Happy Gump Day, everyone. The greatest committee in the history of the College Football Playoff kept Alabama 3rd this week, and people are mad.
It’s laughable what the CFP selection committee is doing, and they’re blatantly doing it without hesitation. This week, Alabama plays FCS Chattanooga, and Tennessee plays LSU.
But LSU dropped out of the poll, so LSU won’t be a significant win for the Vols — even though the Tigers were (and likely still are) a significant win for Alabama.
Watch out, Georgia.
If Alabama beats Auburn in the regular season final, the Tide may just jump all the way to No. 1. You know, the same Auburn team that won at Georgia.
If the CFP selection committee doesn’t care about head-to-head with Tennessee, why would it care about head-to-head with Georgia?
It’s good to be the CFP darling, everyone.
Texas certainly fails the “eye test” at times. The Longhorns have the best resume but don’t always look the best on the field. Even in Texas’ win over LSU last weekend, it wasn’t pretty. There’s certainly an argument that Alabama has looked better than Texas at points this season. But focusing more on the eye test than a mountain of metrics is where the committee can get itself in trouble.
No. 9 Tennessee also has an argument for being ranked above Alabama given its head-to-head win over the Crimson Tide. But it is clear the committee will continue to keep those two schools far enough apart in the rankings to justify not applying the head-to-head result, since they aren’t in the same pod for direct comparison. That decision means the Volunteers have no margin for error this weekend if they lose to former coach Lane Kiffin’s Tigers. You can only imagine the outrage there will be in Knoxville if that were to happen.
Alabama is this week’s most overrated team.
As usual, the math disagrees.
But here’s the thing: The SEC is playing tougher schedules this season. Its teams have gone 10-2 against the other P4 conferences and Notre Dame. The three other leagues are all below .500. And all of the SEC’s teams are playing a 10th P4 game. (There are four on Thanksgiving weekend.) Three Big Ten teams are not, including a 9-1 Indiana team that’s behind 8-2 Alabama and Texas.
The computer ratings aren’t all programmed by SEC engineers, and ESPN isn’t putting in conspiratorial calls to the committee room. The numbers say what they say, and the committee is finally placing more value on metrics than eye tests and body clocks.
Which is what most people always said they wanted.
Until they saw the results.
Alabama is 3rd per Sagarin, and 4th per both Massey and FPI. The usual suspects hate the fact that Georgia has separated itself to the point that Alabama taking them to the wire has become a better resume bullet than anyone else’s best win. The same thing happened in 2011.
Tennessee won by 15 in College Station. Sadly, they had to drop a spot anyway.
Dropping one spot from last week and behind Indiana should concern No. 9 Tennessee, which clearly is not in the same boat as Alabama and Texas. That’s despite the Volunteers’ 26-10 win against the Crimson Tide last month, which continues to be pushed aside by the committee. The Volunteers haven’t necessarily earned the benefit of the doubt, though, winning games behind a very strong defense and struggling at times against some of the weaker teams in the SEC. That was the case this past Saturday, when Tennessee needed a late surge to beat Texas A&M 22-7.
Doesn’t that break your heart?
Last, Keelon Russell is in the running for some hardware.
Alabama’s Keelon Russell was named a semifinalist for the Davey O’Brien Award, the Davey O’Brien Foundation announced Tuesday.
Russell is one of 13 semifinalists for the O’Brien which is presented annually to the nation’s top quarterback. Finalists will be announced on Nov. 24 with the 2026 winner of the O’Brien being announced on Dec. 11 as part of the ESPN Home Depot College Football Awards.
Alabama has had two Davey O’Brien Award winners, first with Mac Jones in 2020 followed by Bryce Young a year later.
He would likely need big games against Auburn and in the SEC Championship Game to win it, but either way will be on all of the short lists headed into next season.
That’s about it for now. Have a great day.
Roll Tide.













