Heading into the spring, Jasson Domínguez was the consensus pick for the Yankees’ fourth outfielder spot, as the former top prospect, now headed into his sophomore season, would be the team’s number one option in the event one of Cody Bellinger, Trent Grisham, Giancarlo Stanton, or — baseball gods forbid — Aaron Judge had to miss significant time. As the roster currently stands, the Martian, despite being optioned to Triple-A Scranton, remains in that role, and in truth, it would be very surprising
if he did not receive a call to the Show at for some extended run at some point this year; injuries are just a fact of life in baseball, after all.
But, as our very own Estevão wrote earlier this month, “Organizational depth and a quality bench…don’t necessarily mean the same thing.” Ever since the Yankees signed Randal Grichuk to a minor league deal with an invitation to spring training late last month, it immediately became the expectation that he would be given the fourth outfielder job out of spring training, and that the Martian would return to Scranton to start the season — an expectation that became reality this week.
2025 Stats (Arizona, Kansas City): 113 games, 293 plate appearances, .228/.273/.401, 9 HR, 27 RBI, 18 doubles, 82 wRC+, 20.8 K%, 5.8 BB%, -2 Defensive Runs Saved, -2 Outs Above Average, -0.4 fWAR, -0.8 rWAR
2026 Projections: 32 games, 140 plate appearances, .242/.295/.419, 5 HR, 17 RBI, 98 wRC+, 0.3 fWAR
Just a few short weeks ago, Estevão broke down the decision to sign Grichuk, and in the process of that piece he discussed reasons to both be optimistic about the veteran this season (such as his 92.4 mph exit velo last season) and to be, well, not so optimistic about him (such as his “predictable unpredictability”). Rather than treading over that same ground again, I’d instead like to talk about what the thought process behind the decision is, what the exact role Grichuk is expected to fill, and what are the possible ways his time in pinstripes may go.
The decision to option Domínguez and roster Grichuk has been met with skepticism around the Yankees online community, and for good reason. The organization has, in recent years, oscillated between playing the kids too much (see: Volpe, Anthony) and running out clearly washed veterans in lieu of letting the kids play (see: Verdugo, Alex and Kiner-Falefa, Isiah). Viewed from that vantage point, this move seems to be just the latest in a long line of overcorrections by the front office.
In this instance, though, there’s one variable that separates Grichuk from Verdugo and IKF: Grichuk is not in line to start, and is a platoon bat at best. Unlike Oswald Peraza and Volpe in 2022 and Domínguez himself in 2024, the young kid is not being blocked; there isn’t a starting job available. A much better comparandum would be 2012, when the Yankees optioned Francisco Cervelli to the minors and had Chris Stewart serve as their backup catcher, in order to have the young catcher receive regular reps. Had starting catcher Russell Martin been injured for an extended period of time, however, it would have been Cervelli filling in as the starter, not the career backup in Stewart. When/if an outfield or DH spot opens up due to injury, Domínguez is certainly slotting into that spot in the lineup.
So why is Grichuk here, rather than having the #NextManUp on the active roster to begin with? Because Grichuk, at least in theory, brings something that Domínguez has not yet shown in practice: the ability to hit left-handed pitching. As of today, the FanGraphs Depth Chart lists Trent Grisham as the Yankees’ starting center fielder, putting him in a platoon with Grichuk. According to their projection, against left-handed pitching, Grisham will sit, Bellinger will slide over to center, and Grichuk will man left. This tracks with the Yankees’ stated intention to factor in platoon matchups more this season — and it is something that, the way this roster is currently constructed, does not benefit Domínguez, as his platoon splits to date are comparable with Grisham’s. Grichuk, at least in theory, brings something different to the Yankees’ bench and gives Aaron Boone some flexibility.
Of course, what if it doesn’t work out? At this stage, it’s hard to say for certain, as despite having a reputation for holding onto aging vets for too long (e.g., DJ LeMahieu and Aaron Hicks), the Yankees have in recent years been willing to pull the plug on an experiment that clearly wasn’t working (e.g., Jay Bruce, Opening Day first baseman, and Enyel De Los Santos, trade deadline bullpen acquisition). The Yankees only have $2.5 million invested in Grichuk, and no sentimental attachments (in fact, given his performance against the Yankees over his career, they might have negative sentimentality). If Father Time has indeed caught up to the 34-year-old, it shouldn’t be too painful for the Bombers to move on.
Hopefully, though, it won’t come to that, and Grichuk quiets those disappointed in his arrival.
See more of the Yankees Previews series here.
