Are we a good football team?–PSU1979dude
We’re definitely at least average! Nowhere near the bottom feeder that many of our own fans called us a month ago, but I’m not sure that I’d say we’re “good” yet. Ask me again in two weeks.
How did we go from “JFC just win a conference game” to “OMG we let them score when we were up 5TDs?!?!?”–vern05
Fandom is a funny thing, ready to flip on a dime. It’s also probably a little bit of PTSD from earlier in the season – or even just the week prior, when we all were
convinced that 28 points weren’t enough at the half.
Luckily, we had 35, and that was more than enough against Minnesota.
Does Rutgers still have the crazy tall receivers that our DBs couldn’t touch with a ladder last year? If so, this game could be a lot like last year where they just threw the ball high and we looked a bit pathetic trying to cover. We didn’t actually cover the receivers, which is another reason that passing worked so well against us. . Are we improved upon that?–Blrac
I don’t think they do. Their best receiver is out for the year, and I heard their main QB was questionable too. Our pass defense, unlike the rest of the team, isn’t just good, it’s likely great, so I doubt this will be a problem for us in this game this year. But I’ve been wrong before, and any thing CAN happen on any given Saturday!
If you are a top recruit as a punter, should you go to Rutgr since you would get a lot of work in?–LarzLion
On a similar vein, I’d probably go to Iowa, as much as that pains me. It’s not just a lot of work (which is definitely important) but it’s also how much the coaching staff values the position that you play – and the Hawkeyes definitely value punting. Plus, they’re actually ranked this year, so in addition to getting good coaching and reps, a player would get eyeballs on their play if they hope to play at the next level.
What’s the deal with Arrington? Know he had an injury but was hoping he’d be higher on the depth chart by now.–StixCity
He had an injury that kept him definitely out until after the BYE week. If memory serves, he may have had a few snaps in the Purdue game – I am pretty sure he didn’t get any this past week, and am unsure about Washington. We actually had our best pass rush of the season without his contributions this past week, so while I’d absolutely be happy for him to bolster our depth up front, I’d rather he make sure that he’s 100% before we put him out there when we don’t need to.
We’ve touched on this subject before, but Penn State is an outlier in the northeast as far as college football is concerned. Is it possible the outsiders who infected the University after IT in an effort to show us hicks how it’s done, have instead just moved football to the same irrelevant level it is at all other northeast D1 FBS schools? My wife, a third-generation Penn Stater who grew up in State College, remarked after the game Saturday that it was the emptiest she has ever seen the stadium in her entire life. It seems many folks are no longer mad at how horribad the team is, they simply don’t care. I mean, we didn’t even reserve our tickets by the early deadline on Nov. 11th. For five extra NLC points? Who gives an ass-rats?–Smee
I don’t think the attendance and team performance are related to each other, and to the rest of your comment. For example, my crew ended up housegating instead of tailgating on Saturday because of the weather, and a half dozen of us decided we just weren’t up to going into the game with the weather, and since this week’s game was going to be much more pleasant just a week later (it also helped that I was able to give a veteran friend my seats in a more desirable place in the stadium, instead of him sitting in the upper deck where his military appreciation tickets were). Everyone in our crew is still very much invested in football and rooting the team on, every play, but decided that it would be a better life decision for those of us who stayed to watch it from the house.
I also did not renew by the 11th deadline, because of the aforementioned issues I had at the white out (and the ticket office’s so far incredibly underwhelming response), and the fact that they tried to charge me thousands of extra dollars. I still care (and I still will be getting my upgraded seats next year, alongside those of three other sports I have season tickets to), but some of the decisions they’ve made have been baffling. I just don’t think it’s moved football to an irrelevant level as most of the other northeast schools – or at least I hope not.
misdreavus79 has been allocating PSU Bags o’Cash TM for other team’s players for next year. You have a list?–JayMPSU
If we’re talking pure pie-in-the-sky wishlist, I’d have to go Malachi Toney and Darian Mensah both from Miami. They’ve been dynamic to watch, and I’d love nothing more than to be able to root for them full-throatedly. To be clear, it’s never going to happen, though.
Thanks for the recommendations last week, we hit up Happy Valley Live and it was weirdly empty at noon, but the food was good. Had fun tailgating afterwards with our parking neighbors and enjoyed Mt Nittany Club during the game, saw some recruits wandering around the concession area including Odoh at halftime (would have thought they’d be on the field?).
