Hard to have a better rookie season than the one the Guardians’ Parker Messick just had.
Messick threw exactly 200 innings, including the playoffs, a remarkable feat in itself for a pitcher who had only thrown 149 innings the season prior. During the regular season, he put up a 2.56 ERA/3.07 FIP, 9.32/2.37 K/BB/9 led by a fastball with a run value of 25.1 and a slider with a run value of 20.8 and a changeup with a run value of 3.1. The only bad spot for his performance was a disappointing playoff run where
he managed only a 3.95 ERA/3.98 FIP, pitching only 13 and 2/3rds innings in four starts.
Messick’s four-seamer and slider both measured with negative run values for the playoffs. He maintained his regular season velocity, but the arm-angle for all of his pitches was down 3 degrees from where it was in the regular season and his command was, likely as a result, diministed, resulting in a walk-rate around 6 per 9. I am tempted to say this decline in performance is probably entirely attributable to fatigue after a career high in pitches thrown. I am sure Messick and the Guardians’ pitching group are looking into why the White Sox and Rays were often able to get opposite field hits off of him, making contact on what were reliable swing-and-miss pitches for him in the regular season in big spots, and on how to make sure he maintains command even more consistently. It’s tough that he couldn’t carry his excellent performance through October, but he showed us he was a rookie, after all, at the end, and I can’t fault him much for being that.
With that said, he did have a nice game one start in the ALDS against the White Sox:
And there are many regular season highlights to relive:
Though Gavin Williams proved to be the staff ace in the playoffs, it was the rookie Messick who anchored the rotation consistently throughout the year. He finished second in Rookie of the Year voting and second in Cy Young voting and then got married this past weekend, so it’s been quite a November for the young lefty, as well.
The biggest reasons for Guardians fans to hope for a 2027 season is to see Messick and Williams try to get them to a World Series. I am confident Parker will put himself in position for another big year; now MLB and MLBPA just need to give him a shot to post one.













