Germany has made it through the World Cup group stage, but the knockout rounds present an entirely different challenge. With the margin for error now razor-thin, one of the biggest tactical questions facing Julian Nagelsmann is whether it is time to move Joshua Kimmich back into his natural midfield role.
Germany legend Lothar Matthäus has been among those calling for the switch, arguing that Kimmich’s qualities are best utilized in the center of the pitch. His ability to dictate the tempo, break
up opposition attacks, and pick out line-breaking passes has made him one of the world’s best midfielders for years. Against stronger opponents, having Kimmich controlling the middle could give Germany a significant advantage.
The problem, however, is what happens at right-back.
Unlike previous tournaments, Germany does not have a natural right-back in the squad ready to step in. Nagelsmann would likely have to rely on a makeshift option such as Waldemar Anton, Malick Thiaw, or Nathaniel Brown. Each brings different strengths, but none offers Kimmich’s combination of experience, positioning, and ability to contribute going forward from the flank.
That creates a genuine dilemma. Does Germany become stronger overall by improving the midfield, or does it weaken the back line too much by removing one of its most dependable defenders from right-back?
Do you agree with Matthäus — should Julian Nagelsmann move Kimmich back into midfield for the knockout rounds, even if it means trusting Anton, Thiaw, or Brown at right-back?
Let us know your thoughts in the comments.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- New, improved notifications system!
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
