Once a highly-rated prospect, Bailey Falter’s best effort was serving as a decent-enough starter for the Pittsburgh Pirates, back in 2024. Time flies, though. Here we are in 2026, and Falter has now been part of two more organizations (bringing his total to four), and is about to embark on the journeyman reliever path that so many pitchers across baseball have travelled. It’s time to take a look at how Falter’s latest stop in Atlanta went.
How Acquired
The Braves picked up Falter (along with Lane Thomas) from
the Royals in exchange for Lucas Braun and Carter Holton in a Trade Deadline deal. Falter was then immediately sent to Triple-A Gwinnett, which is where he made eight appearances (including a start) before getting called up on September 9.
What were the expectations?
There was a lot of speculation (on here, at least) that Falter could’ve been used as a lefty option specifically for the matchups against the Philadelphia Phillies down the stretch. Sure enough, Falter did make an appearance for the Braves against the Phillies during that fateful home series in September, so I suppose the expectations were met? But yeah, the expectations weren’t really too high for Falter coming in and it was apparent that the Braves figured that he’d be organizational depth for the home stretch.
Why were those the expectations for Falter? Well, he didn’t really cut it as a starter or swingman, leading the Phillies to trade him to the Pirates in 2023. There was that aforementioned decent-enough season with the Pirates, but he seriously backslid the next year, and by 2026, he was pitching so poorly that even the Royals only found 13 innings to give him. Nor was he pitching all that well in Triple-A as a swingman. So, the hope was that a more dedicated relief role would serve him well, because he had largely flamed out of the other roles.
2026 Results
Falter made three appearances at Truist Park and two of them were for the Braves. He actually made a long relief appearance for the Royals against the Braves all the way back on Opening Day, which is when he pitched three innings for Kansas City in a game where the Braves were leading comfortably. Mauricio Dubón smacked a two-RBI double off of him to bring the game to its final score of 6-0, but Falter did strike out four batters while he was out there, so there’s that.
Those four strikeouts were his season high, as things didn’t get much better for Falter going forward. He made a trio of appearances during May and the latter of those two appearances were actually starts. Unfortunately, the Yankees blasted him for seven runs over 2 1/3 innings on May 26 in a bizarre outing where he faced 16 batters and didn’t walk or strike out any of them, and that start ended up being his final appearance for the Royals at the big league level as he got designated for assignment.
He wouldn’t appear again at the big league level until September 9, which is when the Braves brought him in to cover the final two innings of a nasty 7-2 loss to the Rays. Those were scoreless innings, though, so that was nice!
Remember when I mentioned that Falter would eventually get to face the Phillies? Well, it happened while the Braves were down 9-2 in a game that Atlanta more “wanted” rather than “needed” since they had already picked up a huge series win by that point. Falter did end up tossing 1 1/3 scoreless innings while he was out there (including a strikeout of Bryce Harper, which made him the most popular guy in Cobb County for about three minutes), which led to some very light speculation about whether or not Falter would make the roster for the Wild Card Series.
Falter did not make the Wild Card Series roster and that appearance on September 13 wound up being Falter’s final appearance for the Braves after he was designated for assignment and outrighted back to the Gwinnett Stripers. (No one claimed him.)
What went right?
So yeah, he struck out Bryce Harper! That was cool. Falter also had those two scoreless innings against the Rays, so he can forever take it to the bank that he was able to keep the 2026 AL Pennant winners quiet for a couple of innings.
He also placed in the 98th percentile when it came to extension, so he was able to make his four-seam heater look that much faster than the 92 mph that it clocked in at, so there’s that.
What went wrong?
Well, if you’re going to stick around in the big leagues with below average velocity nearly across the board on all your pitches then your command and control had better be pristine. That’s not the case for Falter, who generally seemed like he had no idea where his stuff was going. There’s a world out there where Falter’s unique ability to generate “rise” on his fastball despite its total lack of velocity (18th percentile per Statcast) is paired with some set of skills and other pitches that make him successful, but that’s not this world. At least, not yet. Instead, Falter throws pretty much the most generic slider on the planet, and his ability to locate is really an inability. So, you get a bunch of odd fastballs and nothing else, and that’s not a recipe for success. He gave up a .415 xwOBA-against on his four-seamer, and yep, that’s not playable when you throw it over half the time.
To further drive the point home, he didn’t miss many bats with it (9.8 whiff percentage with his four-seamer) and he only had a 10 percent Put Away rate with the four-seamer as well. Again, he threw this pitch 55 percent of the time.
It’s very difficult to live a successful life in the bigs with all of that going on, which is probably why he’s bounced around with four teams across six seasons so far. His last productive season of 2024 feels like a long, long time ago with the way things have been going for him lately.
On the flip side, he didn’t have any shellings as bad as that outing against the Yankees with the Braves, so yay for that.
2027 outlook
Normally this’d be the part where I say that “he’s a left-handed arm so someone’s going to take a chance on him” and speculate about what that future might look like. That might still be the case, but it’s hard to envision Falter making an Opening Day roster based on how this season went — one where the Royals may or may not have dumped him off to the Braves for salary relief as part of a bigger trade, and then the Braves proceeded to only use him twice at the big league level before DFAing him themselves. Falter elected free agency once the season was said and done.
So yeah, hopefully things go well for Falter going forward but he’ll be upsetting the odds if he finds his way onto a big league roster to start the 2027 season. He’s a replacement level until he shows otherwise guy, and his pitching repertoire probably needs a rework before he can.













