On a scale of 1 (Harry Frazee) to 5 (Theo Epstein), how would you rate Craig Breslow’s last 12 months?
3. Breslow did something which is more than the nothing we endured for several years. Maybe that something isn’t the something you wanted, but it’s more exciting than nothing.
— Jacob Roy
4. Caleb Durbin brings elite defense, a little power, and speed on the base paths to third base. However that does mean you need to “replace” the traditional third base bat. If Curtis Mead can bring that to second base you might have done it. Same with Adley Rutschman at catcher. He’s literally doing the Moneyball
“replace in the aggregate” meme. Ranger Suarez remains a strange signing but he made early and the other pitching prospects expendable.
— Mike Carlucci
4. I give him an extra point for getting out there and doing something, as Jacob already said. He didn’t do all the things he said he was going to do, but these past 12 months have been an improvement, and I’ll take it.
— Maura McGurk
Can’t believe I’m typing this. But it’s at least a low 4 for me. The guy simply knows how to dumpster dive in a way his predecessor didn’t. And he brings in All-Star level talent. Even when he’s not bringing in All-Stars, he’s trading guys that kind of suck to give away but bringing in guys that really rule to have on the team. The Jake Bennett trade looks incredible so far. In a vacuum, trading away Kyle Harrison sucks. But Caleb Durbin is a good return and a guy who could possibly stick around for years to come.
— Dean Roussel
3.5. The pitching and defensive infrastructure in place now provides a good bedrock going into 2027, and I like that a lot of the core is under team control. The outfield logjam situation continues to be something that could hamper the team moving forward considering that one of those guys—either the one with a hand that’s currently busted or the guy who’s OPS was just 10 points higher than the area code of the city he plays in—was/is slated as the designated hitter. For a team that plays at hitter-friendly environments for the majority of its games, the pop in the lineup was not up to snuff. Still, I don’t hate what I’ve seen.
– Fitzy Mo Peña
2. “It would be fair to look at some of those other teams [still in the playoffs] and say that they hit the ball out of the ballpark a little more than we do,” said Craig Breslow on October 6th, 2025. Sure, Breslow found a way to put a very strong product of pitching and defense out on the field in 2026. I would argue that when you spend 29 of your 41 draft picks on pitching in your first two years running the show, and then pivot last offseason from spending on free agent hitting to spending on free agent pitching, you better have a great pitching staff. Unfortunately, that’s only half the game, and Breslow admitted as much a year ago but never came close to fixing the problem with hitting for power. The in-season, intra-division overpay for Adley Rutschman, with just one year remaining on his contract, was curious and has left the team with a below-average farm system. If the Red Sox didn’t make the playoffs in 2026, I would’ve been in favor of moving on from Breslow. Instead, because of a fantastic 37-game stretch in the mid-summer, the team inexplicably picked up all of his options, and he is now signed through 2030.
– Bob Osgood
3. Breslow rates at a midpoint of extremes. The pitching development and identification is about as good as we’ve ever seen with this franchise. The problem of course is the offense looks about as bad as we’ve ever seen. They not only ranked dead last in September in runs scored, but they were 17 runs below the 29th ranked team. You could argue Breslow deserves a 4 if turns out he just had horrible injury luck. It’s not impossible we’re sitting here next September and (hopefully) October with pieces of the same general lineup raking (Contreras, Anthony, Rutschman and Mead come to mind). However, an argument could also be made for a 2 with how utterly unprepared this team looked for a series in New York they were apparently studying up on for about a month. That and no playoff baseball at Fenway Park for five years and counting is a massive failure!
For now I land in the middle, but there’s pretty strong forces pulling from both sides.
– Matthew Gross
3 — I’m with Matt in the middle. Here’s something kind of nuts: Only 2(!) of the top-10 Red Sox players by fWAR this season were brought into the organization by Breslow’s predecessor Chaim Bloom (Wilyer Abreu and Garrett Whitlock). And the 7 who were brought in by Breslow (Dombrowski brought in the 10th player, Ceddanne Rafaela) were all acquired within the last 2 seasons. That’s the only stat you need to understand just how much damage Bloom did to the overall talent base in the organization, and just how big of a hole Breslow had to dig this team out from. The fact that he brought in so much talent so quickly and ruthlessly, especially on the pitching side, is a credit to Breslow.
