After an incredibly long drought of middle infielders since the days when Willy Adames and Eugenio Suarez were young Detroit Tigers shortstop prospects, a new golden era is upon us as the Tigers farm system is suddenly packed with middle infielders. This has been a clear focal point to the club’s revamped draft strategy in the last three years. The theory is sound. If you draft shortstops and center fielders, you’re improving the overall athleticsm of your club, even if those prospects don’t ultimately
stick at those positions. 20-year-old Franyerber Montilla was signed in the Al Avila years, but his emergence over the past year adds yet another athletic middle infielder to the Tigers’ prospect hoard.
Montilla was signed in January of 2022 out of Caracas, Venezuela. The Tigers paid him a $500K signing bonus and sent him to the Dominican Summer League at age 17 and 18. The slick fielding, switch-hitting shortstop arrived in Lakeland at age 19 in 2024 and tore up the Complex League. He got a quick look at Single-A ball that summer, and then returned in 2025 mainly playing second base while Bryce Rainer handled shortstop. Once Rainer damaged his shoulder in early June, Montilla moved over to play more shortstop over the next six weeks, until he too suffered a major injury, blowing out his his right ACL in his knee on an infield collision in late July.
The injuries, both in pitcher attrition and just plain back luck for Rainer and Montilla, have really been a plague over the past two seasons system wide. Hopefully they come back with arm strength intact in Rainer’s case, and footspeed intact in Montilla’s case, as those two tools are big parts of their secondary skills beyond the most important factor, their hit tools.
Montilla is a really slick, efficient defender with good hands and range, and a strong throwing arm. He profiles well at shortstop, and it was only Rainer’s absolute cannon at the shortstop position that had the Tigers focusing on him as the regular Flying Tigers’ shortstop. That range is a function of good instincts, but also plus speed, which he put to good use on the bases as well. He stole 27 bases in 67 games last year.
At the plate, Montilla has an efficient, pretty level swing and sprays line drives around the field from both sides of the plate. His big strength is his plate discipline. He walked in 12.7 percent of his plate appearances last year and rarely chases much out of the strike zone. He did strike out 24.7 percent of the time, and at times his discipline can perhaps slip into passivity, allowing pitchers to get ahead with fastballs for strike one and forcing him to battle out long at-bats. The fine line between grinding out pitchers, and failing to jump on mistakes early in counts, is a zone he’s still working to master.
The biggest issue before Montilla is strength and batspeed. He consistently squares up pitches, and he handled all pitch types to an above average level, but it’s below average raw power and he can be a little overwhelmed by good velocity in the zone. Montilla has a pretty slender six-foot tall frame, and needs to keep adding muscle to build a little more batspeed and both get to average power, which is roughly his ceiling, and handle velocity more consistently. He’s closer to getting there as a left-handed hitter, but the samples for him hitting right-handed against lefties are still very small, so more info is required.
Assuming his foot speed isn’t impacted by the ACL, which is usually but not always a safe assumption, the Tigers have a speed player who switch hits, steals bases, and should be capable of playing plus defense either at shortstop or second base. He takes his walks and makes plenty of good contact, but the batspeed still has to improve quite a bit to be able to project him for 15-20 HR level production down the road at the big league level. There’s a very strong floor in place, because Montilla screams utility player, but if he can get past the injury with some strength gains in the rehab process and look like he’ll get close to average power, suddenly the Tigers will have a player that projects like Zach McKinstry with more speed and better defense. If Montilla really maxes out his hit tool, then we’re talking about an everyday infielder anywhere you want to put him.
Unfortunately, ACL tears are usually nine months to a full year to completely rehab, so he may not be back on the field until July, when he’ll be 21 years old. Still, there’s plenty of time to make those strength gains and build on what is a very strong set of secondary tools. Like so many of the Tigers talented youngsters, patience is still required. Hopefully he can get back into a groove this summer and play for West Michigan, then look to take the next step sometime in 2027.
