Stats at a glance: Aston Villa (A) Premier League, 21/11/2026
Average home goals predicted: 1.25
Average away goals predicted: 1.125
Confidence of Roker Report’s writers: 4.9/10
Predicting a win for the Lads: 25%
Fun stat: Confidence in Sunderland’s chances against Villa is higher than we had for Chelsea at home (3.75/10)
Martin Wanless (Cautious Optimist) says…
Score prediction: Villa 1 Sunderland 1
Last time out, we got a win and performance that we’d needed for some time — now we need to show that wasn’t a one off and that we’ve rediscovered our drive and a bit of form.
Our early season results have meant
we simply must keep picking up points and we need to build on last week, not take another step back.
A point here would be a great one; hopefully we show the same desire we did last time out. If we do, we get something.
Key differentiator: The fella who’s got a flat down in Roker will stand out again.
Confidence: 3/10
Bold call: Sunderland’s goal to come from a set piece taken by a player whose name scores 20 or more in Scrabble.
Malc Dugdale (Scarred happy clapper) says…
Score prediction: Villa 0 Sunderland 0
Points are everything right now and after showing we can play as we did last season against Chelsea, I would like us to now show that we can go away and get a point by any means necessary.
Without Brian Brobbey up front. we may struggle to score against a very good Villa side, but with Nordi Mukiele at the back and Jules Ahoka in the middle, I’m hopeful we can park the bus and get a draw.
If the pace possessed by Wilson Isidor gets us a win, I’ll take that all weekend long, but the minimum is another point to get us to two points per game, and if we keep that up, we’ll be clear of danger before long.
Key differentiator: The rock at the back — Nordi Mukiele — will lead a mega defensive display.
Confidence: 5/10
Bold call: Mukiele for man of the match, but to get a yellow for his troubles.
Jack Howe-Gingell (Eternal optimist) says…
Score prediction: Villa 0 Sunderland 1
After a massive home win last time against Chelsea, I hope to see more blood and thunder against Villa andI’m hoping the shift we had is not a one off as I feel like our biggest misstep so far is not playing in that style so far this season.
I want us to play like Sunderland, not anyone else.
Villa will be a tough test but I think we’ll continue in a similar vein and pinch a win, to give us back-to-back league victories for the first time.
I really want Jules Ahoka to retain his place — I firmly believe to my core that he’s a generational talent, and I can’t wait to see what else he can offer.
Key differentiator: Our physicality. It made a welcome return last time and it’s tough to compete with.
Confidence: 7/10
Bold call: Granit Xhaka to be fit but Ahoka to retain his place.
“Champion” Will Jones (Heart over head) says…
Score prediction: Villa 1 Sunderland 1
Now that’s more like it!
Beating Chelsea 1-0 before the international break was a massive result, and hopefully the Lads have had a chance to recharge before another difficult away trip.
Villa are a strong side, particularly at home, but we’ll travel with a bit of confidence after that Chelsea performance.
I think we’ll have to be disciplined and take our chances when they come, but there’s no reason we can’t get something here. Another point away from home would be a decent afternoon’s work.
Key differentiator: Keeping Villa quiet in the opening stages and not allowing them to dictate the game.
Confidence: 6/10
Bold call: Granit Xhaka scores his first Sunderland goal of the season from outside the box.
Matty Foster (Pragmatist) says…
Score prediction: Villa 3 Sunderland 2
Whilst our result against Chelsea was brilliant, I don’t see us following it up with a win here.
I feel Villa have the quality to overcome us, but we’ll put up a good fight.
Key differentiator: Villa’s quality will be too much for us.
Confidence: 3/10
Bold call: We’ll score both of our goals within ten minutes.
![]()
Anthony Gair (Depreciating optimist) says…
Score prediction: Villa 3 Sunderland 1
I reckon we’ll play very well, but be brought back down to Earth with a bump to an Aston Villa side that needs to bounce back after their embarrassing draw with lowly Manchester United.
This result isn’t as negative as it appears, for me. We’ll give a very good account of ourselves and be largely unlucky when conceding.
Key differentiator: The wingers. If they run at the full backs with confidence, we’ll cause more of an issue (obvs).
Confidence: 8/10
Bold call: We’ll end the game on more corners.
Gary Winter (Glass almost empty) says…
Score prediction: Villa 1 Sunderland 1
Following a crucial win against Chelsea, we have some hope to carry into this game, providing we know our place in the short term and stick with the graft, fight, tenacity, and being hard to beat.
I have quite a few memories of draws at Villa Park and I’d certainly take one today.
Villa’s home form isn’t anything to be afraid of, with their only win coming against Manchester City. They’ve also conceded quite a few goals, so they can be got at.
Key differentiator: We just lost any momentum after beating Chelsea due to the international break.
Confidence: 5/10
Bold call: A goal scorer wearing an even number will be preceded by a goalscorer wearing an odd number.
![]()
Brett Lyons-Davis (Gut feeling guy) says…
Score prediction: Villa 1 Sunderland 2
We’re back, spirits raised by a battling and very much needed win over Chelsea.
Villa are up and down at the moment, beating City then dropping points to both Fulham and United recently.
I’m going for the “we raise our game v the big boys” approach for this one.
Key differentiator: We’re playing a team that conceded four to Man United
Confidence: 2/10
Bold call: All goals will be scored by players whose numbers are drawn in Saturday night’s lotto.
![]()
Last game thoughts…
That was more like it.
The win against Chelsea was the shot in the arm we all needed, including the players, and was probably the only thing that could keep Régis Le Bris from joining Michael Carrick in filling out his UB40.
We could’ve scored more; the game could have got away from us if certain things hadn’t gone our way, and maybe the biggest disappointments are the injuries to Brian Brobbey and Granit Xhaka, and the lack of another game until now to build on the win we needed so much.
We did OK away from home last season at some really tough places, so it would be fitting for the Lads to show that aspect of last season is still in our locker too.
Last game predictions…
The predictions for the game before the break were mixed, with only Jack backing the narrow win we got.
A couple of others got the odd point, but with our form changing of late it may get even harder to grab points in the predictions process.
Predictions table and standings
No change in positions post-Chelsea, but the battle for the bottom spot has warmed up with Jack getting a three pointer last game.
Work to do for Malc and Brett as well as Jack to catch up with mid-table or more.
How the points are awarded
Just a quick reminder of how we allocate points to our match-by-match predictions:
- Correct score = Three points
- Correct outcome (but not correct score) = One point
- Correct Bold Call = One point
- Possible deductions for repeatedly not submitting on time = a two-point deduction.













