The Pittsburgh Penguins have played a nice round 20 games so far this season, though the results have not been so nice with a 7-11-2 record that features only three regulation wins. That nice round marker, plus a four-day break between games offers a chance to get reflective about where the team is right now with a look at how the grades go.
As you might guess, we’re taking expectations and role into account to tailor each grade to each player.
Forwards
Evgeni Malkin, 18 games (6 goals, 11 assists) A-: 17 points
in 18 games for the 40-year old, Malkin has 11 assists and no other forward on the team has over seven. He’s only been to the penalty box five times in those 17 games, which is always a welcome indicator that his game is in a good spot when he’s avoiding taking frequent stick fouls. Doesn’t seem to be much muss or fuss if he’s on the first or second power play, the first or second line, he’s just been good at whatever he’s been asked to do so far.
Tommy Novak, 20 games (8G+7A) A-: There’s a case to be made that Novak has been the team’s best and most consistent forward all season long. That is better news for Novak than it is for the team, since obviously when a player like Novak is in contention for ‘best on the team’, that’s probably not a very good team (and, well, it hasn’t been). His 33.3% work in the faceoff circle means he really can’t be a center, though the team has little choice but to place him there more often than not.
Nick Robertson 20 games (7G+0A) B+: The seven goals are great, the grade starts with a B mainly because of his usage (averaging just over 13 minutes per game, mostly in a fourth line and PK role). That’s not really what you want to see from him, not that it’s the player’s responsibility for how he’s been used. Robertson’s also been on the ice for a forward-high five goals against while shorthanded, which may or may not be all his fault, but sounds like an indicator that trying to make a goal-scoring winger into a two-way player isn’t the best usage, leaning more into his strong points to generate offense would be.
Ben Kindel 17 games (4G+5A) B-: It’s great to have Kindel back after his medical incident. At times, he’s been very good this season. At other times, he’s been in the background too much. You’d like to see a little more, but there’s enough there to believe he’s on his way. Luckily, lately he’s been used as more of a second line center with offensively talented linemates, that’s a good start.
Hendrix Lapierre 15 games (2G+5A) C: I mean, he’s been fine? Lapierre isn’t going to blow anyone away. He can pitch in a little bit with his skating and when he’s holding onto pucks in the offensive zone. Decent enough as a depth power play type of option, not moving the needle excessively in either direction. He’s the kind of guy who can be scratched or play in a game, and most of the time you wouldn’t notice it either way until deep into the game.
Sidney Crosby, 20 games (6G+7A) C-: Father Time is always undefeated, it hurts all the same to see a bite get taken out of Crosby. In some ways, he’s playing better than the stats indicate (56.6% expected goals percent at 5v5) and has missed out on a couple points here and there. It’s jarring to see him get outscored (14-17 at 5v5) and only have seven 5v5 points through 20 games. Beyond the numbers, seeing Crosby’s decline for either getting to pucks or having the lightning fast hand-eye and vision combo to make plays erode is more frightening than any stat or metric. That’s what time does, ideally you’d hope for a better second quarter of the season than what he did in the first – and there’s encouraging signs in that his second 10 game sample had a lot better play than those first 10 games.
Rickard Rakell 20 games (6G+5A) C-: Rakell started slow last year (five goalsin his first 20 games played) and then went on to score 19 in his last 40 games, the Pens will have to be hoping he can follow that script again this season. The shots have been there for Rakell (his 37 5v5 shots lead all forwards), the finishing hasn’t, yet. With his talent and track record, better days are likely ahead at some point soon.
Ville Koivunen 16 games (2G+4A) C-: Oh Ville Koivunen, what are we going to do with you? He’s been all over the map, the team has clearly given him a long leash and some patience to play his way into the big contract he was given. To which, there’s nothing wrong with that, you have to find out if this 23-year old who has succeeded in the AHL can do it in the big league. That only comes through time and chances, and he’s gotten it. Koivunen’s been a healthy scratch and ineffective at times, it’s hard to say he’s really taken the opportunity and run with it, but it hasn’t been all bad either. Not a glowing endorsement.
Connor Dewar 20 games (2G+3A) C-: I did really like Dewar (and Blake Lizotte) in the first handful of games this season, which helps salvage the grade to this point, but the last 10ish games haven’t been great. On one hand, the process and results are pretty good, the score at 5v5 is 8-6 with Dewar on the ice with a 55.5% xGF%. Given the defensive-oriented role, that’s great. He’s also had no points in the last eight games and is trending well under the 14 goal, 30 point season from last year to where it feels like there’s something missing so far and more that he could be contributing.
Blake Lizotte 20 games (0G+5A) C-: Pretty much all of Dewar’s writeup can go here for Lizotte, with the addition Lizotte’s faceoff percentage has been trending down (51.0% in his first season with the Pens, 50.0% last season and now just 44.1%). I’m sure he’ll probably score 3-4 goals in a 7-8 game stretch and correct the goose egg in that column at some point, but at this point the team could use a little better out of him.
