David Elliott says…
Xhaka is going to be a miss even though he hasn’t hit the heights of last season.
He remains a big presence on the field and he never hides. He also plays a key role in anchoring the midfield, always being available for the ball and providing dangerous crosses. That said, Jules Ahoka should provide more energy although we must beware not to put too much pressure on his young shoulders. He’s an able replacement but I think we need to use him and other midfielders carefully to manage the workload.
Brobbey’s
injury is a real body blow.
He looks so good upfront; his hold up play is coming on leaps and bounds and he’s a genuine threat. Defences are definitely scared of him and that provides opportunities around him as a result. I love Wilson Isidor but feel we haven’t given him a fair chance so far.
We need to be more adaptable in our build up so that we can use his pace in the channels or behind defenders. Perhaps we should also consider using two of our wingers at the same time before I’m sure Chemsdine Talbi, Nilson Angulo, Malick Fofana and Jocelin Ta Bi could all cause problems for the opposition.
Jon Guy says…
Xhaka will be a miss as I still think his impact on the side when he’s in the middle of the park can be significant given how young some of the players are.
That said he’s lost a little of his spark in recent games and it’s likely that Régis Le Bris will go with more pace in the middle. Given that we look best when we close with intensity and counter at pace, fresh legs at this stage of the season might be a bonus given the amount of games in the run up to the new year.
Brobbey has been immense and gives us so much when he’s on his game, and the opposition centre backs are normally both focused on the big man. We had this problem with Ross Stewart — a catalyst for the team but with a season ticket to the treatment room.
Wilson Isidor is likely to start and if so, we need to play to his strengths and recognise we can’t expect him to hold the ball up.
It means a different shape and style when we have the ball, and we need to bring in a decent striking option in January.
Malc Dugdale says…
This is one up and one down for me.
Xhaka needed a rest irrespective of the injury, and this is a great chance for the team to build from the Chelsea performance, and to progress options for longer time life without him.
It’ll mean we need to be creative to rotate our midfield between the Premier League, Europe and the cups, but sometimes injuries bring opportunities for the team and certain players and I hope this is one that we benefit from.
The other side of the story is that without Brobbey, we’re reliant on a hungry but immature contribution from Timur Tuteriov, and the pacy but less effective leading of the line from Wilson Isidor.
That said, Brobbey has been immense but a little inaccurate with chances of late — which is potentially down to his frequent visits to the physio’s room.
We’ll miss him massively in terms of his hold up play and physicality but we have a squad for a reason, and again if this gives Isidor a run of games supported by Tuteriov, who knows? We may see a couple of people down the pecking order grab the chance too.
Owen Sara says…
Losing Xhaka provides a superb opportunity for Jules Ahoka to nail down a starting spot.
It’s too early to judge whether the loss of Xhaka allowed us to play with the handbrake off against Chelsea. Does this make the players braver and less scared to make a mistake? He’ll still be a voice around the dressing room and the training ground and will no doubt give us some tactical advice, too. We should certainly play with a bit more energy and pace through the middle.
We’ve already seen the drop off without Brobbey and missing someone with such unique physical output will leave a gaping hole in any team.
When we’re so used to playing a certain way with Brobbey, it’s not just a case of flipping the switch and instantly playing a different way. With that said, Wilson Isidor seemed to enjoy games against the Villa last season, and teams may not be set up to play against without having Brobbey to defend against.
Timur Tuteriov should still be full of confidence and we can still cause teams problems but the onus is on Régis Le Bris to make us more potent in attack and set us up to get attacking players involved in and around the eighteen-yard box to give us more threats across the park.
Phil West says…
Given Jules Ahoka’s remarkable rise to prominence, I feel that Xhaka’s absence — although not ideal in terms of robbing us of depth as well as the experience he brings — can be dealt with.
If the DR Congo international and his teammates can raise their games to match the demands of Aston Villa and beyond, I think we can perhaps start to develop a style of play based on greater dynamism and forward motion in midfield. It’ll also enable our captain to rest up, recover and possibly get back to somewhere near his most effective after an underwhelming season so far.
Xhaka’s form has long been a concern but for the moment, we need to adapt, get on with things and place our faith in the likes of Ahoka, who looks perfectly suited to this level, it must be said.
However, trying to cope without Brobbey — a player that, had he been standing on the bow of the Titanic in 1912, the iceberg that caused the great ship to founder would’ve thought “To hell with this. I’m not messing with him. I’ll find another ship to sink” — will be far more challenging, and I’m not entirely convinced we will.
Are Wilson Isidor and/or Timur Tuteriov going to bully defenders, hold the ball up, bring others into play and draw fouls with the same kind of potency as the Dutch striker? Unlikely, although slightly paradoxically, Isidor is a more composed and natural finisher than Brobbey and can certainly score goals at this level, as we’ve seen previously.
Bringing the best out of him will demand a new approach; for Sunderland to play at a higher tempo and for the likes of Enzo Le Fée to spot his runs and slide the ball into gaps for the Haitian international to run onto.
This was showcased at Villa Park last season when Isidor drew us level at 3-3, and if he gets the opportunity to impress in Brobbey’s absence, I hope we don’t try and deploy him as a clone of the former Ajax striker, but that we play to his strengths and attempt to get him into the heart of the action as often as possible.
More questions for Régis Le Bris to answer. Let’s hope he can.
Tom Albrighton says…
Unfortunately for Sunderland, I don’t think you can put a positive spin on either of these injuries.
Whilst Xhaka has struggled for form this season and is perhaps in need of a break, his influence on the squad behind the scenes as well as on the pitch is no secret.
With an already threadbare midfield, Xhaka’s absence will heap further pressure on those who are available, giving those in the middle little respite before the gruelling slog of the December and January fixtures.
As for Brobbey, yet another period on the sidelines is good for neither the team or for himself, especially given how crucial his physicality is when Sunderland play at their most effective.
With open-play goals for the Lads being as rare as hens’ teeth this season, losing Brobbey’s presence is undoubtedly a blow. This is perhaps exacerbated by Wilson Isidor’s tendency to score in bursts and if Isidor can’t hit the ground running over the coming weeks, further concerns will arise in Brobbey’s absence.
Opportunities will of course come to those on the fringes, wth Jules Ahoka, Timur Tutierov and Juan Angulo standing to be beneficiaries of such absences in terms of increased game time, and whilst many will be relaxed on the prospect of Ahoka receiving further minutes, the same may not be said for others given the precariousness of our league position.
All in all, this is a case of two bad injuries at a bad time for us — at a time when our backs already feel firmly up against the wall. The only real hope we have is that in during trying times is when we usually see the best of Régis Le Bris.













