In a day when the Mariners lost their starting catcher with Cal Raleigh going on the IL, Mitch Garver stepped into the role and had his best game of the season – on both sides of the ball – in an 8-3 victory. With that win, the Mariners not only secured a series win over the Astros, but guaranteed a winning season record over their AL West rivals.
It wasn’t just Garver contributing to the offense, though. The Mariners batters had seven extra-base hits, setting a season high, and seven of their eight
runs came with two outs. They had traffic in all but two innings, pounding out 11 hits, and struck out just six times while walking five times.
The Mariners offense staked Castillo to a nice three-run lead early, thanks to a leadoff Brendan Donovan double and then some two-out production: Randy Arozarena walked and Luke Raley got a fastball on the plate from Astros starter Mike Burrows that he did not miss:
I do not know why, in a 1-2 count, after Raley had swung and missed at a changeup previously and then fouled off another, Burrows then thought the next move was “fastball up in the zone to a man with arms that look like Douglas firs stapled to his shoulders” but I’m not upset about it.
For a moment, it looked like Luis Castillo was going to give all those runs right back. He got his first two outs before walking Yordan Álvarez, which, understandable, but then walked Isaac Paredes on five not particularly-close pitches. His command wasn’t much better to Christian Walker, although he was able to get Walker to fly out harmlessly to end the inning. But it came at the cost of his pitch count: 23 pitches in the first inning alone on a day when the Mariners bullpen was perilously short-handed.
The Astros had a little more life in the bottom of the second, but Castillo was bailed out by a baserunning error by Braden Shewmake, trying to make it from second to third on a Cam Smith infield hit right at J.P. Crawford (and then maybe bailed out again on a challenge that went the Mariners’ way). Castillo got out of that inning, and after that, seemed to lock in. He did give up a solo homer to Álvarez in the third, because Yordan gonna Yordan, but also struck out three in that inning, and then worked a clean fourth – again with some help from Garver, who made a clutch challenge to overturn ball three into an inning-ending strike three – and a clean fifth, this time with some help from a nifty snag by Cole Young.
Meanwhile, the Mariners hitters continued to stack offense for Castillo. With J.P. Crawford on board but two outs in the fourth, Burrows hung a slider to Garver in an 0-2 count—which again, feels like a bad idea when in his previous at-bat he’d hit a slider hard but straight to center, but hey, I’m not the professional here – and this time, Garver did everything the same (literally the exact same exit velo, 99.1, and actually ten feet shorter via Statcast – 369nice vs. 379) but yanked the pitch into the Crawford Boxes instead.
Rewatching that, I feel like 369 feels short as a measurement, but also, I delight in Mariners hitters making the homer-inflating Crawford Boxes work for them, so it’s a quandary. Perhaps as a certified Tall Person I should consult José Altuve on what it feels like to be short.
That homer gave the Mariners and Castillo some breathing room, but Cole Young decided to crack the window even further in the sixth after the two batters ahead of him had reached with two outs – Dominic Canzone on a single and Garver on a walk. Young fell behind 0-2 but laid off a changeup and a slider (good Cole!) until he got a sinker right on the plate he could smash into right field. A little adventurous fielding from Astros right fielder Cam Smith allowed seventh-percentile-sprint speed Garver to score all the way from first without a slide. (NB: If you’re watching this highlight at work or in front of delicate ears, mute it, because Burrows swears loudly and distinctly right after this pitch gets hit.)
That healthy lead let Dan Wilson roll with Castillo into the sixth, and it looked like it was going to be another inning of smooth sailing for The Rock despite a one-out Álvarez single. Again, Garver came up with a clutch challenge, flipping a count for Paredes from 2-0 to 1-1; Paredes would eventually strike out. But then Christian Walker refused to just strike out, instead working a nine-pitch walk. Trying to get one last out and maybe a quality start for Castillo, the Mariners opted to leave him in, and he left a fastball on the plate for Braden Shewmake to send to that tricky left field wall, scoring both runners. Nick Davila, making just his fifth big-league appearance, was called in to stop the bleeding and did, getting Brice Matthews to ground out.
Davila went on to deliver a scoreless seventh, working around a walk, and Domingo Gonzalez – now given a five-run lead after a J.P. Crawford RBI double in the eighth – worked around a leadoff double to, who else, Álvarez, and then capped things off in the ninth. Of his six outs, Gonzalez got two strikeouts and four ground-ball outs, which seems like a pretty useful reliever even if the Mariners’ infield defense is shaky on the left-hand side.
The Castillo-Garver battery isn’t the matchup most Mariner fans are most excited about this season, but today the supposed weak links of the roster gave what they had to this victory: Castillo, whose velocity was up a full tick on his fastball, hanging in there for 108 pitches; and Garver, calling a good game for Castillo (who doubled his changeup rate today, with some success – two of his six strikeouts were on the pitch), winning back strikes with savvy ABS challenges, showing patience at the plate, and punishing the mistake pitch he saw. Add in the bullpen performance from Davila and Gonzalez, two pitchers buried in the pile this spring training, and you have a solid win in a game that might have looked like a loss on paper. It’s especially weird because I thought this recap would be all about Brendan Donovan, who had three hits and fell a homer short of the cycle today, but the 2-4 hitters behind him today combined for just one hit and five strikeouts (Randy did walk twice, not trying to take anything away from ArOBParena). Huh, maybe RBI is an important stat.