As for the game it was weirdly anticlimactic being back for the first time in almost a decade, it felt weirdly detached with the almost near constant pumped in noise/music. There was a lot of that back in the day, but this felt like it was taken to the Nth degree. What is up with that? Product of low attendance or ??????–eternalpessimist
It’s probably a combination of both the weather and the attendance. It’s definitely gotten more and more professionalized in the last few years, with a focus on performing rather than the actual school and football, and while I don’t hate a lot of the piped in music choices this year, I too would prefer to hear the band more. I’ve also taken to wearing loop earplugs in most if not all sports events on campus, because the volume is just out of control (yes, I’m getting old).
report that Brian Kelly is interested in the MD job, your thoughts?
If he’s hired, will he start calling everyone Hon and eating crabcakes 3x a day?–kingkub
As much as I would hate this on both sides, in some ways it seems like this is a perfect fit. Of course a team that killed a player because of practice would look to hire a coach that killed a student at practice! Feels almost like a reversion to mean.
Given that OSU’s fan base is the absolute worst, where does PSU’s non-alumni fan base rank in craziness and impatience as compared to other schools as it pertains to football.–psu1313
Please don’t sell PSU fans short at all, we’re definitely near the top right now. We quickly went back to the “elite or bust” mindset that we were at 30 years ago; that’s why there were calls for Franklin to be fired years before he actually was (well, that and the racism for some). Maybe it’s not quite as bad as OSU, because PSU fans aren’t trying to run a national championship-winning head coach out of the program after one bad year in a new collegiate landscape, but there are many who won’t acknowledge that it’s early in a new tenure in Happy Valley in a free-for-all college landscape, with much more limited NIL resources than the schools we’re trying to compete with. It’s tough to hear, and some may think of it as just excuses, but there’s logic there too.
Philip Rivers has just signed to be NC State’s future head coach. Which former Penn State starting quarterback do you think would make the best head football coach for the Nittany Lions? I am not advocating for this, just wondering which QB would make the best HC. Jay Paterno is eliminated because he never started.–Gerry Dincher
It depends on what kind of head coach we’d be looking for. If it’s someone who’s a CEO-type, surrounding himself with quality downstream coaches and able to sell himself and the program but not miring himself in the playcalling, I’d probably say Michael Robinson – he’s been in professional football and media for two decades now, and has likely cultivated a plethora of key contacts to fill out a very talented coaching roster.
If it’s more of an Xs and Os type of coach, I honestly don’t know who we’d get – maybe Trace? He’s young and unproven at that level, but he is a coach at least (and was briefly on Campbell’s staff as well before taking his current role with the Bills).
If Pat Kraft is Fred Flintstone, who is his Barney Rubble?–Salt Cod
I feel like he could be both Fred *and* Barney in this scenario! I wouldn’t put it past him.
Cari, do you think we’ll see any Penn State wrestle offs at the Black Knight invitational?–Psu77
I’d be more surprised if we don’t, especially at 133, where both Masa Ono and Nate Desmond will probably see the mat. We either won’t see wrestle offs, or it’ll be between two PSUers who won’t really see much time, at 149, 165, 184, 197, and heavyweight, since SVN, Duke, Rocco, Josh Barr, and Connor Mirasola will be competing at the All Star Classic next week.
Last year at this tourney, Desmond beat eventual national champ Luke Lilledahl (it didn’t count in his record because it was a teammate), but I doubt we’ll have anything that exciting, since a lot of the young guns who won’t start for PSU this year are at weights mentioned in the last paragraph. So 133 is going to be quite the highlight for us PSU fans.
I watched a few PSU women’s basketball games and later watched USC vs South Carolina. The difference in quality of play was stark. With a new head coach and having to rebuild the program, realistically how long before they can field a competitive team? Will the university actually provide support? I freely admit basketball is not one of my favorite sports but still it would be nice to see Penn State women and men’s basketball be able to compete.–The Crawling Chaos
It really depends on the calibre of players that Tanisha Wright is able to bring in in future years. If she gets the money and resources to really build her bench, I think 2028-2029 is not unreasonable. They took a step in the right direction this week, though, coming back from a large deficit to beat Bowling Green at home on Thursday!
This is BTPR Super Bowl, the great dislike for PSU is incredible. They can lose every game, but beating PSU as their only win and the fan base would be thrilled being 1-11.
So, what five teams, any sport, do you really dislike Cary [sic]? Mine are below.
1 – OSU
2 – ND
3 – Meatchicken
4- Metropolitans
5- 5b–AndOthersReceivingVotes
I tend to dislike players and coaches (like Bryce Harper, Tom Ryan, and Pat Fitzgerald) a lot more than I dislike individual teams. But I guess if I had to choose:
- Nebraska volleyball
- Ohio State football
- Dallas Cowboys
- Houston Astros
- Pittsburgh Penguins
Two part question:
sporting events that you had the opportunity to attend but didn’t only to instantly and forever regret it after?
