It’s hard to overstate just how far Brandon Marsh has fallen this season. On the eve of starting in his first All-Star game, Marsh was hitting .301, seventh best in the NL, with an .829 OPS and 15 home runs, one away from tying his career high. Now as we enter the last full week of the regular season, Marsh’s season numbers have fallen to a .260 AVG and .709 OPS. Those would be the worst season numbers for him since arriving in Philadelphia at the 2022 trade deadline.
That dramatic drop in his overall
numbers is due to Marsh being arguably the worst hitter in baseball since the All-Star break. In fact, his 24 wRC+ and -1.4 fWAR in the second half are the worst of any qualified hitter in baseball. Marsh’s slash line of .180/.237/.238 clearly illustrates just how ineffective he’s been over the last two and a half months. He has just six extra base hits in 46 second half game after having 32 across 92 games in the first half. Marsh went from looking like he finally stepped out of a platoon and into a role as a starting caliber outfielder to regressing further than he ever has since putting on a Phillies uniform, so much so that a platoon has become mandatory and even his playing time in general should be questioned.
With this being the last week of the regular season, it would remain to be seen just how much would be gained from benching Marsh. There is not much that can be done to the roster at this point to provide a meaningful change heading into the postseason. But with that said, the Phillies could look to give either Derek Hill or Bryan De La Cruz more starts against right-handed pitching in order to try and find some more production than what Marsh is currently offering. The caveat there though is that neither of those two has a good track record of hitting righties particularly well, with Hill hitting .229 with a .656 OPS this season. De La Cruz has been good in limited opportunities this season with a .364 AVG and .924 OPS in just 37 plate appearances, but his career line against RHP is a much more pedestrian .248/.292/.412.
So, should the Phillies cut back on Brandon Marsh’s playing time? If so, who should get more at-bats? What would you do with Marsh in the postseason?
