Maikel Garcia was poised to be a breakout star this season. In the World Baseball Classic, Garcia excelled for his home country of Venezuela, and after the final against the United States it was Garcia—not Bobby Witt Jr.—who ended with the better offensive line (.962 OPS vs .733 OPS) and an RBI in that key match. It was a continuation of Garcia’s excellent 2025, an All-Star season in which he put up 5.6 Wins Above Replacement per Fangraphs and won his first Gold Glove.
All of this excitement prompted
yours truly to write an article gushing about Garcia titled “Maikel Garcia has the juice.” In it, I said that my intuition said that Garcia could maybe have another gear in him, that he’s got a sort of je ne sais quoi about him, and that if anyone could fight off the regression monster after a career year, it was him.
I also wrote this:
The unfortunate truth is that everyone can’t improve. Even when lots of players improve, some don’t. Some do worse. Others get hurt. Take any two consecutive years and you’ll see that pattern. Like, look to the 2015 Royals championship season, a big step forward over 2014. Some players got better, but not all: Alcides Escobar was worse, Alex Gordon got hurt, Salvador Perez was worse, Jason Vargas got hurt, Omar Infante was worse, Greg Holland got hurt, Danny Duffy was worse.
Well, shoot.
Yes, the dust has settled on 2026, and Garcia did not, in fact, improve. To be completely fair to Garcia, he was still quite good when on the field, and would have put up in the realm of ~3.5 WAR if he had 160 games under his belt like he did last year. But there’s the rub: Garcia did not play 160 games. In a frustrating season, Garcia was only limited to 82 games, a tick over half the year.
Garcia first missed half a dozen games in May with a hamstring injury. Then there came a bizarre hand injury situation, where he missed more games over the next month or so before finally going on the injured list near the end of June. And then when Garcia came back on August 17, he played in all of four games before injuring his other hamstring and missing another 21 games.
I don’t know about you all, but it certainly didn’t feel like Garcia played 82 games this year. Partially that was because the Royals were really bad, of course, and that impacts cognition of a lot of things. Partially it’s because he regressed from a 120 wRC+ last year to a 99 wRC+ this year and therefore didn’t have as many cool moments. Partially it’s because he was gone for not just one really long stretch of time, but two, alongside peppered unavailability in between.
There’s just not much to say about Garcia this year because I don’t think we learned anything. Can he replicate 2025 again? There’s a chance. But it was quite a career year, and he just has to be ok offensively to be an overall boon for the team; being good is a bonus. And when a player suffers multiple different injuries after years of healthy playing, you can’t really label Garcia with an “injury-prone” sticker.
So I guess we’ll look at next year to see if Garcia can at least put together a full, healthy season, and we’ll see if his offensive woes this year were due to his myriad injuries. What hasn’t changed, though, is my opinion of Garcia. I think he has “it”, whatever “it” is. I think he’ll bounce back next year.













