Today is an off day for the Penguins and things are draaaagging this week with four days between games. It’s not the end of the calendar year just yet, but with Thanksgiving approaching next week and the holiday season right around the corner, this looks like a good time to give into impotence and see how things we thought in December of 2025 for how the calendar year of 2026 would go.
Evgeni Malkin gets a contract extension
It was widely reported that the Penguins had little to no interest in extending
Evgeni Malkin entering this season. Malkin has put up 29 points in 26 games and made little secret that if it were up to him that 2025-26 would not be his last year playing in Pittsburgh. It won’t.
Here’s one in the correct column. By the spring of 2025 it looked like Malkin might have been winding down – he only scored nine points in the last 17 games of the 2024-25 season, which was the worst point/game season of his career with just 50 in 68 contests. Since then over the last 13 months, Malkin has played some really inspired hockey staying productive with 78 points in 74 games since the start of 2025-26 and playing with an obvious, proud veteran chip on his shoulder who doesn’t want to get put out to pasture.
The Pens didn’t have much choice but to bring him back in 2026-27, and so far Malkin’s held up his end of the bargain.
External Sidney Crosby trade ‘rumors’ will go even crazier
It’s a cottage industry for outside media members, many north of the border, to wish away Sidney Crosby from the Penguins “for his own good” to have a chance to win with Colorado or even Montreal. Crosby’s own agent has done nothing to tamp down the desires for his client to have a meaningful conclusion to his playing days. Alas, though it will result in much sound and fury in the interests of gaining attention and clicks,
There’s a lot of reasons to be happy about Pittsburgh getting one more crack at the playoffs in 2026, the biggest might be to tamp down the Crosby rumor mill. Most of the ‘insiders’ have by now accepted and talk up the fact that Crosby himself has never really wanted to change teams. The future is always uncertain, ironically recently more has shifted towards what could happen with Malkin down the stretch this year.
For now, we’ll chalk this up as a happy to be wrong that Crosby-related trade talk was mostly extinguished in 2026, possibly and hopefully for good.
Most, if not all of the major veteran pieces stick around
If Crosby and Malkin are in place, it makes some level of sense to stave off desires to trade the Bryan Rust, Erik Karlsson, Rickard Rakell contingent of veterans around them. All have contracts that last at least through all of 2026, and in the order listed above are most likely to stick around. With prorated cap hits disappearing and multiple-team retention abilities limited, in-season trades of players with major salaries will be difficult for contenders to pull off. Dubas has never been in a major hurry to trade any viable player whose contract wasn’t expiring, a trend that we see continuing throughout 2026.
This is subject still to change in the next six weeks, but for now all of Rust, Rakell and Karlsson remain with the Penguins. There are stories and reports of the team being ‘open for business’ and it surely looks like in 2027 that some/many of these names might be moving on. For now, status quo was easy to see as a result since the Penguins haven’t been in a hurry to tear down major, contributing pieces to their team while they still have term left on their contracts, and none of those players do until Karlsson’s contract runs out in 2027.
No playoffs in 2026, but no huge collapse
The Penguins are currently clustered within a 10-team group in the Eastern Conference that has between 40-45 points, with playoff spots for the top three of those teams. They will not get one of them (Washington, New Jersey and Florida will), but Pittsburgh will also not have the bottom drop out and go all the way to the bottom of the conference like some others inevitably will.
This one left egg on our face. The Pens did well to make the playoffs, going an impressive 24-13-7 down the stretch and pick up 55 points in their remaining 44 games (even more impressive considering they rested players and weren’t even trying to win in the last few games). The bigger story overall might be the division- Columbus (11-10-5 after the Olympics) and the New York Islanders (11-13-0) had major meltdowns in the final stretch of the season. Washington and New Jersey, who we thought would eventually get their acts together, never did. The Rangers were a mess from start to finish.
It was a perfect storm for the Pens (and, sadly, the Flyers) to sneak towards the top of the division, and one that might not repeat every year for all the teams around them besides Carolina end up having different degrees of surprisingly disappointing seasons.