But Breslow not only fell totally flat in achieving what was his stated goal at the outset of the 25-26 offseason (adding power to the team), but the failures that are on his resume are of the spectacular variety, e.g., Rafael Devers and Alex Bregman would have finished second and third on this team in wRC+.
— Dan Secatore
On a scale of 1 (Bobby Valentine) to 5 (Terry Francona) how would you rate Chad Tracy’s performance?
3. I don’t know how much a manager really influences wins on a day-to-day basis, and I don’t love how he managed the first playoff series of his career, but he was in charge during a historic turnaround, so he deserves some credit.
— Jacob Roy
2. This is really hard and I dislike 1-5 scales because 3 feels like cop-out but I see him at just a tad under 3 on a 1-4 scale. These were his first two playoff games and the roster was on fumes. Going to Erik Miller after taking out Tolle? Ok, we all saw September, but it wasn’t not the worst call ever given the rest of the bullpen. Miller again in Game 2 and then not having anyone warming up from the moment he brought in Garrett Crochet — who was not 2025 Garrett Crochet — really sank the ship. What was the point? I get that if you used Chapman or Whitlock in that moment Crochet might have to be the setup guy, but that’s playoff weirdness.
— Mike Carlucci
2.5. Maybe the recency bias of the Wild Card is looming too large right now, and unfairly canceling out the historic summer this team pulled off. But he looked like he was in completely over in his head in the playoffs. I didn’t love the way he managed throughout September either, resting guys and taking it easy. (Part of that was the math of the playoff system, and he rested guys because he could.) But I kept thinking, well, he knows what he’s doing; he must be getting them ready behind the scenes, gearing them up for what’s coming. But they never stepped on the gas again, and I think he owns a lot of that.
— Maura McGurk
3.5. I was not an Alex Cora fan, and the proof is in the pudding with multiple last place finishes. The “we just have to play better” retort drove me crazy to no end and it was getting more prevalent as his tenure went on. Tracy buys half a point simply by describing what went wrong in losses. But this isn’t about Cora, and Tracy turned around a team that looked awful and gave them spark. I am a bit sour on Tracy, as I’m sure much of this writing team is, for inexplicably pulling Gray in the game that decided the Red Sox’s fate, especially when it came to allowing Erik Miller to implode for the second time in 24 hours. I said this about another manager last year: when Aaron Boone out-manages you, you’ve done something direly, direly wrong. But, if management decides that having platoon guys on the roster in an everyday capacity is something that needs to happen, there was no better move than making Chad Tracy, Triple-A manager and a guy with experience with a lot of these young guys, the manager for the 2026 season. Jury’s out on 2027 and beyond.
— Dean Roussel
3. That was a really bad Wild Card series in New York for Tracy, but I still think he’s the guy moving forward. He’s got a good amount of experience with the young core dating back to his time in Worcester, and he was clearly doing something right during the summer. Maybe that stinker in the Bronx is the best way for him to adapt. To quote the modern day philosopher Bigtime Tommie, “In school, you are given the lesson first, then the test. But in life, you are given the test, and then you learn your lesson. That’s the old school way.”
– Fitzy Mo Peña
3. This felt closer to a 4 after the regular season, but it was not a good postseason for Tracy. Whether the pitching decisions would have mattered due to the Red Sox ineptitude at the plate is beside the point. Tracy went 77-58 at the helm after Alex Cora was fired, which has to count for something, and he still feels like the right guy for this somewhat younger team. With some postseason experience under his belt, hopefully he is more prepared the next time around.
