The Hall of Fame ballot was officially released today, and there is one name that will stick out right away for Nationals fans. Ryan Zimmerman is making his debut on the ballot this year. After retiring in 2021, the five year wait is over for the Nationals most iconic player. He is one of 14 first timers on the ballot.
Zimmerman is not
the most talented player to ever play for the team, and did not reach the highest peak. However, he will always be Mr. National. He became the first player ever drafted by the Washington Nationals when he was selected 4th overall in 2005. Not only did he live up to the billing, but he exceeded expectations.
Nats fans did not have to wait long to see their first ever draft pick. Zimmerman made his debut the year he was drafted and showed off his immense talent during a 20 game cameo where he posted a .988 OPS. From there, Zimmerman became the face of the franchise and the team’s best player.
Through the dark days of Nationals baseball in the late 2000’s, Zimmerman provided light. He had an unrivaled flair for the dramatic. Whenever he came up in a big spot in the 9th inning, you knew good things would happen. His ability to come up with walk off homers was legendary. Zimmerman hit 11 walk-off home runs for the Nats, the second most ever by a player on one team.
The most iconic of those homers came in March of 2008. It was the first ever game in Nationals Park against the Braves. The contest came down to the wire, but the Nats had their star up in the bottom of the 9th. In that big moment, the Z-man came through, launching a homer off of Peter Moylan to win the game.
It is a bit of a shame that Zimmerman’s prime came when the Nats were not competitive. Zimmerman’s two best all-around seasons came in 2009 and 2010. The Nats only won 59 and 69 games in those seasons, despite Zimmerman having back to back 6+ WAR years.
Unfortunately, I do not think Zimmerman gets into the Hall of Fame. A big reason for that is because he just did not produce enough in his 30’s. After his age 28 season in 2013, Zimmerman had 33.7 career WAR. He only had 6.4 WAR after that season, ending his career with 40.1 wins above replacement.
Nagging injury problems forced Zimmerman to move to first base and miss a lot of games. He only played more than 115 games once after 2013. In that season, Zimmerman hit .303 with 36 homers and a .930 OPS in 2018. When he was even somewhat healthy, he could still hit, but that was not often enough.
He is unlikely to get in, but I do hope that Zimmerman stays on the ballot for next year. The Nats legend only needs 5% of the vote to stay on the ballot. I think he is deserving of that honor. Zimmerman meant so much to a new franchise and holds several Nationals/Expos records including hits, homers, RBI and games played.
Zimmerman was a fantastic player, who would have gotten more national recognition if he played for a better team. In 2009, Zimmerman was 25th in NL MVP voting despite being 4th among NL hitters in WAR. The fact he was only an All-Star twice feels criminal.
When the Nats got really good, Zimmerman was either hurt or overshadowed by younger stars such as Harper and Strasburg. Despite that, he was still the leader of the team and the most beloved player for Nats fans. He means so much to this city and is a truly iconic player.
If I had a ballot, I would definitely give Zimmerman a vote just because of what he meant to DC and to get him to that 5% mark. This is a relatively weak ballot and voters have 10 spots to fill up, so there would be room to give him a vote without overlooking other real candidates.
In the end, Zimmerman is likely just a Hall of Very Good player and a franchise legend. If we could turn off injuries, things could have been different, but that is unfortunately not how things work. There is a little bit of a what if factor here, but Ryan Zimmerman still had a tremendous career and is Mr. National for a reason.













