Hello CSR! Welcome to Brian Answers, part two of your weekly Panthers fan mailbag for everyone. The Panthers season is well on its way as they still control their own destiny. Thanksgiving is around the corner and I’m happy football is still meaningful at this juncture. Let’s dive right into all your questions!
RealityDan: So question… according to a quick google search, the Panthers have two “return from IR designations”. One seems to be locked in for Horn, do we use the other one on Thomas Incoom
or do we hold onto it and loose Incoom for the rest of the season?
I believe you are correct in that Jaycee Horn is earmarked for one of those designations, unless they decide it isn’t worth bringing him back. I don’t know what his injury situation looks like since he didn’t get surgery and is rehabbing it instead, so it is definitely possible he doesn’t come back at all. For the last spot, I suspect at this point in the season they will still hold one. Remember, they only have to be in injured/reserve for 4 weeks to qualify for that designation. We still have 8 games left, so lots of runway.
schrodingersblackcat: Brian, what was your favorite part of the game on Sunday? Beating the Saints in NO? Chuba going into full-on superhero mode? Our recovering DEF showing up and looking like they’re could soon become more-than-respectable? Freeling and Hunter showing us signs that they’re the future of this franchise? The 15 minute mindless turducken conversation that let you completely switch off and dissociate just long enough to forget how boring the first half was? Which aspect of this victory isn’t being celebrated enough?
Also: Brad Idzik gets a visit from the Ghost of Offensive Drives Past. What does the ghost show and tell him?
I don’t care how ugly the victory is, a win against the Saints in New Orleans will always be a massive plus in my book. Carolina also hasn’t beaten the Saints in two whole seasons, so we’ll take it. I would also say seeing the defense play hard and fast. They are certainly still motivated which gives me hope this team could still make the playoffs and be somewhat competitive, at least in the wild card.
I would imagine the ghost shows him that having Bryce Young take the easy throws is sometimes the right call. I know that many have detracted from the win on Sunday since Bryce was hitting Chuba Hubbard out of the backfield, but Brad Idzik’s offense is definitely taking a lot more shots down field. WHICH IS GOOD! But some weeks, you just got to take what the defense is giving you rather than pushing the ball down the field when it isn’t as necessary. The NFL now knows Carolina isn’t going to hesitate to throw the deep balls, that does open things up in the short game in itself.
@WTMealey: What NFC wildcard contender playoff teams do you think we can beat? At least have a decent chance even if we’re not favored.
I think even with our current losing record the goal is a playoff W. That would look like progress.
I’d say the Lions and Packers are teams the Panthers can beat. They already beat the Lions and I think the Packers game goes a bit differently in round two. I’d also go with the Rams and Seahawks, just because the Rams aren’t a dream team and I think they played Seattle well enough last season that they could make a jump. I’m not expecting the playoffs right now but if they do make it, I think there’s a real chance they could win at home against some of these teams.
TXPanther: What should be my 3rd side choice for our Thanksgiving order? We are going with Mashed Sweet Potatoes and Fire Roasted Brussels Sprouts. The last option comes down to Mac & Cheese, Green Bean Casserole, or Mashed Potatoes with poblano mushroom sauce. There’s a cornbread stuffing option but we didn’t like it last year.
I’m very partial to Green Bean Casserole, though it was one of my favorite recipes growing up that had a lot more fixings in it that I think most recipes have as a standard. Mashed Potatoes with that mushroom sauce sound very good as well though. If I were coming to your Thanksgiving I’d be excited to try them.
TXPanther: How many penalties/penalty yards will the Panthers have this week?
25 yards on 2 penalties, this is the get right game. Book it, you heard it here first.
Brazilian Panther: Give us three players you want to see resigned and other three dudes you want to see released or traded at the end of the season Brian.
The list to bring back is pretty easy for me, OT Ikem Ekwonu, CB Mike Jackson, and TE Tommy Tremble. I think the Panthers are in a much better situation if the first two are healthy this season, and bringing back Jackson allows them to play a slower game with upgrading the cornerback situation. And Tommy Tremble just deserves it with how far along he has come. He’s an important piece in the passing game now and has always been an important piece in the run blocking attack.
Based on your question I assume we’re not talking about players that are simply going to be free agents in 2027. I’m going to preface this question by saying I almost never vote for players to lose their jobs. But, if I had to pick, I think you need to let OG Robert Hunt go, DT Terk Wharton go, and maybe QB Kenny Pickett. For the first two, it would be purely for cap reasons as compared to performance. But I wouldn’t be upset if they both stay. As for Pickett, I think his ceiling is fairly capped if he ever needs to come in for a long period. I’d bring in another veteran with higher upside or see what you really have in Haynes King.
Bull123: just took a quick look at tampas schedule…notwithstanding lions this week, they have chargers, ravens, saints twice, falcons, rams and us
they can easily be 9-8…i see no path for us without beating them on the Monday night game
are they the hurdle?
After the beating they put on the Panthers, not only do I think they need to beat them to push any tie-breakers, but I think the Panthers have to beat them to prove they deserve to be in the wild card. Every season teams have bad games, but that was a fundamental beating you need to really bounce back from in game 2.
Irishboy: Brian, I thought the Panther’s offense was completely out of sink most of the game against the Saints. While I thought this could be a get right game for them, only for Chuba, we would have been in trouble. I know the saints have a decent front 7, but their secondary wasn’t.
As I am someone you wouldn’t have a strong grasp on schematics, why was our offense basically bad?
As schrodingersblackcat pointed out in the comments, the Saints did play a lot of man against the Panthers, and that has generally been their formula playing against the Dave Canales/Brad Idzik offense. While I love Jalen Coker and Tetairoa McMillan, both guys just aren’t as strong against man coverage because they aren’t the fastest guys. Both can win jump balls and 50/50 passes for sure, but in man they are more likely to have a guy in their hip pocket which forces tighter window throws. I think this is why losing Chris Brazzell for the season was a bigger deal than people realize, the offense just doesn’t have that speed option that can beat the breaks off a guy who just wants to run with them. Couple that with Idzik trying to push the ball down the field more and the margin for error is just much lower. All in my opinion, but I’ve seen several analysts this week share the same sentiment.
schrodingersblackcat: Who was the best James Bond, and why was it Sean Connery?
Sean Connery is a strong one. I have more of a connection to Daniel Craig but that was because Connery was a bit before my time. I will say, my out of left field answer, Patrick Gibson as a young James Bond in the First Light video game actually really hit with me for some reason. Definitely worth checking out if you are a 007 fan and play modern day games.
That’s all for this week, Panthers fans. Enjoy this week and hopefully another victory for the team. KEEP POUNDING!













