Michigan has hit the bottom of the barrel yet again, this time with a 31-7 loss at the hands of the Oregon Ducks, dropping the Wolverines to a dismal 5-5 on the year.
Michigan’s offense was under new leadership with Jim Harding taking over as the interim offensive coordinator, but it was more of the same, with the group still struggling to string any sort of momentum together. Meanwhile, Jay Hill’s defense finally cracked after being dominant for the first nine games of the year, surrendering a season-high
31 points and 467 total yards.
With this trip to the West Coast in the books, here’s a closer look at how each side of the ball graded out according to Pro Football Focus in the loss.
Offensive team grades
Believe it or not, Michigan’s offensive grade actually went down from where it was last week, as the Wolverines scored a 52.9 on offense after being at a 59.0 last week against Michigan State. The passing attack was particularly bad, with a 32.6 grade, as both Bryce Underwood and Tommy Carr got extended playing time. Pass blocking was also an issue against Oregon’s tough defensive front, with Michigan registering just a 50.6 grade on that front, which was actually about a six-point improvement from last week.
Offensive snap counts (snap count / overall grade)
QB Tommy Carr (42 / 48.2)
QB Bryce Underwood (20 / 33.2)
RB Savion Hiter (36 / 67.3)
RB Bryson Kuzdzal (20 / 62.5)
RB Jordan Marshall (11 / 56.9)
WR Andrew Marsh (56 / 65.0)
WR Salesi Moa (50 / 53.7)
WR Travis Johnson (37 / 53.4)
TE Jalen Hoffman (42 / 56.4)
TE Hogan Hansen (22 / 58.5)
TE Mason Bonner (10 / 55.0)
OT Marky Walbridge (62 / 52.5)
OT Evan Link (62 / 57.6)
OG Nathan Efobi (62 / 61.7)
OG Manuel Beigel (56 / 61.9)
OG Avery Gach (14 / 60.5)
C Jake Guarnera (62 / 56.9)
What stands out?
Neither quarterback was able to establish any sort of rhythm in Saturday’s game, and it showed in the grades, with both Underwood and Carr being the two worst-graded players on the offense against the Ducks. It’s unclear why Kyle Whittingham and the coaching staff wanted to rotate the quarterbacks in-game as they did, because it would appear that the plan didn’t do anybody any good.
Running back Savion Hiter stood out as the best player in the offense with a 67.3 overall grade, aided by a 70.6 run grade and a 78.1 pass block grade. Hiter provided the lone spark for the offense with a 70-yard touchdown to open up the second quarter, Michigan’s longest play from scrimmage of the season.
On the offensive line, Manuel Beigel started at guard with Avery Gach serving as the rhino. Beigel actually was one of the positives getting the start on the inside this week, especially in the run game where he produced a grade of 63.1. However, he was a big liability in pass protection with a 45.6 pass block grade, while freshman Marky Walbridge also struggled at tackle with a woeful 20.9 pass block grade.
Defensive team grades
Statistically, this was Michigan’s worst game of the season defensively, but Jay Hill and his group have certainly earned some slack thanks to the domination they’ve shown in the first nine games. Furthermore, this was just the second-worst grade Michigan’s defense has received all year at 67.8, ahead of the 60.3 it received against Rutgers.
What went into that score was Michigan’s worst pass-rush grade of the season at 56.3, and that was apparent all afternoon as Oregon’s Dylan Raiola had plenty of time to sit in the pocket and find the open man. On the flip side, Michigan’s run defense got back on track, recording a 77.6 grade, its highest mark in its last four games.
Defensive snap counts and grades (snap count / overall grade)
DT Enow Etta (49 / 61.3)
DT Jonah Lea’ea (38 / 68.9)
DT Trey Pierce (28 / 70.8)
DT Bobby Kanka (4 / 69.8)
DE John Henry Daley (59 / 58.3)
DE Benny Patterson (31 / 72.3)
DE Dom Nichols (24 / 61.1)
DE Tariq Boney (17 / 67.0)
LB Troy Bowles (58 / 57.5)
LB Nathaniel Staehling (43 / 63.7)
LB Chase Taylor (38 / 47.8)
LB Aisea Moa (16 / 71.3)
LB Nathaniel Owusu-Boateng (4 / 32.3)
CB Jyaire Hill (61 / 55.0)
CB Smith Snowden (58 / 58.2)
CB Zeke Berry (55 / 72.1)
S Chris Bracy (65 / 68.6)
S Rod Moore (34 / 63.0)
S Mason Curtis (20 / 71.8)
S Jordan Young (15 / 63.5)
What stands out?
Although it was a bad performance overall by this defense’s standards, there were a few players who stood out positively. Benny Patterson was perhaps the biggest bright spot of the group, registering the highest overall grade of any player on the defense. He also played the second-most snaps of any defensive end on the roster, another sign that his role is growing on this team. Trey Pierce was also pretty disruptive up front despite just 28 snaps.
The secondary was the biggest area to nitpick the defense, with Railoa and the Ducks putting up a whopping 341 yards through the air and two Oregon receivers, Dakorien Moore and Jeremiah McClellan, both going over 100 yards. Jyaire Hill and Smith Snowden both got burned for long touchdown receptions.
On the brighter side, Zeke Berry impressed in coverage. Mason Curtis also got quite a bit of run at safety on Saturday with 20 snaps and performed well.













