If you’ve been around the Braves fandom for a while, you can probably think of at least a handful of minor leaguers whose performance prompted a clamor of “Call him up! Why isn’t he up yet?!” Many of those guys more or less faceplanted when they were eventually called up… if they were called up at all. Brewer Hicklen, though, fell into the category of, “He did alright” once he got called up to the big league club.
How Acquired
The spitting image of a minor league journeyman, the Braves signed Hicklen to a minor league deal
in the 2025-2026 offseason. Hicklen had been around various geographic blocks:
- Drafted by the Royals (2017)
- Traded to the Phillies for cash (2023)
- Minor league free agency; minor league deal with the Phillies (ahead of 2024)
- Traded to the Tigers for cash (2025)
- Traded back to the Phillies for cash (2025)
And then, as noted, minor league free agency and a minor league deal with the Braves.
What were the expectations?
Up until 2026, Hicklen had only gotten cups of coffee in the majors: four PAs with the Royals in 2022, 5 PAs with the Brewers in 2024, and four more with the Tigers in 2025. He didn’t do anything particularly exciting in those 13 tries, but… it was 13 PAs.
The bigger issue expectations-wise was that he had stopped hitting in Triple-A. Despite the lack of major league exposure, Hicklen had consistently hit well in Triple-A through 2024, but that performance had dipped across the Detroit and Philadelphia organizations in 2025.
As such, it was hard to expect anything but sub-replacement-ish performance, given his status as an outfielder that had most recently not even succeeded at hitting at Triple-A.
2026 Results
Hicklen functionally had two stints with the Braves in the bigs: two weeks in July around the All-Star Break, and then from late August through the end of the year. Before those stints, he was destroying Triple-A: through July 10, he had a 131 wRC+ for Gwinnett; he finished his minor league season with a 134 wRC+. Yeah, he outhit his minor league xwOBA a bit, but it was still a .350 xwOBA.
In the majors, he got a few starts when he was first called up, and straight-up raked in 21 PAs over five games, putting up a 200 wRC+ and a .355 xwOBA (that he outhit by over .100). He then shifted into a pinch-runner/defensive replacement role (nine PAs in ten games) but still held his own offensively (109 wRC+ with wOBA and xwOBA pretty much matching), and then got a few starts down the stretch with worse batting stuff (17 PAs in five games, .209 wOBA, .234 xwOBA).
Put all that together, and Hicklen got 47 big league PAs in 2026, putting up a .348 wOBA (120 wRC+, yay) and a .306 xwOBA (meh), while playing nondescript defense, mostly in right field. He got 0.2 fWAR for his xwOBA-outperforming efforts.
He struck out in his sole postseason PA.
What went right?
He got far more PAs than any team had ever given him before. He hit the ground running when first called up, and his batting line was pretty good, even if it was more fortunate than solid by the end — though it was still far too few PAs to say anything about his ability to hold his own in the majors. He also crushed minor league pitching, which is what got him those big league PAs in the first place, which was an important turnaround from his poor 2025 in Triple-A.
Though Hicklen didn’t get much exposure, he showed some nice building blocks in his PAs. Basically, he was reminiscent of those tools-over-performance prospects whose skillset was really aligned to the 2019-2024 PowerPoint Braves: he ran incredibly fast, he swung hard, swung often (especially early in the count), made relatively a lot of pulled air contact, and focused on quality of contact over frequency of contact. He did all this while barely chasing, which was weirdly impressive given how his swing was imbued with the essence of reckless abandon.
He had a few big hits as a result of his swing-first tendencies. Two that come to mind were his RBI double against the Padres, pushing a 2-1 lead to 3-1 in the ninth, and a different RBI double that did the same thing in the sixth. He didn’t really have a signature hit that turned a game around, but had two games with more than 0.06 WPA (though he also had three games with -0.06 WPA).
What went wrong?
Hicklen ultimately made so little contact, that you can see why he’s been in the minors for so long, even while dominating Triple-A. His z-contact rate was about 71 percent; league average is about 83 percent, and 71 percent is a bottom-five-in-baseball value among anyone with 50 or more PAs (and would be bottom-two behind Munetaka Murakami for anyone with 200 or more PAs). His o-contact rate was a hilarious 23 percent; league average is about 58 percent and was the lowest for anyone with his number of PAs or more. Hicklen’s approach was a refreshing change from a team that seemed unsure about what it wanted to do at the plate, and he somehow avoided chasing while being primed to swing swing swing, but he definitely hit the limit of how little contact you can make and still produce a useful batting line, and then blew right past it.
Some PAs emblematic of this issue:
- On July 12, in the PA that was his Braves debut, he came up in the second after Dustin May had walked the first two batters of the inning, and a bunt to move them over. He took a strike, fouled off a pitch, and then waved through a fastball in the zone for a strikeout. (The Braves only scored in the frame on a wild pitch, which tied the game. They won by a run late.)
- On July 21, he struck out three times (and walked once) in a blowout loss to the Padres. Those strikeouts included a three-pitch strikeout with the bases loaded and two out where he represented the tying run in the sixth (fouled off a non-strike, whiffed on a non-strike, whiffed on a pitch in the zone), and two where he fell behind by taking strikes and then waved at strike three.
2027 Outlook
Hicklen remains with the club, hanging out on the 40-man roster. He projects as a 0.5 WAR-ish fifth outfielder right now given his speed and not-awful-in-total 2026 batting line, plus his minor league performance. The Braves could probably do worse given their propensity to carry bench guys that don’t play and wouldn’t offer anything if they did, but he’s also out of options, which limits their flexibility. They could opt for a guy with more roster flexibility, or a guy with a better projection (like a 1.0-1.5 WAR outfielder) for the spot instead.
I do kind of hope they hold on to Hicklen in some capacity, because even if the team veers further away from “swing hard in case you hit it” and “elevate and celebrate,” he’d be a nice throwback whenever he shows up — even if he may be addled in the contact department.













