Mets Player Performance Meter: Pitchers, April 6-19

I thought this meter would be better than the hitting meter because the offense has really been the problem. But honestly? It’s not that much better. There are more positive grades for sure, but there are almost as many pitchers mired in the poop right now as the hitters, which is almost impressive. All of the high leverage relievers that had excellent starts to their seasons have since had at least one blowup each—multiple blowups, in some cases. David Peterson has lost his rotation spot and Kodai

Senga is perilously close to doing the same. Though the top three in the Mets’ rotation have been mostly solid, not all is sunshine and rainbows with the pitching staff either. Just about nothing is going right with the Mets, which is, well, how these types of losing streaks happen.

Player	Last week	This week
Huascar Brazobán, RHP
Luis García, RHP
Joey Gerber, RHP	—
Clay Holmes, RHP
Craig Kimbrel, RHP	—
Richard Lovelady, LHP
Sean Manaea, LHP
Nolan McLean, RHP
Tobias Myers, RHP
Freddy Peralta, RHP
David Peterson, RHP
Brooks Raley, LHP
Kodai Senga, RHP
Austin Warren, RHP	—
Luke Weaver, RHP
Devin Williams, RHP

Like with the hitters, there has been some roster turnover since our last meter. Richard Lovelady, who pitched 2 1/3 scoreless innings across two appearances on back-to-back days, is now on the Washington Nationals. Luis García, who got lit up in the series finale against the Diamondbacks, was released and picked up by the Twins on a minor league deal. When Lovelady was designated for assignment, the Mets called up Craig Kimbrel, who has been a pleasant surprise and has yet to allow an earned run in his first four Mets appearances, despite taking the loss in Sunday’s walk-off defeat for allowing the ghost runner to score. Briefly on the roster was 28-year-old righty Joey Gerber, who pitched two scoreless innings in his debut in the series opener against the Dodgers in which the Mets were shut out. But unfortunately Gerber is now on the injured list due to a blister and the Mets called up Austin Warren to replace him on the roster. Warren gave up a solo homer on Wednesday in his 2026 debut after things had already gotten out of hand. Given that Christian Scott is set to be called up to start on Thursday and Warren is one of the only optionable arms the Mets have, he may not be long for the roster either.

Things were already out of hand by the time Warren entered the game on Wednesday because Devin Williams gave up a grand slam to Dalton Rushing that put that game out of reach. That outing marked the first runs Williams surrendered as a Met. It wasn’t a good week for Williams, who also blew his first save opportunity as a Met on Sunday by giving up the game-tying run in the ninth. He did strike out three batters in the inning to limit the damage and send the game to extra innings, but a blown save it was nonetheless.

Tobias Myers started Sunday’s game because David Peterson has been jettisoned to the bullpen. They piggybacked Sunday’s game and both pitched well. Myers gave up one hit over two scoreless innings, striking out two and walking one. Peterson followed in bulk relief and pitched 3 2/3 scoreless innings. It was a bounce back outing for both of them. Peterson was coming off two poor starts in a row that lost him his rotation spot and would have earned him a poop emoji too if it wasn’t for Sunday’s strong outing. Myers’ run of brilliance to start the season ended when he gave up three runs to the A’s over three innings of long relief, but the Mets were shut out in that game too. Myers also gave up one run over two innings in Wednesday’s 8-2 loss to the Dodgers.

Clay Holmes started Wednesday’s game and took the loss, despite pitching well. He gave up two runs on four hits through five innings of work, striking out four and walking one. Holmes was the starter the day Myers got roughed up by the A’s too and also took the loss in that start despite yielding just one run in 5 1/3 innings of work because the Mets were shut out. Holmes has been one of the few consistent performers on the staff and still earns positive marks, as the two L’s on his ledger are hardly his fault.

Nolan McLean has been the Mets’ best starter though, which is not all that surprising. Both of his most recent starts were games that were blown by the bullpen. On Tuesday, McLean struck out eight over seven fantastic innings, over which he gave up just one run. But of course, the Mets lost 2-1. Against the Diamondbacks, McLean took the loss despite being brilliant through six. In the seventh, he walked the leadoff hitter, retired the next better, and then allowed a single before he was taken out of the game. Both of those runs would come around to score, charged to McLean.

It was Luke Weaver who blew up in that game, allowing both of his inherited runners from McLean to score and then two more of his own for good measure. He followed that up with a nightmarish outing against the A’s last Saturday in which he was lit up for four runs. He only avoid the poop emoji because he bounced back in Chicago with back-to-back scoreless appearances in close games over the weekend. McLean’s other start was blown by Brooks Raley and that outing represented the first blemish on his record all season. He too was scored upon in back-to-back appearances, but not knocked around to the level that Weaver was. Also like Weaver, he bounced back to earn a hold in Sunday’s game.

One of the only relievers who maintained a clean sheet over this terrible stretch is Huascar Brazobán, who is, I believe, the last member of the Opening Day bullpen remaining with a 0.00 ERA. Brazobán did mop-up duty in both of Kodai Senga’s most recent starts, which were both horrific. Senga gets slapped with the poop emoji for that, but still has his rotation spot, albeit tenuously. Brazobán pitched 2 2/3 scoreless innings in relief of Senga against the A’s. He had a rockier outing following Senga against the Cubs, but the Mets’ defense didn’t exactly help his cause. Brazobán issued two walks to load the bases in Sunday’s game with a skinny one-run lead to protect, but escape the jam by striking out Seiya Suzuki.

In the second of Senga’s disastrous starts, Sean Manaea pitched the bulk of long relief and the Cubs piled on against him, tagging him for five runs in four innings of work. His other outing in this twelve-game span was a positive one though; he pitched three hitless innings in a tight game in the series finale against the A’s.

That outing was in relief of Freddy Peralta, who had a very good outing that day, despite the Mets being shut out (I’m sensing a theme here). He delivered a quality start, yielding just one run on four hits through six innings of work, striking out six and walking three. Unfortunately, he took the tough luck loss. He was equally sharp through 5 2/3 in Chicago, but then unfortunately issued back-to-back walks with two outs in the sixth, which both came around to score on a home run surrendered by Brooks Raley. Overall, Peralta has been solid, but gasses quickly in the middle innings.