possibility. And unfortunately, we have been trained to look for ways for Power 4 supporters to put down their Group of 6 peers. And if it’s possible, it won’t be long until a biased committee member or two attempts to exploit it to maintain the status quo between the haves and have-nots.
More marquee September games between good teams are great for the sport. Using that as a reason to shut G6 teams who might have an extra loss to their name is not. Regardless of the motives, we will see how this theory plays out in the years to come.













