The older you get, the easier it is to think four, five years ago wasn’t ancient history. I still have the same phone, same laptop from 2022, for instance – the same desk chair, car, house, backpack. But watching Wednesday evening’s contest in Great American Ball Park between the Cincinnati Reds and San Francisco Giants was enough to make one realize just how long ago the promise of the early 2020s Reds really was.
Tyler Mahle, who was dealt during the 2022 teardown to Minnesota for the likes of Spencer
Steer and Christian Encarnacion-Strand, was back on the mound in GABP to face the Reds. He was doing so as a Giant after he’d been a Twin and Texas Ranger in between, a nomadic post-Reds trip that shows just how fickle the business of baseball can be once injuries begin to tear away at your fabric.
Mahle was the vet in this one, the one whose velocity is down and pitch-mix is new as he works to figure out how to pitch once rearing back for a couple extra miles per hour isn’t in the cards any more. Sharing the mound with him was Rhett Lowder, who was a 19 year old pitching for the Strasburg Express in the Valley League of collegiate summer ball during the same 2021 season when Mahle posted career-bests in bWAR (4.9) and IP (180.0) with the Reds.
And it was Lowder who was in command.
Cincinnati’s righty exited after going 6.2 IP, his longest outing yet in the big leagues. He’d allowed 2 ER while on the bump, though Brock Burke did allow one inherited run to score once taking over in the 7th. It was an effective, efficient 90 pitch outing for Rhett, who limited hard contact for the most part and threw all of his pitches all over the strike zone.
The same could not be said for Mahle, however. He spiked a handful of balls in the dirt, walked 5 batters in his 4.0 laborious IP, and left enough pitches over the heart of the plate for the Reds to not just homer four times off him, but post some tape measure shots in the process.
Neither of the 3-run blasts by Sal Stewart were tape measure, truly, as both only flew into the first few rows of GABP’s small confines. Still, they were lasers off the bat on pitches not exactly right down the pipe, both coming on swings where Stewart’s elite combination of hand-eye coordination and reaction time allows him to put his own unique swing on each pitcher’s pitch and still find ways to barrel them. Both were also to right-center, in case anyone’s worried whether or not he’s a step-in-the-bucket rookie who’s just thriving on pulling the ball.
(He’s tonight’s Joe Nuxhall Memorial Honorary Star of the Game, by the way. He was a senior in high school down in Florida during Mahle’s brilliant 2021.)
Similarly, Eugenio Suarez (3 for 4, HR, R, RBI) poked a slider the other way for a homer on a pitch Mahle left up, a good piece of hitting as opposed to just running into one that missed in a hot zone.
Elly De La Cruz, though, hit the snot out of one. He launched a 442 foot homer to straightaway CF off Mahle, a true tape measure shot from the left-side of the plate as he reminded us that, despite recent success hitting righty, it’s him hittin’ lefty that’s the show-stopper.
All told, it was a brilliant night of baseball for the Reds, who won 8-3 and moved to 11-7 on the season. They claimed the series win over San Francisco, as that ends tomorrow at 12:40 PM ET with Chase Burns on the mound. They also made the iffy-hamstring issue that closer Emilio Pagan is dealing with a moot point for a night, as their offense finally kicked it into gear enough to make needing a closer not really a thing.
