Welcome to Big Cat Country’s staff roundtable!
This week, we’re previewing the Jacksonville Jaguars’ matchup against the New York Giants in Week 11.
Question 1: What’s your top question about the Jaguars this week?
Dillon Appleman: Does Jordan Davis’ presence help the pass rush off the edge finally get home? Josh Hines-Allen and Travon Walker have struggled to reach the quarterback this season, and some of it can be blamed on a lack of interior push that has allowed QBs the freedom to step up and avoid
that outside pressure. We’ll see on Sunday if Davis’s push is enough to finally see a little more flash from the Jags’ expensive edge duo.
Travis Holmes: Can this Jacksonville offensive line block the Giants’ defensive front one-on-one? As Liam Coen said on Monday, this game will be won in the trenches. When facing a Harbaugh team, of course it will. But Jacksonville will also have to stay out of obvious passing downs to avoid the clear problem areas. Walker Little and Cole Van Lanen against Kayvon Thibodeaux and Abdul Carter should be an interesting matchup, though Arvell Reese and his 4.5 sacks versus Ezra Cleveland, Emmanuel Pregnon, and Jonah Monheim is the one worth watching. Reese had a 3-sack game with a forced fumble against Philadelphia in Week 9, being used as an interior blitzer that forces teams to either play the Giants’ defensive line one-on-one or chip inside using running backs, where Reese normally has the athleticism advantage. As a top five blitzing team, that feels like something that may determine the game.
Gus Logue: Will the weather make a difference? Rain is expected at MetLife Stadium on Sunday, so in theory, it could make the game a little sloppier and give the underdog a slight edge. On the other hand, Jacksonville scored 33 points against Baltimore and 42 points against Indianapolis in wet conditions in recent weeks. It’s probably nothing to be nervous about… but the turf at MetLife is a different beast.
Henry Zimmer: My biggest question this week must be about how well and how much Jordan Davis and Jessie Bates play. This Giants offense is fine, but with two huge defensive additions for the Jags, it will be interesting to see how much they can impact a game already. Imagine a game where Bates gets a pick and Davis gets a sack.
Question 2: What’s the key to a Jaguars victory this week?
Dillon: The key is to end this fairy tale that J.J. McCarthy is in right now. After a brutal short career in Minnesota, McCarthy got dealt to the Giants this season and, to his credit, has played well in place of injured Jaxson Dart. That said, he’s faced nobody of substance since assuming the starting role. I’m looking for this Jacksonville defense to bring the McCarthy narrative down to earth a bit on Sunday.
Travis: Jacksonville must find a way to eliminate the explosives in the passing game this week. J.J. McCarthy loves attacking deep more than any quarterback in the NFL. In his four games played, he’s first in air yards per attempt, both against the blitz and four-man rushes. But just looking at his overall resume, McCarthy is 22nd in the league in on-target throws (per SIS), right below Kyler Murray. In the deep passing game, the Jaguars have allowed 50% of opposing deep passes (20+ air yards) to be completed this year, the NFL’s fourth-worst rate. Meanwhile, the Giants rank top 10 with a 44.7% completion rate on deep passes. Jessie Bates should help in the deep middle, but the cornerbacks will still be challenged on the boundaries in this one.
Gus: Don’t lose in the trenches. I don’t even think the Jaguars have to “win” there; they just can’t let the Giants build a significant advantage in that area. J.J. McCarthy doesn’t move me whatsoever. Between Travis Hunter and Jessie Bates and Jordan Davis, Jacksonville should be equipped to contain Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely and Cam Skattebo, respectively. If the Giants put up enough points to keep pace with the Jaguars, I think it’s because they dominated in the trenches, not because of a sick performance by a skill position player.
Henry: J.J. McCarthy has been throwing a ton of balls since he took over starting, but he only has 2 passing touchdowns. Limit McCarthy to yardage and no touchdowns and the Jags are winning their fourth straight.
Question 3: Who will be an X-factor for the Jaguars this week?
Dillon: Chris Rodriguez. With Bhayshul Tuten still dealing with a lingering ankle injury, he may not be able to play Sunday. That means Rodriguez would get bell cow duties, and I’m confident he can step up if that is the case. The weather is looking bleak in East Rutherford on Sunday, which could lead to a sloppy run fest, so Rodriguez could be in line for a big role and will need to step up.
Travis: Craig Wrolstad is this week’s X-factor in my book. If you don’t recognize that name, that makes sense. He’s the referee heading up this week’s officiating crew calling Sunday’s game. This is also the same crew that called Jacksonville’s Week 1 matchup against the Browns, where the Jaguars only had four penalties while Cleveland had 11. I only point that out because this crew ranks as the No. 1 officiating crew at calling defensive pass interference and No. 4 in illegal contact penalties, which may bode well for Jacksonville getting a few, since the Giants are already fifth in the league in DPI flags.
Gus: I’m going to give a boring answer — Parker Washington — so I can give a cool stat. According to NFL Pro, Washington leads the league in yards per route run against press coverage (5.0) and on in-breaking routes (3.5). Both figures rank narrowly ahead of Jaxon Smith-Njigba. And New York’s defense aligns at least one cornerback in press coverage on a league-high 70.6% of snaps.
Henry: My X-Factor this week is not a who but a what: the field surface at MetLife. This field is known for taking lives so I just hope that the Jags get away unscathed. This stadium scares the hell out of me.
Final score prediction?
Dillon: Jaguars 23, Giants 20
Travis: Jaguars 32, Giants 20
Gus: Jaguars 30, Giants 14
Henry: Jaguars 35, Giants 17
What are your Week 11 predictions, Jaguars fans? Let us know in the comments!
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
- New, improved notifications system!
Download the SB Nation app on iOS or Android.













