Germany just won 5-0 against Xavi’s Dutch national team—the same side that beat Greece 7-0 last week. GERMANY did that. This win was absolutely delicious, so savor it for as long as you want. Tell everyone. Here are my three observations from this game.
Only three observations? Muller_Era, what happened to you? Germany just won 5-0. The last time we checked, you’d write fifteen observations on a dead-rubber 2-1 win.
You’re only washed up or a nobody until you score
I love that every time Germany plays, they bring in a player you’ve never heard of
before. That, unfortunately, was the state of affairs for a long time due to a few reasons—one being that squad selections were heavily influenced by short-term results. One day you could be the starting striker, and in just two months, you’d become old news. The second reason was, obviously, injuries.
In Jürgen Klopp’s case, however, the manager started his job a mere three months ago. Therefore, it makes sense that we continue to see new faces.
Derry Scherhant was a young player from Berlin, circulating among its multiple youth settings at first before settling at Hertha. SC Freiburg picked up the attacker last year, and since then he has played for them. Brajan Gruda was a Mainz youth product who helped them survive a relegation battle before heading off to Brighton. Kai Havertz’s case with Germany was considered set in stone — just another former Germany youth prospect who had nothing but unmet potential. And finally, Florian Wirtz. Barely surviving the golden boy-to-dumpster-fire pipeline, Wirtz was universally considered a terrible purchase by Liverpool.
My point is, tonight we saw an attack from which the average watcher would have expected nothing. However, a closer look at the game would reveal that the manager was Klopp.
Who could call Havertz and Wirtz washed up if they score? Who could call Scherhant and Gruda nobodies when their performances tonight cemented Germany’s position as a threat?
In terms of optics, this was the best game for this set of players to execute Klopp’s plan and win: it’s Xavi Hernández and his Netherlands side. Whether or not people check to see if they were good, they’ll deem Germany a top side just because of the names on the opposition end.
I would further love to argue that what we saw tonight proves that the issue was NEVER Germany and its talent, but the guy in charge—though that’s an argument for a bit later. For now, let’s establish a few standard facts:
- Identity: Everyone, their mother, and Philipp Lahm made it abundantly clear that Germany lacked a footballing identity after the World Cup. Klopp has brought back a visible footballing identity: an aggressive counter-press that relies on players to act fast and then take viable risks to move the ball forward, featuring vertical progression accompanied by overloads in attacking areas. There is a clear Kloppian idea, and it is being executed by the players he has picked. The experimentation in earlier international windows, despite looking ridiculous, was actually crucial to establishing which set of players he could rely on.
- Hold your horses: NOTICE, I said set of players. What I mean to say is that the squad is still NOT set in stone. YES. NOT SET IN STONE. And there’s a very good reason. The two games that Germany have won—against Serbia and now the Netherlands — had operationally different squads. This is because Klopp chooses players whose skills he can utilize for a particular opponent. Last game, it was Maximilian Mittelstädt and Malick Thiaw; this game, it is Nathaniel Brown and Nico Schlotterbeck. Thiaw was chosen against Serbia for his aerial abilities, while Schlotterbeck was brought back because the Dutch midfield is extremely skilled under pressure and can move between defensive lines. Here, the Dortmund star brings his distribution skillset to break the passing lines of the Dutch midfield.
- It’s all in your head: It is clear that Klopp is excellent at managing players’ self-esteem, because there is ABSOLUTELY NO OTHER explanation for Wirtz’s transformation.
Klopp has absolutely transformed this side down to the fundamentals of running a team: establish a playing identity, keep your options open, play to your opponent, and unlock player potential by identifying their bottlenecks
That thing Antman said in Endgame
In the beginning of Avengers: Endgame, Scott Lang (Ant-Man) exits the Quantum Realm only to find that everyone he knew had vanished after the events of Infinity War. He reaches the Avengers headquarters to ask a pertinent question: “What the h*ll happened here?”
So, the same Netherlands who beat Greece 7-0 just collapsed under Germany? Yes, they did.
The Dutch defensive vulnerabilities, combined with their inability to contain Germany, set them up to fail. Additionally, the absences of Frenkie de Jong and Virgil van Dijk made the issues more jarringly evident. On paper, their squad is perfect, but the structure they operate on has very easily identifiable and exploitable deficits:
- Aggressive full-backs mean that there is always space left behind. Bayern fans may be familiar with this idea—that if your full-back presses forward and inverts or overlaps, he leaves behind a defensive vulnerability that he can only cover by sprinting. However, you must factor in how fast the opposition wingers are. In this case, Florian Wirtz and Brajan Gruda are incredibly fast players who can easily punish this space.
- A high line means that the midfield and defense need to stay in tandem to ensure they don’t create additional spaces. However, staying coordinated at all times is difficult; when an attacker bypasses the midfield, they can simply make runs past the center-backs and make use of the space left by defenders stepping out to retrieve possession.
- The Netherlands’ midfield is filled with attacking-minded players who step forward often, which once again plays directly into the strengths of the German attack.
- Without strong figures to organize the defense and act as sweepers who clean up after the team’s mistakes, the Dutch suffer even more.
Wirtz is fast enough and clever enough to find himself between the lines, and Gruda — as established last game — is ruthless: he runs straight at defenders and is extremely direct. Scherhant finds himself past the defenders waiting for the next move, while Havertz makes runs into the box, drops deep, creates chances, and opens up space for Wirtz to run into.
Klopp assembled the perfect side to beat the picture-perfect Dutch.
It was never a Germany issue
Over the past ten years, the blame has always been player-oriented: that Germany simply doesn’t have the talent, or that they’ll never be as good as Philipp Lahm, Bastian Schweinsteiger, Mats Hummels, Mesut Özil, Sami Khedira, Toni Kroos, Mario Götze, and of course, Thomas Müller.
And all of that is true.
There will never be another Thomas Müller. But why does there need to be one?
The blame game completely falls apart when you realize Germany doesn’t need those exact players to win — it needs a manager who’s willing to hunt for new talent and a tactical plan that works with their skills.
If the DFB doesn’t scout, the manager inevitably has to do it himself if he wants to win. I’m not saying the solution to a poor administration is doing their work for them, but at some point, the work had to be done. The critiques against the quality of available German talent make no sense when a bunch of “nobodies” accomplished two wins so emphatically. The moment you stop looking only at Bayern and the Germans playing abroad, an ocean of talent becomes visible. It’s no longer the same thirty-odd guys being tried in ten different permutations and combinations only to produce the same mediocre results. So say what you want about Klopp’s 40-man squad from a month ago; it has clearly worked.
The more you watch this Germany side, the clearer it becomes: they needed vision. They needed Klopp. If you take a step further, you realize this cohort of players, combined with Jamal Musiala, genuinely looks like a World Cup-winning squad.
The formula has been cracked, and all that’s left is for Germany to play on.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- New, improved notifications system!
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts













