After starting off the season 6-1, Northwestern has fallen to 6-4 following a 28-19 loss to Ohio State on the road. The team was once again missing starting quarterback Aidan Chiles, as he continues to deal with an upper-body injury.
It was a close, one-score game until the fourth quarter, when a Drew Wagner muffed punt led to a Jeremiah Smith touchdown, allowing Ohio State to pull away.
With the hopes and dreams of the early season dashed from the minds of the Wildcat faithful, what can be learned
from this disappointing outcome?
NU needs more from the O-line
The run game from just three games ago is gone. Northwestern’s running backs have not rushed for over 100 yards since the matchup against Rutgers. Since then, Northwestern hasn’t even been able to rush for over 4 yards per carry.
This is not because there is a lack of talent in the backfield; far from it. Senior running back Joseph Himon II showed how dynamic he is in the receiving game with three catches for 32 yards. Junior running back Caleb Komolafe consistently made something out of nothing and churned his legs for extra yardage.
However, the offensive line was not winning the battle at the line of scrimmage at all. Ohio State consistently moved the Wildcat offensive line off its spot and made it incredibly difficult for the running backs to find holes to burst through.
Redshirt junior Nicco Marchiol was also sacked five times. Marchiol would constantly have to navigate around the pocket and find space to get just a couple of yards or limit negative gains. This is not to say it was fully on the offensive line, as there would be times when Marchiol would stand like a statue, taking a sack as a result.
If Northwestern truly wants to translate the explosive offense performance it had against the bottom feeders of the Big Ten to stiffer competition, the offensive line has to be better, or head coach David Braun has to do a better job recruiting the O-line talent that has been present in Northwestern’s recent history, like first-round picks Rashawn Slater and Peter Skoronski.
The defense needs to figure out how to tackle
It is painful watching a game knowing that the first person to attempt a tackle for Northwestern is sure to miss. It is more painful when it has been a problem the whole season, as exemplified by Northwestern’s hardest matchups.
Ohio State’s running backs Bo Jackson and Isaiah West would receive the ball in the backfield or catch a checkdown and turn what should have been 3-to-4-yard gains into ones of 5 yards or more, putting the Buckeyes ahead of the sticks.
In one of the worst instances of the game, Ohio State ran a reverse jet sweep to senior wide receiver Devin McCuin and linebacker Braydon Brus found himself in the backfield to create a 10-yard loss. Instead, he missed the tackle, which turned into a 20-yard gain that was fortunately called back due to an illegal block in the back.
The missed tackles are what allowed Oregon to create so many explosives in its comeback against the Wildcats. The missed tackles allowed a weak Iowa offense to score 24 points on the road. The missed tackles are the reason Jeremiah Smith set the all-time Big Ten receiving yards record against Tim McGarigle’s unit.
It has been something that head coach David Braun has been complaining about all season. Yet, it has persisted and gotten worse. If Northwestern wants to start converting these close games into wins, the defense needs to step up and not mess up the fundamentals.
The ‘Cats were close to another breakthrough
Despite it being an incredibly tough three-game stretch for Northwestern, the fact that it had these expectations and found itself in this position is incredible.
I know Northwestern fans don’t want to hear “almost” or that the team is right there, but Northwestern is competing with the heavyweights of the conference week in and week out. Northwestern captured the attention of the national media for multiple weeks. And sure, the ‘Cats couldn’t make good on its 6-1 start, but it is just a matter of time.
If Northwestern can beat Minnesota and Illinois—I know it’s a big if—an 8-4 record would be something incredible the team can build on next season. It will allow Braun and company to convince more talent to come to Evanston through the transfer portal, especially with the additional resources the program is getting.
I don’t like the expansion of the College Football Playoff to 24 teams, but Northwestern’s growth and seemingly easier schedule next season could land the team in the tournament as a result.
Northwestern showed what is possible this season. Now the expectations for seasons in the future can rise to make that possibility a reality. The Wildcats are right there; they just have to deliver.