Egor Chinakhov 16 games (3G+3A) D: As I wrote in a recent recap, I do believe Chinakhov’s breakout is coming and that he’s playing better than the stats indicate, but at some point you have to measure against results. Many were thinking/hoping Chinakhov could score 30 or 35 goals this season. He’s on pace for 13 with the season almost 1/4 of the way done. That’s disappointing. I do think he can and maybe will turn it around, but so far his season has been more “Columbus Chinakhov” than “2026 Pittsburgh Chinakhov” and that’s a big concern.
Andrei Kuzmenko 12 games (0G+1A) F: The desire to be understanding about his personal circumstances make this a tough call that brings no joy in writing, but Kuzmenko’s season has been a total bust. He’s always had skating limitations that now look incompatible with the speed of the NHL game. Who knows how or if he can come back from this given how poor it’s been. You gotta feel for him but it’s just not working.
Bryan Rust 7 games (3G+2A) Incomplete: Missing time with injuries is a way of life for Rust, sucks since he’s so capable when playing.
Justin Brazeau 6 games (1G+0A) Incomplete: For now we’ll give Brazeau some grace as he works back from injury. Some of the numbers under the hood (getting outscored 2-5, a 44.6% xGF%) are not looking promising.
Elmer Soderblom 6 games (0G+1A) Incomplete: He’s been a non-factor and is now hurt, this has not been a good season for Soderblom so far. Once he gets healthy he probably needs to pick it up a full notch or two in order to be a lineup regular, and possibly stay on the team’s roster at all.
Defense
Kaedan Korczak 20 games (0G+10A) B+: This team doesn’t have a lot of pleasant surprises, Korczak certainly is one of the few bright spots. He’s big, can skate, can move the puck and is competent positionally. He’s never going to be a headliner but he is settling into a nice role.
Kris Letang 20 games (1G+9A) B+: Surprisingly, Letang has been aging gracefully in a lower pair role. His goals allowed (1.8 per 60 at 5v5) is the lowest on the team for regular defensemen (then again, so too is his GF of 1.65 per 60 coming in the lowest).
Erik Karlsson 20 games (3G+16A) B-: Going by stats, it looks deceivingly good for Karlsson. His defensive work has been poor and some levels are among the worst in the league, highlighted by the whopping 24 5v5 goals he’s been on the ice for in just 20 games. His passing has been inconsistent and more like 2023-25 Karlsson than the 2026 version of the player who put the team on his back. He’s also had to play with several different partners, in part because they haven’t found a right fit there.
Sam Girard 17 games (2G+6A) C+: Girard’s game can sometimes be a lot of sound and fury that doesn’t equate to much when he overskates and tries his spin move, but he’s done fairly well. The team needs him to be more of a top guy than he truly is capable of, but he definitely is at least an NHL caliber player and the blueline doesn’t always have a lot of that.
Spencer Stastney 15 games (0G+3A) C: He’s been fine, not great but usually devoid of critical mistakes. There is a reason Stastney is more of a 6/7 type of player and at times gets elevated into a bigger role than he should be in, but someone has to log those minutes for the team.
Declan Carlile 20 games (3G+3A) D: The results (4.1 GA per 60 at 5v5) are killing Carlile. He probably should never have been on the first pair to start the season, but again, someone has to play there. The team is generating a lot of offense with Carlile on the ice (3.3 expected per 60 and 2.9 actual, both among the leaders on the team) but the results the other way have been backbreaking too frequently with it looking like his decision making and positioning have been bad.
Goalies
Sergei Murashov (2-5-1, 3.25 GAA, .893 save%, -0.1 GSAx) B+: It’s been a roller coaster for Murashov, who has played three of his best games in the last week or so (.928 save% and only allowed seven goals in those last three starts). That’s what the Pens are hoping to see for him to raise his level and compete. It’s a shame but unavoidable that he’s going to have to stand on his head and bail the team out a lot more than a 22-year old rookie should, such is the hand he’s been dealt early in his career.
Arturs Silovs (5-6-1, 3.35 GAA, .873 save%, -2.5 GSAx) C: It’s not an easy task to play goal behind this team. Silovs has had some good games and some poor games. He’s given the team a fighting chance in several and has a decent enough win/loss record to show for it. Overall, it’s hard to imagine any starting goalie faring well playing a lot of games in front of this team.
Team
Offense: C-: The good news: the Penguins are generating a lot of chances. The bad news: they’re not scoring on enough of them.
Defense: F It’s very bad and not even NHL quality. The Pens can’t stop leaking chances against, most troublingly when it comes to an absence defending the front of their net. It’s burning them.
Coaching: D: This is a hard grade and more on feel. We can all gripe and moan about exact placements or deployment, but overall it just feels like Dan Muse and company pressed all the right buttons at the right time last year, leading to several career-best seasons. Who’s playing really well this season? Only a handful like Robertson, Malkin, Korczak and Novak. Plenty more are playing worse than anticipated. That could be more individual execution than coaching blame, but in some ways the perception of the coaches is always tied to the performance of the players. Right now the team is lost defending, their power play sputters at inopportune times and they just haven’t found the right ways to make the right changes (if those options are even on the table at all). I don’t know how the coaches fix or work with what they have on hand, but somehow they did a better job last season.













