The Green Bay Packers have had next to no luck with injuries for the better part of three years now, and that has even spilled into players who have returned to the field. After tearing his ACL halfway through an All-Pro-bound season, the Packers rewarded Tucker Kraft with a sizable contract extension after he returned to the field this summer, inking him to a four-year, $75M extension with $26.5M in guarantees and about $34M in effective guarantees.
Given Kraft’s fantastic production in 2025, the
extension was well-earned, even with the caveat that 2026 may be a bit of a bump in the road returning from an ACL injury, and unfortunately, the bumpy road is what we’ve gotten. Even with the receiving room being more streamlined this year, even with the full breakouts of Matthew Golden and Christian Watson accounted for, Kraft has lost the “juice.” The star tight end is actually getting targeted at a marginally higher rate per game in 2026 than he did in his breakout 2025, but the results have been extremely disappointing. His catch rate has dropped from 73% to 66%, and his yards-per-target has plummeted by 40% to just 6.6. His yards-per-route-run is a career-low 1.3, even lower than his rookie season, and barely over half his rate last year.
The first assumption, with the breakout of Watson and Golden as serious threats in both the intermediate and deep games, is that Kraft’s targets are different than they were in 2025, but he’s actually getting targeted farther from the line of scrimmage in 2026, with an air yards per target of 5.9 compared to 4.5 last season. That 5.9 mark would be the highest of his career. If Kraft is getting targeted a bit farther down the field in 2026, and Jordan Love is playing at perhaps the best level in his career, what is going on?
Tucker Kraft looks like he’s had his powers removed from him by the Space Jam aliens. His ability after the catch is completely gone. In 2024 and 2025, he averaged over three yards after catch over expected per reception. This made him one of the very best players in the entire NFL with the ball in his hands. In fact, despite missing half the season last year, he finished thirteenth in total yards after the catch over expected, and led all qualifying receivers in YACOE per reception. In 2026, he’s basically average in this category, only averaging a measly +0.38 yards after catch over expected per reception. Every Kraft catch this year is gaining about three fewer yards after the catch than it did last year, all while he’s catching fewer of those targets. You would hardly be able to tell the difference between Kraft this year and a fringe-starting level tight end. Kraft has fewer YACOE than AJ Barner, Pat Freirmuth, and Brevyn Spann-Ford this year. He’s barely above Adam Trautman. Adam Trautman has six catches.
The rule of thumb is that in returning from an ACL tear, the player won’t be back back for about 18 months post-op, and so that means we’re probably only going to get a mildly better version of Kraft for the rest of 2026, but as the Packers look to reload the offensive line this off-season to make a more serious run at contention in 2027, they’ll need the pre-injury version of Kraft back. They can’t afford to toss another albatross contract onto the Bako-Bewele, Wyatt, and Banks pile.

















