Even with the lockout looming over all the business of MLB these days, there are still some procedural moves that need to happen for the Phillies to get in compliance with certain deadlines. Today is one of those deadlines. By 6:00 PM this evening, this team will have to have selected those players that they would like to protect from the Rule 5 draft by adding them to their 40-man roster.
This can be both a blessing and a curse this year. It’s a blessing in that the team would be deeming these players
worthy of keeping around in case of injury, to prevent other teams from claiming them and for creating some necessary depth on their roster. It’s also a curse as when the lockout happens (I’m not even saying “if” any longer), those players that are still minor leaguers will not be able to participate in any baseball related activities with the team. They’ll lose training time at their respective complexes, contact time with necessary coaches and possible playing time if the lockout should stretch into the minor league season.
MLB Pipeline was kind enough to list their top prospects from each team that need protection, the Phillies being included in that list:
Bryan Rincon, SS (No. 4/MLB No. 96)
Aroon Escobar, 2B (No. 6)
Juan Villavicencio, SS/3B (No. 19)
Wen-Hui Pan, RHP (No. 20)
Mavis Graves, LHP (No. 26)
Assuming that these are the players the Phillies would be willing to protect, let’s preview each of them and their chances of actually getting protected by the team ahead of that 6:00 PM deadline.
Bryan Rincon – Rincon is probably as close to a lock as there is to being added to the 40-man roster. His prospect profile took a huge jump this season, boosting him to the point where there was actually some talk about his getting looked at as a shortstop this season for the team in 2027. That’s probably a little extreme at this point, but his entering the spring as a possible Edmundo Sosa utility type player for the infield at some point next year is completely on the table. If he hits in Lehigh Valley whenever he starts his season, his defense will have him in Philadelphia in short order.
Aroon Escobar – Escobar is also another one that will be added, though his addition is little shakier than it was at this time last season. He did not have a good 2026, posting a .667 OPS over 569 plate appearances and seeing about all of his important things in hitting taking a step back. The lack of quality hitting prospects in the team’s system gives him some safety, but this isn’t as secure as it should have been.
Juan Villavicencio – Villavicencio had a really good start to the 2026, hitting .298/.383/.570 in 304 plate appearances in Clearwater before falling off dramatically upon promotion to Jersey Shore (.213/.338/.311 in 145 plate appearances). One could have blamed some of that fall off to being worn out by a long season as the 449 plate appearances he had on the year were by far the most he had seen in his career, but there was an element of seeing better pitching exposing some of his flaws. His being 21 years old means teams would probably pass on him if they had a chance to add him to their big league team, so leaving him off the 40-man for another season is probably a safe bet for the team.
Wen-Hui Pan – Pan is an interesting decision. It’s likely he is not added, but he has put himself on the map as someone who could make things tough later in the season. He took enough of a jump coming back from Tommy John surgery in 2026 that the team should be excited for his development. His splitter is a plus pitch that can get outs and his velocity is good enough that he can pair the two for a good strikeout rate. If he’s not added to the 40-man, he’s definitely someone a lower tier team like the Rockies or A’s would take a chance on if given the opportunity to draft him in the Rule 5 draft. Does that make him someone the Phillies protect?
Mavis Graves – Even with the team’s lack of left handed relief pitching options they possess in the upper crust of the minor leagues, keeping Graves does not seem like something the team would do. While Graves did have some success upon switching to relief full time once he went to Reading, there simply isn’t a track record enough to guarantee that same success just yet. While all teams need cheap relief pitching of some kind, it’s doubtful anyone is giving Graves the leash long enough to stay on a major league roster should he be drafted in the Rule 5 draft. If he were drafted, it would be a better bet that he was returned at some point to the Phillies. It’s tempting to keep him on the 40-man, especially in place of some of the current dreck that occupies the lower spots, but those players are there to be dropped for better additions than Graves.
These are the just the players that are on the Pipeline top 100. There are plenty of others that at least stand a chance to have themselves considered for addition.
Kehden Hettiger – Catchers are always given a shot during the Rule 5 draft and it’s possible someone takes a shot at Hettiger. The Phillies have other catchers that they are signing to minor league deals, so them protecting Hettiger is a longshot.
Keaton Anthony – The perpetual holder of the “give him a shot” crown, Anthony, as a young corner infielder, might see a team choose him in the continued search for cheap power. With the Phillies, that shot is not going to happen anytime soon.
Raylin Heredia – Heredia has really done nothing but hit at every level he has played at, but he hasn’t ever found a home defensively. Even the hitting he does do isn’t really impactful enough for the team to give him a shot as he is almost allergic to taking walks. He’s a fringe guy at best.
Estibenzon Jimenez – Jimenez was exposed to the Rule 5 draft last year and saw teams pass on him, so there really is no fear that he’ll be selected again. He was better in 2026 across three levels, but he’s still a JAG at this point.













