As the offseason continues to plug along, we have not seen a ton of moves yet, even with the looming lockout. A couple big names such as Evan Phillips and Jake Bauers have signed. However, we have not seen a free agent frenzy just yet. That could change soon though, and the Nationals might be involved in this next wave.
The Nats have been connected to two arms in recent days that intrigue me. Dustin May and A.J. Minter have both been linked to the Washington Nationals over the weekend. Neither are
marquee, top of the market signings, but they are realistic targets with upside. Minter is an ultra reliable lefty reliever, while May is a younger free agent whose best years could be ahead of him.
First, I want to start with Minter because he is my favorite target of the two. Last season, the Nats missed slow heartbeat bullpen arms who knew what they were doing. That is exactly what Minter would provide. He has appeared in over 400 games, and has a track record of success. The 33 year old was linked to the Nats by Jon Morosi.
It has been reported that the Nats are unlikely to commit multiple years to bullpen arms. I think there is a chance Minter could sign a one-year deal, so he would fit the team’s parameters. He has had some durability issues the past couple years, but when he is on the mound, Minter is excellent.
Last season, Minter posted a 2.56 ERA in 48 outings with the Mets and Twins. His fastball velocity was down a tick after lat surgery in 2025, but his cutter heavy mix and elite control still meant he was effective. Last season, Minter only walked 4.3% of hitters. That type of command would bring a new element to the Nats bullpen.
Minter was homer prone last year, but due to the fact he did not allow many hits or free passes, most of those homers were solo shots. He does not have the craziest stuff or the biggest strikeout numbers, but Minter is reliable. The lefty would be a great 7th or 8th inning option for the Nats.
Lastly, he also has a ton of experience in the NL East. He pitched for many years in Atlanta and was effective with the Mets last year. It is worth noting that Kyle Schwarber is 1 for 16 against Minter and Bryce Harper is only 4 for 17 with no homers. A one-year $9 million deal makes a lot of sense for both parties.
The second option mentioned is a higher upside, but also more volatile target. When you think of guys with great stuff that have not put it all together yet, Dustin May is one of the faces you see. He has a bunch of high velocity pitches that move all over the place, but he has not lived up to his potential yet. Jim Bowden has connected May to the Nats.
Bowden is not the best source in the world, but I don’t think the idea that the Nats are going after May is unrealistic. His stuff and youth make him someone that Paul Toboni would like. The Red Sox also traded a surprisingly rich haul to get May at the deadline while Toboni was in Boston.
Last season was just a classic Dustin May year. He posted a 4.70 ERA in 145.2 innings, but flashed in some dominant starts. As usual, the underlying numbers were kinder to May than the surface level stats. He had a 3.63 FIP and 3.96 xFIP, which hints at middle of the rotation upside.
The fact he has been relatively healthy the past two seasons is also an encouraging sign for the 29 year old. We have seen profiles like this have a lot of success in their 30’s. Zack Wheeler is the perfect example of that. He spent most of his 20’s either hurt, or being slightly underwhelming. Despite that, the Phillies gave him a huge contract based on his upside, and he has been a Hall of Fame level arm in his 30’s.
May is not that good, but I think there is a very real possibility that his best seasons come in his 30’s. The league knows about this potential, so May will not be cheap. If I had to guess, May will get a deal in the 3-year $45 million range.
He signed a 1-year $13 million deal last year, coming off a worse season with more health uncertainty. He threw harder and had better underlying numbers in 2026 than 2025. Teams have also given up shockingly expensive returns for May at trade deadline’s, which shows his value.
It would be a risky signing for the Nats, but May has real upside. He is one of the few arms on the market who is under 30, and has developmental upside to unlock. That is something that I think will appeal to Paul Toboni.
There is only a couple weeks left before the lockout begins. I think the Nats will make several moves before then. Now, we have to wait and see what those moves are. AJ Minter and Dustin May are two realistic targets who have been linked to the Nats.













