Six games in, and it’s safe to say that—outside of the offensive outburst on opening day—the bats have gotten off to a slow start for the Mets. They haven’t scored more than four runs in a game since that first one, and numerous games have gone into extra innings because the Mets couldn’t bring enough runs home to win in regulation despite the pitching staff holding the opposing offense at bay.
Well, we got another one of those games today—and this was perhaps the most frustrating of them all, as the Mets
failed twice to score in extra innings and fell to the Cardinals 2-1 to lose the series.
Today’s game started an hour late due to rain, but the Mets’ bats did not seem to get the memo about the new start time. Indeed, after failing to score at all in last night’s game, the offense once again looked helpless against Cardinals starter Matthew Liberatore, who retired the first fourteen batters of the game before Mark Vientos broke up the perfect game with a two-out double in the fifth. Alas, through five innings the Mets were held scoreless, making it seventeen straight innings without a run dating back to Monday night. Thankfully, the Amazins had their top starter on the mound, as Freddy Peralta suited up for his second start of the season and matched Liberatore in putting up zeroes. The biggest threat against him came in the bottom of the fifth when the Cardinals got runners on second and third with just one out, but a strikeout and groundout kept the game scoreless.
Francisco Lindor got on base in the top of the sixth thanks to a one-out error, but was immediately picked off (which counted as the second mental error of the day for Lindor, who also forgot how many outs there were and gave up a potential double play earlier). That proved to be consequential, as Juan Soto then came up and hit a high fly ball to right that just barely stayed fair and went over the fence for what should have been a two-run homer. Still, the scoreless streak was finally over thanks to the Soto’s first bomb of the season, and the Mets had themselves their first lead of the day. But alas, they would not hold it for long. Peralta quickly got into trouble in the bottom of the frame, allowing a single and walk to put runners on first and second with nobody out and then falling behind 3-1 to Alec Burleson. He managed to fight back and strike Burleson out, at which point Carlos Mendoza turned to the bullpen. Huascar Brazobán came on and induced an infield pop-up for the second out, but Nolan Gorman then lined a single into center to tie the game at 1-1. A strikeout then ended the inning and finalized Peralta’s line on the day (5.1 innings, 3 hits, 2 walks, 7 strikeouts, 1 run).
The Cardinals pulled Liberatore after six innings of one-run ball, and old friend Ryne Stanek was the first pitcher out of the St. Louis bullpen. The Mets got two runners on against him—on a Luis Robert Jr. single and a two-out catcher’s interference against Francisco Alvarez—and Mendoza then called upon Carson Benge to pinch-hit for Tyrone Taylor. The Cardinals responded by bringing in lefty reliever JoJo Romero, who struck out the rookie to end the threat. We then got a string of 1-2-3 innings from both bullpens (first from Brooks Raley, then a full frame from Romero, then from Luke Weaver) to bring us to the ninth with the score still tied.
Jorge Polanco led off the inning with a double against Riley O’Brien. But as they have done over and over and over and over again in this first week of the season, the Mets failed to capitalize on the threat, and three straight outs—culminating in a strikeout by Marcus Semien, who has not gotten a hit since opening day—sent the game into the bottom of the ninth. Seeking to get the game to extra innings, Mendoza turned to his closer, and Devin Williams was able to work around a leadoff walk to hold the Cardinals scoreless and give the Mets their third extra inning game in this young season.
The Mets and their futile offense then committed the cardinal (no pun intended) sin of playing extra innings on the road and failed to score even the ghost runner in the top of the tenth against new pitcher Justin Bruihl. In do or die mode, Mendoza turned to Tobias Myers (who had just pitched multiple innings on Monday) to attempt the unenviable task of trying to hold the Cardinals scoreless and send the game to the 11th. And remarkably, Myers was able to get the job done, as he struck out the leadoff batter after a failed attempt at bunting the ghost runner over to third, and then two harmless groundouts ended the frame with the game still tied at 1-1.
Given new life, surely the Mets’ bats wouldn’t fail to score yet again, right? Surely they aren’t THAT pathetic, right? Well, after a Bo Bichette groundout off new pitcher Chris Roycroft sent the ghost runner to third, back-to-back walks loaded the bases with one out. The Cardinals brought in a new pitcher—right-hander Gordon Graceffo—to try to get out of the jam. And get out of the jam he did, as Brett Baty then hit a soft grounder to second that result in a forceout at home and Semien (who, again, has not gotten a hit since opening day) flew out to end the inning with the Mets being held scoreless yet again.
So Myers was forced to go out for a second inning and try to pull a rabbit out of his hat yet again. And for a moment it looked like he might, as he induced a groundball double play (following an intentional walk to start the inning) to give the Mets two out with a runner at third base. Alas, Masyn Wynn—who had not had a hit all series leading up to this at-bat—blooped a ball into right field that was just past the reach of a diving Benge, bringing the winning run home to end the game.
It’s been six games. Far too soon to be drawing any meaningfully conclusions. But boy howdy this offense has been dreadful to watch one week in, and for the sake of all of our sanity they should try really hard to be better moving forward—particularly in this part of the season before they start facing off against some more intimidating competition later in the year. Onto San Francisco.
SB Nation GameThreads
Box scores
Win Probability Added
FanGraphs" />
Big Mets winner: Freddy Peralta, +20.8% WPA
Big Mets loser: Marcus Semien, -34.9% WPA
Mets pitchers: +25.4% WPA
Mets hitters: -75.4% WPA
Teh aw3s0mest play: Juan Soto solo homer in the sixth, +18.3% WPA
Teh sux0rest play: Masyn Wynn walk-off single in the 11th, -37.5% WPA
