Thank you to VEB reader CodyG for showing me the way on xWAR, a rather particular new stat that has a goal to seek out who might be underrated or overrated by WAR. This article is simply to introduce the stat to a more mass audience than the comments section, to discuss what xWAR actually means, as well as what fWAR and bWAR are to anyone who doesn’t really know.
“Data: FanGraphs (fWAR, position-level Statcast FRV, DRS, and player stats), Statcast (xwOBA), and Baseball-Reference (bWAR).
- How fWAR is calculated: Batting, baserunning, and fielding runs plus positional, league, and replacement-level adjustments, divided by runs per win. FanGraphs methodology
- Batters: xWAR replaces wOBA with xwOBA and removes the inherited FanGraphs batting park adjustment, with no additional xwOBA park correction.
- Defense: Uses position-level FRV and/or DRS, centered by season and position, with 100% FRV for C and OF, 60/40 FRV/DRS for 1B/SS, and 40/60 for 2B/3B. Where only one metric is available, that metric receives full weight (marked *); stints with neither metric are ignored. Def Runs is the total used in xWAR; FRV/DRS show raw totals. No eligible positions means zero. The FanGraphs positional adjustment remains. Tango’s analysis”
Fielding runs
are a part of Wins Above Replacement level, or WAR. It’s a stat that seeks to incorporate all quantifiable aspects of the game. I wanted to point out that Fielding Run are awarded for actually preventing runs, basically. This is all tracked and computerized since there are cameras and sensors on every MLB game.
Even baserunning boosts or takes away from a player’s WAR value. The all around best players have the highest Wins Above Replacement level. A replacement level player is like a AAAA player worth 0 wins, the theoretical fill in player when things go bad. They should not be too terrible and take away from the team, nor will they add to it. Sort of a temporary substitute ideally!
Which means it’s really really bad if you’re a player with negative WAR. You’re not going to last at the MLB level.
I think this list of Cardinals position players will be most interesting if we can see fWAR (fangraphs), bWAR (baseball reference), and this new stat explained above, xWAR. The difference between fWAR and bWAR is mostly just a difference in evaluating defense. Sometimes they are similar conclusions, and sometimes they are different.
I think xWAR is interesting because it is simply an alternative viewpoint to gain perspective upon what is usually quoted. xWAR uses a blend of defensive metrics which I think is super cool. It foregoes wOBA for Expected wOBA (xwOBA).
We all know JJ Wetherholt had the most WAR by far of the rookie class of 2026, but what will xWAR say about this popularly perceived anomaly in the stat? That is just one thing to look for. Did Burly’s season seem underrated by WAR at 3.2? To give some perspective, Alec Burleson was the 55th most valuable MLB player by fWAR. PCA was worth over 7 more wins!
Just a quick note: WAR accumulates over innings played, so part-time players will of course have less of it.
In general, bWAR attempts to explain what happened on the field, while fWAR and xWAR are moreso trying to project what will happen going forward. I am listing the Cardinals according to their overall fangraphs value:
- JJ Wetherholt (best defender): 4.6 fWAR / 4.5 bWAR / 5.7 xWAR (fangraphs -1.1 WAR)
if you are expecting Wetherholt to build on his good season, you’re probably right! I too think he will be even better next season. Average of WAR: 4.9 - Alec Burleson: 3.2 fWAR / 3.7 bWAR / 4.4 xWAR (fangraphs -1.2 WAR)
I think most of us were thinking the fangraphs 3.2 WAR seemed a little low for the season Burly had. It is possible that he is the most underrated player on the team by fWAR. Seriously. Average of WAR: 3.8 - Jordan Walker: 2.7 fWAR / 3.3 bWAR / 2.4 xWAR
Do not be surprised if Walker has a slight step back next season. I would have no problem with that for as young as he is, and as long as he does not slip back into old habits at the plate. Average of WAR: 2.8 - Masyn Winn: 2.3 fWAR / 2.7 bWAR / 2.8 xWAR
Do not despair, Winn fans! He is probably going to be a pretty good player. I would wager a 3+ WAR season for next year, or maybe prorate that; I don’t know. That is of course, if he hits a little better. Which he has in the past. Average of 2026 WAR: 2.6 - Ivan Herrera: 1.4 fWAR / 2.9 bWAR / 1.8 xWAR
I think it’s probably safe to say Ivan Herrera will be worth more than 2 WAR next year. But then again, he got hit by a pitch so many times this year I do not know what his on-base percentage could possibly be! That’s gonna be a tough guess right now, imo. Average of WAR: 2 - Leo Bernal: .8 fWAR / .8 bWAR / .7 xWAR
