For all but maybe one or two years in the Aaron Judge era, the Yankees have always had a good, if not great, offense beyond the big man himself. They routinely pace the Junior Circuit in runs, wRC+, home runs, etc. Regardless of who’s in the lineup or what their overall skills are, they generally manage to cobble together a fearsome lineup (well, except in 2023).
That’s not to say they’ve been without flaws. The past half-decade or more of Yankees baseball has usually fielded an offense that meets
the same qualifiers, to the point where it feels like a stereotype. They’ve been overly right-handed. They’ve prioritized the home run ball. They drawn walks and reached base, albeit at the expense of spells of high strikeout rates. They’ve been mediocre at best on defense. They’ve been extremely unathletic and composed of 30-something sluggers. The few players with any sort of athleticism have made bad mistakes on the bases. Their bench has been extremely shallow. On and on and on.
And these stereotypes are not without reason. The Yankees have employed some Three-True Outcome kings (Joey Gallo in particular and Giancarlo Stanton to an extent), have fielded lineups with very few lefties (2018-20, especially), have had substandard defenders littered across the diamond (Luke Voit, Gleyber Torres, Gary Sánchez), and have had some of the worst baserunning teams of all time, buoyed by aging veterans (Stanton, Anthony Rizzo, DJ LeMahieu, Josh Donaldson).
But there was an organizational change that took place at some point after the pandemic, trying to slowly erode this stereotype. Starting in 2021, by acquiring Gallo and Rizzo, the Yankees once again began prioritizing lefty bats who could abuse the short porch. They won the Team Gold Glove in 2022 and focused on finding more fundamentally sound defenders. They looked to reduce their strikeout rate by adding hitters with good plate control after the Gallo experiment flamed out in spectacular fashion. They’ve added more youth and athleticism to their lineup and bench, giving them more late game flexibility.
All of this came to a head at the 2025 Trade Deadline, when the team acquired José Caballero, Amed Rosario, and Austin Slater to add more right-handed depth and positional versatility to a lineup that was lefty-heavy. While Slater is gone (they still wanted him back at one point!), they re-signed Rosario and stopgap Paul Goldschmidt to keep the same versatility in 2026.
That’s where we stand today. For the first time in the Judge era, the Yankees are deep and versatile with their hitting core to start a season, to the point where they could conceivably option a player who would start on most non-playoff teams to the minor leagues. It’s jarring after what we’ve seen in the past.
As things stand entering spring training, the everyday lineup will be identical to the one we saw in October, sans the injured Anthony Volpe. Yet, it’s entirely possible that the team could deploy entirely different lineups depending on the handedness of the starting pitcher:
vs RHP:
Austin Wells (C)
Ben Rice (1B)
Jazz Chisholm Jr. (2B)
Ryan McMahon (3B)
Oswaldo Cabrera (SS)
Cody Bellinger (LF)
Trent Grisham (CF)
Aaron Judge (RF)
Giancarlo Stanton (DH)
vs LHP:
Ben Rice (C)
Paul Goldschmidt (1B)
Jazz Chisholm Jr. (2B)
Amed Rosario (3B)
José Caballero (SS)
Cody Bellinger (LF)
Trent Grisham (CF)
Aaron Judge (RF)
Giancarlo Stanton (DH)
The Yankees are able to simultaneously field quality lineups with seven left-handed bats and a separate one with five right-handed bats. Both lineups would yield a formidable top and middle of the order and would still have upside towards the bottom with Wells and McMahon’s power and Rosario’s hefty platoon splits.
In these lineups, the team would have the versatility to use its entire bench at the end of games. If the team isn’t completely sold on Rice’s defense, he can be subbed out in the final innings for Goldschmidt or J.C. Escarra, depending on the position. The same can be said with Caballero or Cabrera, whoever is on the bench, replacing Rosario, as while the lefty-killer does have versatility in the sense that he could spell one of the team’s starting outfielders at times and get reps at first and second base, he’s not strong defensively.
This 1-through-13 depth gives the team countless pinch-hitting, pinch-running, and defensive replacement opportunities, depending on the lineup they deploy on a given day. We haven’t even talked about potential fourth outfielders, Jasson Domínguez and Spencer Jones, who both flex elite speed if called upon, but unless there’s an injury, both could start the year in Triple-A. That’s how deep this hitting core is. And what happens after Volpe returns from his shoulder injury?
This overflowing depth gives the team some insurance options if/when players go down with injury. Stanton will inevitably hit the shelf for several weeks, but the fit is rather seamless with Domínguez or Jones (the latter presently much more of a long shot due to his contact issues) moving into the lineup at either DH or in the outfield and shifting things around. The same can be said if Judge, Grisham, or Bellinger goes down. In fact, with the signing of Goldschmidt, the only positions where an injury would cripple the team’s depth* would be catcher—due to forcing Rice into a much larger role—and shortstop, while Volpe is down.
*The caveat here is on Judge, since depth strength might only mean so much if you lose the best hitter in the sport to an injury.
It wasn’t even a year ago that the Yanks were playing games with a bench that consisted of multiple players who provided almost zero value to the team. Jorbit Vivas, Oswald Peraza, and DJ LeMahieu were not options to pinch-hit, and while Vivas and Peraza could pinch-run or sub in defensively, neither moved the needle enough to be on the roster for a playoff team. These are Triple-A emergency depth guys, who each team normally has anyway.
I’ve said in the past that running it back isn’t the worst thing in the world, and while the team could’ve upgraded at a number of positions (especially with the pitching staff), they’ll still be entering 2026 with maybe the best and most complete offense they’ve had since their last World Series title in 2009.
