The Minnesota Vikings’ 2026 quarterback competition is officially on, and the stakes couldn’t be higher. On the latest episode of The Real Forno Show, Vikings beat writer and NFL draft analyst Tyler Forness breaks down exactly how both J.J. McCarthy and Kyler Murray can win the starting job — treating it as a true 50/50 competition. The episode also unpacks what Minnesota’s reduced undrafted free agent spending reveals about the current state of the roster.
The QB Battle Breakdown
Forness pulls no punches when evaluating
McCarthy’s 2025 struggles. “He ranked last in EPA per play, success rate, and completion percentage over expected” in his first six starts, per advanced metrics from rbsdm.com. However, McCarthy’s final four games showed a dramatic turnaround — finishing fourth in EPA per play among qualifying quarterbacks — though Forness cautions those came against four of the worst defenses in the league. Kyler Murray, by contrast, posted top-15 numbers in EPA per play and eighth in success rate during his last full season in 2024, doing so with inferior weapons and a worse offensive line than what Minnesota offers. As Forness puts it, Murray is now being handed “a Rolls-Royce” in terms of skill position talent.
Key Points from the Episode:
- McCarthy’s path to victory requires three things: improved mechanical consistency (“his footwork would be all over the place”), faster processing speed, and better ball placement — he posted a 23% uncatchable ball rate, one of the worst marks in the NFL last season.
- Murray’s path is simpler but not guaranteed: “All Murray needs to do is show some improvement in mechanics, handle the offense, and just play like Kyler Murray can play — and I think he runs away with this thing.”
- Justin Jefferson weighed in publicly, saying of Murray: “just coming here with a new team and being that vocal leader. — That I feel like that’s the main thing that we’re looking for especially out of him, being more vocal, being that leader that we’re looking for” Forness sees this as Jefferson firing both quarterbacks up rather than a genuine indictment.
- The UDFA class tells a roster story: The Vikings spent only $1.408 million on undrafted free agents — down significantly from $2 million-plus last year. Three players — WR Dillon Bell, OL Tristan Leigh, and DL Monkell Goodwine — received $247,500 in fully guaranteed base salary, signaling they’re the most likely to make the roster or practice squad.
- Forness on the bigger picture: “The only bad aspect of this conversation is they both stink. We just want a quarterback that’s gonna help lead us to a Super Bowl.”
- Producer Dave Stefano noted Warren Moon publicly questioned Murray’s leadership and motivation, “I hope he’s learned over the last couple of years, with all the criticism he’s taken and the injuries he’s gone through, that he has to give more of himself to his football team. He has to show people more about what he’s feeling and thinking. You have to do that as a quarterback in order to get people to follow you.” Adding another layer to an already compelling competition narrative.
Listen:
Or on your favorite podcast aggregator.
Watch:
Why You Should Be Watching The Real Forno Show
If you want the sharpest, most analytically grounded coverage of the Minnesota Vikings — from film breakdowns and draft scouting to roster construction and quarterback debates — The Real Forno Show is essential viewing. Tyler Forness and Producer Dave Stefano deliver unfiltered, data-backed takes every week as part of the Vikings 1st & SKOL production. Subscribe on YouTube, leave a five-star review on iTunes, and ring the bell so you never miss an episode. SKOL Vikings.
Fan with Us!!!
Tyler Forness @TheRealForno of Vikings 1st & SKOL @Vikings1stSKOL and A to Z Sports @AtoZSportsNFL, with Dave Stefano @Luft_Krigare producing this Vikings 1st & SKOL production, the @RealFornoShow. Podcasts partnered with Fans First Sports Network @FansFirstSN.
Engage With Us
Do you think the Vikings’ QB competition between J.J. McCarthy and Kyler Murray is truly 50/50 — or is one of them already the favorite heading into training camp?