– Bob Osgood
3. I loved most of Tracy’s regular season and how he works with the guys in the clubhouse in general! At the same time though, I detested everything about those two games in New York and all the BS that led up to it. The energy level around the team going in, the decisions to pull both Gray and Tolle when they were a strength of the team all year, the decision to lean so heavily on the bullpen when injuries, slumps, and general wear and tear made it as weak as it had been all year, and the fact he kept putting Roman Anthony in the lineup every single day down the stretch when we now know he was still fighting through his hand injury. All of that was disgusting! It’s funny, when Tracy first came up from Worcester after Alex Cora was fired, many people expected him to look like a guy who couldn’t handle moving up a level so abruptly. That never really happened in terms of regular season games, but it sure as hell did happen when the abrupt change was getting ready for a postseason game.
– Matthew Gross
Are you confident in the overall direction of the club?
I’ll say yes, but only because I’m giving grace for the amount of injuries sustained this season. With a deeper bullpen and a healthy lineup, maybe things go better. If next year plays out the same way and a hapless offense rolls into a road Wild Card series unable to score runs, I’ll be the first to say it’s time to clean house and go another direction.
— Jacob Roy
Yes. I don’t think the roster is perfect but it’s not a group that will go out and lose 9-0 every night. They’ll be fine in 2027.
— Mike Carlucci
Yes. There was a real run of bad luck injury-wise, and there’s still work to do on the roster, but this year showed me that there is a desire to work on it.
— Maura McGurk
I’ve always been sour grapes on this question, but yes. I think there’s some questions that loom large, as well as a lockout that looms larger, but for the first time in half a decade, I am confident in this team’s ability to field a playable team next year.
— Dean Roussel
Generally speaking, I think I am. This sentiment can absolutely shift if the proper levers are not pulled in the winter, though. Good pitching is in place, yes. Good defense is in place, yes. A fair chunk of guys can get on base, yes. But man, we have GOT to improve the power in this lineup. Hopefully Curtis Mead can offer a shot in the arm, but one Curtis Mead does not solve all of the issues. I’m gonna need more on top of that. What it is…well, I’m not paid to figure that out, now am I?
– Fitzy Mo Peña
Sorry for all of the negativity, but no. With $269M already committed in salary in 2027, it’s hard to see a top-of-the-market free-agent bat (in a pitiful free-agent class) coming in, and Breslow has traded quite a bit of the farm system out already. He’s going to have some tough calls with non-tender candidates (Jarren Duran?) and will need to get creative with improving the lineup. I’m very excited about watching Franklin Arias play in 2027 but am tentative after seeing how things have unfolded with Roman Anthony, Kristian Campbell, and Marcelo Mayer, albeit for various reasons. Between the Tim Healey article from June outlining club dysfunction and then listening to how the veterans spoke in the moments after the postseason ended, things feel pretty chaotic behind the scenes, and I’m not confident that anyone cares about “beating the Yankees” anymore.
– Bob Osgood
No! Compared to this time a year ago, I’m less confident in Garrett Crochet’s ability to stay on the field and be a reliable ace. I’m less confident Roman Anthony is going to win his battle with the injury bug and take his rightful place as the next exceptional Boston outfielder. And I’m less confident in the organization’s ability to specifically identify supporting cast members who are built for October pressure. Add in how much the farm system has been cleared out with so few results, and the future starts to look a whole lot dimmer. If the question is if I’m confident about the Sox’ ability to be mildly competitive going forward, or if the next five years will be better than the last five, then yes, I’m confident of the buoyancy in that boat. But given how poorly the club played outside of the 32-5 stretch this summer when 2026 was supposed to be THE year they took a huge leap, and my confidence evaporates. They need enormous gains internally to ascend to a championship level. Some of that will likely come from better health, but probably not enough.
– Matthew Gross
I am confident that the Red Sox are finally operating with a sense of urgency. But until we can be confident in Roman Anthony, it’s hard to be confident about the Red Sox future overall. Everything this organization has done since 2020 has been done with an eye towards developing at least one homegrown superstar. If Anthony’s wrist prevents him from reaching that level, they’re screwed.
— Dan Secatore
