There were some interesting players who were non-tendered around MLB yesterday. Could the Guardians pursue any of them?
Luis Gil, RHP, 28 years old, career 3.61 ERA/4.54 ERA, 9/5 K/BB/9. After winning Rookie of the Year in 2024, Gil has fallen apart with injuries and ineffectiveness. Would he be willing to sign as a reliever? If so, his fastball and slider still look solid and he may have potential to be very effective in one-inning stints.
Trevor Larnach, OF 29 years old, 108 wRC+ and 25/10 K/BB%
for his career – Larnach cannot his lefties at all but has a 132 wRC+ against LHP. He’s a bad outfielder but could he be paired with Adell to help keep Larnach healthy and maximize around 300-350 plate appearances against RHP?
Bailey Ober, RHP 31 years old, career 4.15/4.22 ERA/FIP, 8.4/2 K/BB/9 – Ober would be a minor league free agent candidate but he gets great extension and I could see the Guardians working with him on a sinker/cutter-heavy mix to be an effective back-end-of-the-rotation option. I suspect someone will give him a major league deal, however.
Matt Wallner, OF 29 years old, 122 wRC+, 33/10 K/BB% for his career – A carbon copy of Larnach, Wallner cannot hit LHP but has a career 137 wRC+ vs RHP. He is also an even worse fielder. Again, is there a chance to split DH between Wallner and Adell and end up with an all-star level hitter?
Luke Raley, 1B/OF 32 years old, 113 wRC+, 31/6.5 K/BB% for his career – With a career 124 wRC+ against RHP, Raley offers some of what Larnach and Wallner do, however he has played at first base some. He has been bad defensively there and in the outfield, though. I wonder if Raley is heading toward a minor league deal whenever the lockout ends, in which case I’d be interested. But I prefer Larnach and Wallner in this role.
Davis Schneider, UTL, 27 years old, 105 wRC+ 30.5/13.6 K/BB% for his career – Schneider has a career 98 wRC+ vs LHP and 110 vs RHP. He’s been essentially an average defender at second base or the corner outfield spots. To be honest, I don’t see a great fit here but if you thought he could get back to his 127 wRC+ of 2025, he would be great. But I am not sure why you’d think that.
Right-handed outfielders Victor Bericoto and Matt Vierling don’t offer enough of a platoon advantage combined with their lack of defensive excellence to make them of much interest to me.
Wallner and Larnach’s stats play slightly up at Progressive Field and Raley’s and Schneider’s play slightly down. Larnach has, by far, the best plate discipline of the bunch, so he would be my choice. I think a mix of Adell and Larnach at DH has potential to be a huge improvement over the current plan of Adell and Manzardo or Ingle and would love for the Guardians to pursue this discarded division rival’s former hot prospect.
Which player would you prefer? Do you have someone you like better who isn’t listed above? Let us know in the comments below.