xWAR taps the brakes a bit on Bernalamania, but also, Leo played in only 24 games… if xWAR is right he’s a 4.7 WAR player over a full season if you want to extrapolate that stat. Average of 2026 WAR: .8 - Pedro Pages: .6 fWAR / .4 bWAR / 1 xWAR
It is possible we have been underrating Pedro a bit. He could be a 2 WAR player if he played a whole season. Ok, maybe not. He’s ok, I think he will have an MLB career whether he stays in the organization or not. Average of WAR: .7 - Nathan Church: .4 fWAR / 1.7 bWAR / .1 xWAR
He is a walking enigma. That sure looks like a bench guy if you ignore bWAR. But what if he can pull off the Church magic again next year? I’m not counting on it, but he did hit some dingers. I wouldn’t even mind seeing Chase Davis get a chance, though. But Church ain’t bad, really. Average of WAR: .7 - Replacement Level Players
- Thomas Saggese .3 fWAR / -.4 bWAR / .2 xWAR
- Jose Fermin: .3 fWAR / .4 bWAR / -.1 xWAR
- Everson Pereira: .3 fWAR / 0 bWAR / .2 xWAR
- Blaze Jordan: .1 fWAR / .3 bWAR / .7 xWAR
- Bryan Torres: .1 fWAR / 0 bWAR / 0 xWAR
- Jimmy Crooks: 0 fWAR / -.5 bWAR / .7 xWAR
Joshua Baez, who art thou? We did not have enough of a look in 2026. If you extrapolate his .2 fWAR over a full season, he’s just around 1 – 1.5 WAR. Good bench guy. But what does bWAR say? And xWAR? They total less than the fWAR put together. I would not be so surprised if Baez starts the season in AAA, if he doesn’t tear apart spring training. Then there’d be two J. Baez in Memphis! Maybe.
Of the replacement level players, Blaze Jordan might have the most promise. A Nathan Church and Pedro Pages level player. But they’re all young, who’s to say what will happen.
The Music of the Year 2000: Indie/Emo/Math Rock Edition
Last week I got things started looking back at the year 2000 withfive huge albums, celebrated and memorable albums by godspeed you black emperor!, radiohead, yo la tengo, queens of the stone age, and ween. The year 2000 might be past the date when a lot of people stopped paying attention to new music, but for me, it’s around the time when many of the sounds that we hear often today in contemporary music began. As influential a year of music as any, but there was something about the Y2K thing, people getting out their best.
This week I’m narrowing it down to a few popular subgenres of music in 2000, indie rock, math rock, and emo punk. I’ll just get to it, all you need to know there is nothing too heavy here, but each release does rock in its own way.
- Faraquet – ‘The View From This Tower’ I list this one first not because it’s my favorite, although I do like it a ton… it’s because of all the albums I’m about to list, it is the most exemplary of all three genres listed. It’s super catchy yet heady rock music. (DC)
- Don Caballero – ‘American Don’ thinking man’s music. Check out this album, AND all the ones before it. Real American music. The lineup on this album has reunited for some shows! Very exciting as they are one of my favorite bands of all. IFYKYK (Pittsburgh/Chicago)
- Pram – ‘The Museum of Imaginary Animals’ absolutely beautiful and creative music! Must hear! (England)
- Thingy – ‘To The Innocent’ pretty much unclassifiable, but all the genres apply here as well. Rob Crow of Pinback’s band that bridged the gap between Heavy Vegetable and Pinback. Another album of absolutely beautiful songs but with a catchy alt punk meets prog rock twist. I listened to this album almost every day for a few years, I don’t usually do that. There’s so many twists and turns to the music there’s a lot to learn here. (San Diego)
- Ruins – ‘Pallaschtom’ this duo is definitely more in the math rock/prog/zeuhl realm, but it fits within this group of bands as well because it is so creative and interesting. You’ll either be supremely annoyed or endlessly entertained with this one, there’s not much in between here. You will never be able to figure this band out, exactly, which is part of the mindfuck appeal. Absolutely phenomenal drummer and insane bassist/vocalist. Insanely good at bass, and the vocals are insane. The drummer Tatsuya Yoshida is a legend. (Japan)
- Q and Not U – ‘No Kill No Beep Beep’ another blend of emo, indie rock, and more progressive sounds, whatever you want to call it I feel this captures a moment in time of American punk rock culture. (DC)
- The Microphones – ‘It Was Hot We Stayed in The Water’ this is on the indie rock/emo/folk side of things to close out this week in the year 2000, hope you like it. (Washington state)
Thanks for reading and tuning in. Have a good ‘un! Hope you enjoy.













