It seems that judging by the comments here and elsewhere that a number of fans have reached the point of no return on this team. We have also seen more than a few players express some frustration with how things have been going. Obviously, that does not mean there is a mutiny. That would be irresponsible reporting at this point and would spill us into hot take territory. However, when seasons like this go south there are inevitable questions about who gets assigned blame and what happens to them?
I think we can all agree that Nick Caley and Cole Popovich’s days are numbered. Is it even completely their fault? Heck, the team has had four late fourth quarter leads in one possession games and seen the defense give up the score every single time. I’d certainly understand anyone willing to give a pass to Caley and the rest of the offensive coaching staff. However, after watching what we watched on Sunday and coupling that with the horrible effort against the New York Giants, it seems that Caley really hasn’t grasped what would make this team a consistent offensive threat.
That leaves two people clearly in the crosshairs and it seems amazing that either of these two would be here. I hate to look at one football game as changing everything, but the Browns loss in particular shows all kinds of issues that at least need to be talked about if not acted on. I clearly try to look at things rationally and logically, so there are four possibilities here. We will go in the order of most to least likely.
Both Nick Caserio and DeMeco Ryans stay
I know this is the least popular option on the board, but it is the most likely option. What would the justification be? Essentially, this pairing has been together for four seasons and they have been successful in three of them. So, this would be a bet on the fact that everyone deserves a mulligan and that both would learn from their mistakes and right this ship in 2027. Let’s ignore for the time being that Caserio has been on the job longer than that and has two other failed head coaching hires.
Most people would consider that just the necessary time it took to fix Bill O’Brien’s mess. The roster is still in good shape and the cap appears to be in good shape as well. Yes, he did trade away some draft capital to get Marvin Harrison Jr. We will have to get to that in a minute when we look at the other possibilities. So, in essence this group would be hiring their third offensive coordinator and third offensive staff. We could editorialize beyond that, but those facts alone probably speak for themselves.
Ryans stays and Caserio goes
If it comes down to who has the most juice in the building it would have to be Ryans. For one, he has been there only the four seasons where Caserio has the extra two seasons to his name. That comes with the extra baggage of those decisions made before Ryans, but it also means he has had six years to get things like the offensive line right and failed to do so. I am not predicting a power struggle here, but if one occurs Ryans also has the advantage of being a franchise icon.
In a game of finger pointing it becomes a battle between the team having good enough talent and not executing because of coaching and the team simply not having enough talent. It would be interesting to see how such an argument would play out. You could make a case either way and I certainly would argue both ways, but in this scenario we are simply listing what is most likely to happen.
Caserio stays and Ryans goes
This would mean that Caserio wins the power struggle over whether it was the talent or the coaching that went south. I actually would almost put this is the last option because I just don’t see it going down this way. There are just too many head scratching moves to make anyone buy an argument that Caserio isn’t the most culpable. Moreover, some of these choices were criticized at the time. Why did you have to trade draft capital to move up for Keelan Rutledge? Wouldn’t he have been there with your pick? Why did you trade a second rounder for Marvin Harrison when others were traded at the deadline for far less?
Why in the hell are you drafting Marlon Klein at all much less in the second round? Was anyone else really going to draft him before the fourth round? Why are we going with the same buy a bunch of cheap guys on the offensive line for the third season in a row? That strategy didn’t work the two times before. Wasn’t Reed Blankenship one of the worst safeties in football in 2025? I could keep going, but you get the idea. I’m just not buying Caserio having more juice than Ryans.
Both of them get the boot
I think this would be the vote of most of the more vocal fans. Here’s the main problem with it: the Texans have never done this in their 25 year history. They’ve never sacked both at the same time. The closest would be Dom Capers and Charlie Casserly, but even they were separated by a matter of months. The secondary problem is a problem of classic overreactions. If you fire a coach and general manager every time you have a bad season you are going to have a revolving door at both positions.
For these reasons, I just don’t see this outcome as likely. I imagine a good percentage of the fanbase would choose that, but I also wonder how much that fluctuates depending on the results of the most recent game. The Cleveland game obviously points to major coaching issues and if that continues this option could become more likely. The end result is likely that there will be some better games mixed in and therefore the emotions won’t be so strong.
What is my vote?
Honestly, I have seen quite enough of the Nick Caserio experience to last a lifetime. A part of my calculus on this is the fact that this is the first major failure of the Ryans era. He has never seen his defenses struggle like this even going back to his San Francisco days. He has been hit in the mouth and it is time for him to respond. Sometimes that takes an offseason to engineer. Having been a coach before, I know how hard it is to adjust when you are right in the middle of it.
Caserio has tried the same thing over and over again and gotten the same result. He has gone cheap on the line. He has hired buddies for the coaching staff. These things have not worked, but he keeps going back to that well. I don’t think it is a good idea to cut coaches free just because they failed once. I think Ryans deserves a chance to fix it, but firing Caserio clearly puts Ryans on notice. He must hire an experienced coordinator and not go the first time coordinator route yet again. This might be where ownership steps in and forces a coordinator on him. Of course, that is just my opinion, I am sure you have some of your own and this is your opportunity to share them.