- I went to the 1985 Orange Bowl to see us lose to Oklahoma and passed on the Fiesta Bowl the next year….big regret there
- and a friend bought tix for the Duke-Kentucky game at the Spectrum in 1992 that is considered one of the greatest college basketball games of all time. didn’t really have the money at the time to overpay for the tix, but in hindsight, I’ve pissed away money on dumber things
On the flip side, what great sports events were you able to attend?
- I was in the stands the night Cal Ripken Jr broke the Ironman’s record and many of Joe’s milestone victories–kingkub
The biggest one I regret not going to was Joe’s final win at Penn State. I lived in Maryland at the time, and didn’t have a hotel for that game, so my sister and I were planning on driving up and back the same day that day; the weather ended up being not good at all, so we decided to stay home instead. With the benefit of hindsight, I would’ve found a way to get up there. I also do regret watching all of the Nationals’ post season in 2019 from my couch instead of finding a way to see at least one game in person, though not any of the world series (since we lost all of those home games). Probably the wild card game would’ve been the best.
I’ve been able to attend a lot of great sporting events, like the 2016 win over OSU, the 2018 NCAA wrestling championships (ie, when Bo Nickal pinned Myles Martin in Cleveland), and a lot of Joe’s milestone victories too. Nothing to the degree that you mention, re: Ripken, which would have been amazing to attend.
Tennessee is 8-2 and ranked 9th . They don’t seem to have had a problem adjusting to Jim Knowles defense . Why did Penn State have such a problem?–paa0028
This is certainly the million dollar question, isn’t it?
In Franklin’s defense (see what I did there?), it did take OSU a few years to really get into Knowles’ defense. But it absolutely should not have been the huge dropoff that it was last year, and the buck ultimately stopped with the head coach at the time.
If you could have attended any other B1G school and studied something different & more exciting, where and what? An example would be Journalism at Northwestern, or Creative Writing at Iowa, or Architecture at USC.
For me, it would be film school at USC.–salmonmousse
If I had attended a different school, it would’ve not been another Big Ten school. I do second guess my major at Penn State quite a bit, though, as I was decidedly not forward-thinking when I was in my early twenties, and I think I would have really succeeded in the fields of engineering or actuarial sciences.
Besides the first football game and Campbell Soup, what else is New Jersey famous for?–Nittpicker
Personally, New Jersey will always be famous for having to pay to leave it. They’ll never live that down.
The Cambridge Dictionary has announced that the word of the year is “human.” Do you think Matt Campbell approves?–Homer Ozzie & The Straw
I’m not sure what “human” has to do with CMC, but sure, ok! I also amd not sure why that’s their choice of word of the year, which seems pretty random to me. Does it have something to do with AI threatening to replace humans? That’s the only way I could make it at all defensible.
McDonald’s has some pretty crappy breakfast sandwiches. I’ll rank them from best to worst. Just sticking with the basics, no Sheetz MTO mayhem here.
- Sausage and Egg McMuffin with Cheese.
- Sausage McGriddle
- Bacon and Egg Biscuit.
- Steak and Egg Bagle [sic]
If McDonald’s adds the Scrapple and Egg (insert bread here), where does it rank? What would the reaction to scrapple be nationwide? Would your local McDonald’s know your order on sight when you roll up to the drive thru of the Scrapple sandwich was added?–Gerry Dincher
I’ve still never tried a sausage and egg mcmuffin, but with this and the same ad I keep seeing during this year’s Hallmark Christmas movies, I now really want to try them (love a sausage mcgriddle, though).
I’d probably rank scrapple at McDonald’s pretty low. I can’t imagine they’d cook it the way good scrapple deserves to be cooked – I envision it would be either all mush, or burnt to a crisp the entire way through. So they wouldn’t know me any more than they do now, which is practically none because I think I’ve been to McDonald’s once in the last few years.
I am pretty sure I misspelled bagel in my previous question. What are some words that you always struggle to spell correctly. For me it’s just about anything that ends with ‘el’ or ‘le’. I have a 50/50 shot of getting it right.–Gerry Dincher
There’s not too many that I always struggle with spelling correctly, but typing them correctly is decidedly another answer. I type so fast and struggle to get my thoughts out on the page that the word I always type wrong (and have set to autocorrect on my work and personal laptops) is “the”. Inevitably, more often than not I type “teh”. Which is very much not correct.













