Each week, we ask you to post some questions in The Feed ahead of the game. This week, a lot of you had questions about the future of the athletic department and the football team.
Ahead of Michigan Football’s game against the No. 4 UCLA Bruins, Michigan made headlines. Earlier this week, reports started surfacing that the University was one step closer to hiring its new athletic director. The entire Maize N Brew team did a great job handling the news, shout-outs to everyone, including Nick Durand.
Nick was really on top of getting the information to you all.
If the new athletic director keeps Whittingham
No, I don’t think that this has to be true, as he proclaims. I also don’t think the University operates like a business where you can cut the highly paid guys on the roster and get a lot of cheaper guys in the portal (like hiring new employees right out of college). If you want to compete, you need top talent, and maintaining your roster is just as beneficial as going out and getting new players.
Personally, I think comments from HC Kyle Whittingham about roster turnover and blaming the portal and funding just show he doesn’t get what the University of Michigan wants to be about. While Michigan has money and resources, we want players to understand the history and be proud to represent the university. That “woe is me” stuff is insulting.
No, I do not think that there’s too much faith in Whittingham being able to cobble together a better team if he has a full recruiting cycle and transfer portal window. This roster had enough on it to beat teams like Iowa, Minnesota, and Michigan State, and they lost those games.
Ahead of this week, I honestly thought it was a toss-up. Michigan has had a lot of pride in its academics, and I wasn’t sure the new President would want to wade into the world of firing a first-year head coach without an AD. That process moved pretty quickly, so I’d say the chances of him getting fired have certainly increased. While I think incoming AD Trev Alberts will probably make several changes when he gets to Ann Arbor, having him so quickly definitely signals that higher-ups at least want the option to show Whittingham the door.
Honestly, I think it’s more likely he’s gone now that there’s a new AD scheduled to take over the department. It’s going to take someone who’s willing to make those abrupt changes, instead of waiting things out. If Warde Manuel had still been around in December, I would have said it’s going to take a lot more than an angry fan base and a losing season. Honestly, if they hadn’t made the AD move this week, I realistically saw Whittingham getting another season to coach this team.
On hopes for Michigan’s next head coach
If Michigan is going to fire Whittingham, they need to do it as soon as Alberts gets in his role if it’s not possible to do it sooner. I know a lot of people have thrown out names and wish lists, including Indiana DC Bryant Haines, Michigan DC Jay Hill, UCLA HC Bob Chesney, and UNM HC Jason Eck. I just want this coaching cycle to actually allow the process to play out more than I care about getting a specific name on the list. Michigan had a clear person to hand the baton off to when Jim Harbaugh left, then it hired HC Kyle Whittingham to patch up an incredibly messy season quickly. Michigan’s football program is in the muck, and it needs to take some time to seriously consider candidates who are willing to adapt to a changing football landscape. With the CFP expanding next year, there’s a little more room for roster changes, but I want the team to pick someone who could be the face of Michigan football for an extended period of time. I’m just not sure I’ve made up my mind about who that person should be.
I really think that UCLA has a solid chance at the CFP. I’m not sure I see Chesney leaving that opportunity to go and coach a different program. But we all know I’ve been wrong before.
On players heading into the last few weeks
It’s tough to hear guys like Rod Moore sharing that he wished he left for the NFL sooner. I’m sure some of that is just connected to how unfortunate the past few years have been for him, and this football season feels like a personal affront to how he’s played over the years. The players have said publicly they’d like to spoil UCLA’s perfect season, but I just don’t know if that’s going to happen.
Just ahead of the UCLA game, we learned about charges pending against WR Andrew Marsh. As of writing this, the University didn’t give any indication about Marsh’s status for the UCLA game, but let’s just assume he’s not playing. Wide receiver JJ Buchanan is also out after his injury in the Oregon game. My guess is they’ll look to WR Travis Johnson a little more this weekend, and I’d also expect to see Salesi Moa get a few more targets. Freshman Jaylen Pile also had a few snaps last weekend, maybe he’ll be on the field more, too.
On the line, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the same starting lineup as last week. That’d be Evan Link at LT, Manuel Beigel at LG, C Jake Guarnera, Nathan Efobi at RG, and Marky Walbridge at RT.
Thoughts on the game heading into Saturday
There’s always a chance, but I’m not picking the Wolverines this week. Michigan’s chances certainly increase if they score early, but UCLA’s offense has been able to get a lot done in many of their games. The time change could negatively impact them, but I don’t think they’ll overlook Michigan. The CFP hasn’t necessarily been kind to the Big Ten this year, and UCLA probably gets that they don’t want to leave anything to chance.
I don’t think the Michigan defense has necessarily given up, but they have struggled the past few weeks. Oregon really took advantage of some miscues by defensive players, and that’s a possibility for UCLA. With the injuries on the offense and overall lack of identity, I wouldn’t be surprised if this team doesn’t score.
On UCLA’s turnaround and HC Bob Chesney
It’d be easy to say that UCLA doesn’t have the toughest schedule, but the turnaround at UCLA goes beyond just having it easy. They lost a starting QB in Nico Iamaleava, but they’ve had great production from their offense, regardless. They also have a defense that has been able to limit opponents. Chesney seems like he has a real knack for getting the best out of his players. I don’t know; some coaches are just able to motivate their guys and surround themselves with a great support system. He seems to be one of those guys.
I agree that they’ve had a relatively easy schedule compared to some of the other teams in the country, but I wouldn’t say they’re overrated. It’s tough to go undefeated in college football right now, and the fact that they keep winning is pretty significant. They’re doing a lot with what they’ve got. I think people expected a turnaround there, but the work Bob Chesney has done is pretty impressive.