Trades will result in more change than free agency
Kyle Dubas is a known flipper and will continue to swing assets around.….Pittsburgh won’t be going out and paying Alex Tuch or Artemi Panarin $11+ million contracts on multi-year deals and again look to focus on the Parker Wotherspoon/Justin Brazeau B-level free agents that could use a bigger opportunity to showcase their talents.
At it’s core, this is correct. The Pens weren’t terribly active in free agency, making a few adds like Andrei Kuzmenko, Trevor van Riemsdyk and Declan Carlile from the summer shopping market. (Wow, what a class that’s turning out to be! Sadly, a lot of the magic from the 2025 FA class didn’t carry over this past year..)
On the other hand, Pittsburgh added six players currently on the roster (plus depth defender Ilya Solovyov who often is) to the club in 2026 via trades by bringing in Sam Girard, Elmer Soderblom, Hendrix Lapierre, Kaedan Korzcak, Nick Robertson and Spencer Stastney in various deals during the calendar year.
Despite a large amount of cap space, Kyle Dubas had said all along that he wasn’t interested in high-priced and long-term contracts to lock up players for most of their 30’s, as most the top free agents on the market can command. For better or worse, Dubas stuck to his guns on that front by only making one and two year commitments, and letting others like Ryan Shea go find longer contracts with another team.
Sergei Murashov will chase two different types of Calders in 2026
In the spring of 2026, Murashov and Wilkes-Barre/Scranton will make a serious run at the AHL Championship, the Calder Cup. That will only be a precursor for Murashov, who by the end of 2026 will become the primary goalie in Pittsburgh and have his name firmly in the mix for the 2026-27 Calder trophy
The words “chase” and “firmly” do a lot of heavy lifting, but this one ended up mostly right. Murashov was by far the best player for WBS’s 2026 playoff run and helped them into the Eastern Conference Final. He then made the NHL at age-22 coming out of training camp. That’s the heart of the matter for the prediction and it has a solid base there.
For the fine details, Murashov, of course, is not going to get much true Calder buzz for 2027 rookie of the year. Montreal goalie Jacob Fowler is doing better and going to lap up all the attention on goalies in that race with Cole Hutson, James Hagens and Gavin McKenna as the main contenders at this point. But the spirit of this prediction for a big step forward for Murashov in 2026 was in the right place. That’s not exactly going out on a huge limb since Murashov’s stock was trending up, it’s still a good thing he did stay on schedule with his progression up to the NHL ended up being predictably linear to this point.
Only 2 of the 12 impending unrestricted free agents are retained
Some of the names (Dumba, Hayes, Clifton, Danton Heinen) are easy clears for the Pens to let slide away when their contracts expire. Malkin, as mentioned, will be one of the few to stick around. Perhaps Ryan Shea as well, if a trade offer doesn’t present itself as more tempting. Ancillary pieces (Dewar, Blake Lizotte, Noel Acciari, Brett Kulak) will all move on from Pittsburgh as they look to get younger with the next wave of AHL players moving up, same goes for Stuart Skinner….It’s possible a select handful from the Dewar, Lizotte, Skinner, Shea group will be back
Close, but no cigar. Three impending unrestricted free agents (Malkin, Dewar, Lizotte) were kept, the other nine (Mantha, Dumba, Hayes, Clifton, Heinen, Kulak, Skinner, Acciari and Shea) moved on from Pittsburgh, some before the end of the 2025-26 season.
Overall, 2026 for the Penguins has been an odd year. They did better than almost anyone expected in the first part, only to slink away in the first round of the playoffs. Since then, there hasn’t been much to get them out of a holding pattern that’s led to an unimpressive end of the year on the ice.
All that means is buckle up for next month’s predictions for 2027, there is a lot up on the air with all of Crosby, Malkin and Karlsson in the final years of their contracts, the potential for a draft lottery and moving onto the next chapters for the franchise in many regards..













